Enter Sweepstakes! · Advertise on this site · Get Bargains
You are here:  About > Jobs/Careers > Librarians and Library Science
an About site
 One of Over 700 Sites
Your Guide with Guide
Tim Wojcik
Bio | Contact

Access Issues
Academic Libraries
Business Partners
Clip Art
Filtering Software
Internet Resources
K-12 Media Centers
Libr on the Edge
Niche Resources
Online Forums
Public Libraries
SLIS - A to M
SLIS - N to Z
Social Response
Special Libraries
U.S. Government

Subject Library 

All articles on this topic

Find books related to this topic Click Here

Find videos related to this topic Click Here

Your favorite products, right here Click Here

Stay up-to-date!
Subscribe to our newsletter.

Do you like our sites?
Wish to share them with others - and earn money?
Become an Affiliate

More Sites On This Topic
Apply to become
a partner
for this site.

Search for 
in   Sites A to Z
  The First Amendment In-House: A Librarian's Work in Practice

Policy #4 of the Library Bill of Rights reads "Libraries should cooperate with all persons and groups concerned with resisting abridgment of free expression and free access to ideas."
So what about the librarian's freedom of expression in the workplace? In the library.

Librarians are taught that they have a special responsibility to protect intellectual freedom and freedom of expression for all ideas, be they popular or unpopular. One would infer that this sense of mission to protect freedom of expression would naturally osmose to the organization in which librarians work. One would think.

Librarians do demonstrate a remarkable tolerance for a wide variety of ideas. However, library organizations exhibit the same nature as any other group of human beings: the need for control and the need to control. And, library functions such as cataloging and circulation have less tolerance than average for variation. Per the catalog number, a title belongs in only one place. And per authority rules, a title has only one catalog number, etc., etc.

Besides business functions, however, is a library organization likely to be more tolerant or less tolerant of the free expression of ideas?

Among the many variables affecting an organization, three crucial factors are: the personality of the director, and the pressure of outside events, and legal considerations.

The Director - Easy going, urbane, and witty. Micromanaging, petty, and unforgiving. Directors can be either. Or a mixture. And timing is also involved. A director who is looking ahead to their next assignment is likely to be more tolerant of ideas since they won't be responsible for dealing with them. Alternatively, a leader near the end of their tenure is more likely to want a steady course, and avoid risks, to ensure a smooth landing into retirement. No new ideas, thank you.

Or, there are times when the library is rolling out a new program or initiative and the director needs to work out the wrinkles before making a judgment. A director who would otherwise tolerate some dissent will probably not allow public second guessing. Veteran workers who are upset by change are likely to vent their frustrations. The director may have zero tolerance for these comments especially if the change is something that the director has a personal interest in having succeed. One example of timing from outside the profession was captured in the film "The Insider". The film depicts how the CBS program 60 Minutes is co-opted into altering coverage of a story due to the timing of its pending purchase by Westinghouse and the risk of a lawsuit by the tobacco industry upon the value of CBS to Westinghouse.

Pressures from Outside - These include the budget, the library board, the faculty, the provost, elected officials, or random events. A random event such as a child accidentally accessing a pornographic webpage on a library Internet computer can create a chilly atmosphere in the organization until the spotlight is turned off. An overbearing library board can make an otherwise well balanced organization react with tightlipped control. A crusading elected official who is on a mission to cut costs or purge public places of bad influence will make a library organization a monosyllabic environment.

Legal Restrictions - The right of employers to command "subordination" from their workers is still a given. However, the right to pursue intellectual matters while in a government's employ can also be restricted. The USA Court of Appeals recently ruled in Urofsky vs. Gilmore that professors employed at state universities can have their access to the Internet restricted while at work. While this issue revolved around accessing sexually explicit material, the legal point made is that the government has a much greater authority to abridge freedom of speech while acting as an employer than it does while acting as a governing body. In fact, librarians are very likely to be employed by a governing body such as a county, municipal, or state educational unit.

Asking at the Interview - The job interview is a natural time to pick up a sense of the tolerance for free expression. A very normal question to an employer would be "What is your management style?" or "How does your organization collaborate on decision making?". Better sources for the straight scoop on freedom of expression would be from employees, or recent former employees. If vigorous intellectual freedom and expression is that important, determining the tolerance up front is necessary. In fairness to the organization, they deserve to know a bit about the nature of an employee as well. Some libraries welcome vocal defenders of free speech.

All libraries should welcome strong defenders of free speech.

- - - - - - -

Thanks to Epinions.com and the Emory University School of Law website for links to their webpages.

Related sites:
25 Years of Collegial Management - Explores the model of revolving leadership at the library of Dickinson College in Carlisle, PA
University of Wisconsin School for Workers - Lists several examples of the School's efforts to mediate management and labor disputes
The Library Bill of Rights - a set of concise policy statements on the free flow of ideas which libraries protect

Subscribe to The Librarians and Library Science Newsletter

Sponsored Links
Lowest Prices at DealTime!
DealTime helps you find the lowest prices on the products you are looking for. Save time and money and let DealTime do the shopping for you. Click here now!
Personal answers to your questions
The web’s best source for answers to your questions. Over 5600 experts on topics from auto repair to computers, pets to taxes, fitness to health. Got a question? Find the answer at ExpertCentral.
Finders, Keepers, Online Auctions
The Internet's first destination for collectors, hobbyists and curious shoppers. boxLot.com is an integrated community complete with a premier auctions site, shopping, insights and events.
Tired of searching? Let your answer find you.
Get the answer you need, not thousands of search engine "hits." InfoRocket.com is the fast way to the right answer - guaranteed.
Enhance your Web Site
Make your site interactive with Polls, Guestbooks, Discussion Boards, and more. Our Free Site Tools are easy to create, customize and maintain.
Sponsor this site  

Create your business plan. Here’s how.

win millions!!
Just three easy steps can make you a millionaire!

Better Jobs for a Better Life

Win a piece of *NSYNC!
Head to Alloy.com for a chance to score your very own platinum copy of No Strings Attached!

single pixel
single pixel
casino online
- - free stuff - -
find a better job
quick jobs search
click for a job!
$$$$ win big $$$$
high paying jobs
post jobs here
low rates go lower!
meet your match
find a loan
home contractors
looking for love?
online trading
online casino$

Related sites
single pixel
on About 
Elementary Educators
Grad School Admissions
Literature - Classic
Secondary School Educators

Explore More On The About Network
Arts/Humanities ·  Autos ·  Cities/Towns ·  Comedy ·  Computing/Technology ·  Cultures ·  Education ·  Food/Drink ·  Gadgets ·  Games ·  Health/Fitness ·  Hobbies ·  Home/Garden ·  Homework Help ·  Industry ·  Internet/Online ·  Jobs/Careers ·  Kids ·  Money ·  Movies ·  Music/Performing Arts  ·  News/Issues ·  Parenting/Family ·  People/Relationships ·  Pets ·  Recreation/Outdoors ·  Real Estate ·  Religion/Spirtuality ·  Science ·  Shopping ·  Small Business ·  Sports ·  Style ·  Teens ·  Travel ·  TV/Radio · 
single pixel

For more information, visit
Our Story, Be a Guide, or Advertise. For rules of use,
read our User Agreement and
Privacy & Kids Privacy Policy.

Having a problem?
Report it here.

About Canada   ·    About UK

Copyright  © 2000 About.com, Inc.
About and About.com are registered trademarks of About.com, Inc.
The About logo is a trademark of About.com, Inc.
All rights reserved.