news.oneworld.net
guides: media democracy

options
news headlines this week's news events diary guinea yugoslavia ethiopia climate change imf & world bank digital divide education for all debt relief radio channel photo channel kids channel media channel tv channel editor's letter guides think tank africa south asia europe support centre join oneworld directory jobs volunteering shop principles organisation foundation centres supporters press contact us production
 

oneworld.net's guides aim to challenge and inform, questioning assumptions and suggesting alternatives on the subjects that really matter.

 

Media Democracy

 
'Two nuclear power plant manufacturers own two of our national networks - General Electric owns NBC, and Westinghouse now owns CBS. The other network is owned by a cartoon company: Disney owns ABC.' US Presidental Candidate Ralph Nader


image: CBA

Freedom of speech - Traditionally, many discussions of media democracy have focused on the right to freedom of expression. Particularly during the Cold War years, Western governments made much of state censorship in the Soviet bloc as a useful contrast to the supposed freedom of their own press. Yet although free speech is still a right denied in many instances across the world (as in the recent 'Gandalf' convictions by the British state), concentrating exclusively on that aspect has obscured issues even more fundamental to media democracy in many countries today.

Voice projection - For media democracy is much more than just 'being able to say what you like'. Media democracy is about voice projection - making yourself heard. While technology has made it easier than ever to publish your own magazine (or record your own video news), it has become ever more difficult to reach even the smallest audience with that material. Even if you can find a distributor to take it round to the tiny number of independent outlets still open and willing to stock it, the fact that you can't spend millions on advertising each year means only the hardened few will ever pick it up.

Concentration of ownership - In its more sophisticated form, censorship is achieved not through the police and prison systems but through capitalist institutions working together to maintain the hegemony of their beliefs. This is made even easier now that the majority of media businesses are owned by a tiny number of industry giants. Whether in individual countries or - increasingly - on a global scale, these cartels effectively control the images and stories through which we understand the world. Instead of a true democratic plurality, we are offered infinite versions of the same product (with slight variations in the packaging).

Keep it safe - This lack of variety has serious consequences, as it becomes increasingly difficult to voice alternatives to the mainstream media's orthodoxy. How much coverage was given to the hundreds of thousands in North America and Western Europe campaigning against their countries' assault on Iraq in the Gulf War? Restricted media democracy leads to restricted political democracy, as alternative ideas are deliberately kept away from public attention (especially if they might offend the advertisers).

Net power - If you're reading this you'll probably already know many of the hundreds of Internet sites offering alternative readings to mainstream media orthodoxy. The Net has clearly made such views more available than before, and acts as a democratic force in its own sphere by offering more equal voice power to the big and the small. The problem is: the Net still doesn't project far enough to challenge the power of the traditional media - just as the host of alternative magazines which have existed for years have never managed to challenge the mainstream. In this respect media democracy relies on all of us: it is our support and subscriptions that keep diversity alive.


Author

More links

Quotes

Y O U R   C O M M E N T S

Guides Co-ordinator Bry Lynas welcomes your views and suggested links

M O R E   G U I D E S

on related subjects:
> guides: human rights

F U L L   C O V E R A G E

For links to all related OneWorld stories:
> democracy
> freedom of expression
> globalisation
> human rights
> civil rights
> communications
> internet

O N E W O R L D   L I N K S

Last update: 19 July 2000

Mainstream media
Are the 'mainstream media' controlled by elites to advance their interests? asks Global Issues.


Tibetan media in a straitjacket
Censorship and intimidation is taking a tough toll on Tibetan journalists (TIN).


Media repression in Yugoslavia
The state crackdown against independent media in Serbia is gathering speed (Radio B92).


mediachannel.org
OneWorld.net's Media Channel keeps an eye on the global media.


Propaganda
New Internationalist looks at spin and propaganda.


Pan-African media watchdog
NDIMA (Network for the Defence of Independent Media in Africa) is a human rights NGO based in Kenya. It runs training courses for journalists


Media Institute of Southern Africa (MISA)
MISA believes that media freedom - and thus the free flow of news and information - is essential to social and economic development, and the development of democracy


A universal challenge
Engaging with the modern media machine (WACC)


Language and communications
This World Goodwill newsletter focuses on communications.


cyber-times.org
A Hong Kong-based forum for the exchange of information and the promotion of understanding across international boundaries


International Freedom of Expression Exchange
IFEX is a network of over 40 organisations which campaign against freedom of expression and press freedom violations worldwide.


Tibet Information Network
An independent news and research service providing information on and analysis of developments in Tibet.


Media as mirror to the world
To what extent do the media reflect the real state of the world? In Iran, Burkina Faso and Algeria, journalism is more concerned with the values of truth and rigour (Le Monde Diplomatique)


Pakistan Press Foundation
The PPF is a non-profit media research, documentation and training centre committed to promoting and defending freedom of expression.


Outfoxed by Monsanto
Corporate control of the airwaves (In Motion Magazine)


Cuba: what price press freedom?
Any public criticism of the government "summarily dealt with" (WACC)


O F F - S I T E   L I N K S

Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting
The news behind the headlines, what's wrong with the news and much more.


What are journalists for?
Does war drive the news? Are there 'facts' or just 'spin'? Who writes the news? Thoughtful analysis of the brave new world of today's media.


Reporting on the PR industry
The Center for Media & Democracy serves citizens, journalists and researchers seeking to recognize and combat manipulative and misleading PR practices


Adbusters
Redirecting existing commercial media culture towards ecological and social awareness. Good spoof adverts


What makes mainstream media mainstream?
Noam Chomsky talk to Z Media Institute


Media Watchdog
No longer maintained but still has a good list of resources