EDITORIAL CARTOON
Historic trial
THE IMPEACHMENT process that has started has brought some measure of
stability to the nation. It perked up the financial markets, causing the peso to
gain 52 centavos last Tuesday--it closed at 49.38 from Monday’s 50.35 to the
dollar--and making the stock market climb by nearly 14 points. Even on the
parliament of the streets front, there is an atmosphere of calm, although we
cannot predict yet what will happen during the Welgang Bayan on Nov. 27.
It is well that the majority in the House decided not to question the manner
of referral of the articles of impeachment to the Senate by then Speaker Manuel
Villar. A majority motion would have delayed the impeachment process and further
angered people who would like the proceedings to begin as soon as possible. The
majority also probably got a hint from President Estrada himself who said he
wanted the process speeded up so that he would have an opportunity to present
his side.
The Senate is also to be commended for agreeing quite quickly on a set of
rules of procedure for the impeachment. A delay would again have provoked
militant groups seeking the ouster of the President to hold more demonstrations,
rallies and strikes.
Everything seems to look normal now. But the start of the impeachment
proceedings should not mean a stop to the rallies urging the President to
resign. The two processes--impeachment and resignation--are not mutually
exclusive. The President still has the option to resign although the impeachment
process has started and although he has time and again said that he would never
resign. But the government should not crack down on people who want to continue
holding rallies and demonstrations calling on the President to resign. The
people have the right to speak freely and to peaceably assemble to express their
opinions and ideas.
Let us offer the following pieces of unsolicited advice on the matter of the
impeachment of President Estrada:
o There is a report that only the government station, PTV-4, will be allowed
to cover the impeachment proceedings. We urge that this plan be reconsidered,
and that all media outlets be allowed to cover the trial. The nation and the
entire world should be allowed to watch and monitor the proceedings through the
electronic and print media.
o The Senate will be converted into a court for the duration of the
impeachment trial. Proper court decorum should be observed during the
proceedings. This means that no public demonstrations of any kind--whether for
or against the President--should be allowed inside the hall. The Chief Justice,
who will preside over the trial, will have to enforce the rules strictly.
o A certain area outside the Senate, however, should be designated to allow
the pro- and anti-Estrada groups to present their sides to the Senate and the
people at large. A report that militant groups plan to serenade the 22 senators
with Christmas carols and send Christmas cards and a ‘‘12 days of Christmas’’
wish list to them looks encouraging. It could set a peaceful and
non-confrontational tone for subsequent demonstrations. The pro and anti groups
can disagree, but they don’t have to resort to violence.
o We hope the 22 senators who, together with the Chief Justice, will try the
impeachment case; the 11 prosecutors from the House; the lawyers for the
defense; the lawyers who will assist the two panels; the witnesses; and other
people who will be directly involved in the trial will not lose sight of the
objective of the process, which is to find out the truth about the charges. Let
us not resort to delaying tactics and convoluted technicalities to becloud the
issue. We repeat: the objective is to find out the truth, and it will be on the
basis of this truth that a finding of guilty or not guilty will be returned (or
so we hope).
President Estrada will go on trial during the impeachment proceedings that
will begin today. But it is not just the President who will be on trial. It will
also be the Senate that will be on trial. It will also be prosecutors and
lawyers of the prosecution and the defense who will be on trial. The
constitutional process of impeachment will also be on trial because this is the
first impeachment in the history of the Philippines. The entire nation will also
be on trial, in that we will see how people will behave and react to the
proceedings. The world will be watching us. We hope and pray that the Senate as
an institution, and the senators as individual members of that institution, will
always keep in mind that they will be setting precedents and making history as
they proceed with the trial of President Estrada.
|