Cameras | Reviews | Prices | Business | Help | News | Handhelds | Desktops | Notebooks | Downloads | Developer
Sm@rt Partner
Free Downloads
 
Gifts Grads Will Love
 
Find IT Software

 
ZDNet > Business & Tech > Sm@rt Partner > Can You Trust This Penguin?
 

 
Click Here!
 

 
Search For:            • Search Tips
• Power Search
 
 
 
arrow
Sm@rt Home
arrow
Breaking News
arrow
SP Opinions
arrow
Back Issues
arrow
Special Reports
arrow
Contact Our Staff
arrow
Advertising Info
arrow
Events
 
Click Here!

 
Also On ZDNet
 
ZDNet RC
 
Pick a Resource Center
 

ZDNet RC
 IT Product Finder
 Web Hosting
 Post an RFP
 CNET Tools for VARs
 
 
 
arrow
Apply for a FREE Subscription
arrow
Customer Service

 

 

Nov 1, 1999 Issue

Can You Trust This Penguin?

What's Wrong (And Right) With LINUX

By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols, Sm@rt Partner

Let's get real. we all know there's a ton of Linux hype out there. A day does not go by without another vendor declaring Linux support. But there's also a lot of fear, uncertainty and doubt about Linux. In this exclusive report, Sm@rt Reseller cuts through the hoopla and reveals where Linux plays best, and where its use should be avoided. Some of our findings--based on our internal tests and interviews with key Linux experts--may surprise you.

Certainly, Linux has momentum. Shipments of the operating system are expected to increase 25 percent annually through 2003, predicts International Data Corp. But those numbers can be misleading. Linux has yet to take root on the desktop and lacks many high-end features that Unix proponents take for granted.

Still, Linux has some clear strengths. With Samba for file serving and Apache for Web serving, it has proven to be a robust solution for file, print and Web servers. It's also an important operating system for network appliances, whether they are simple file servers or complete Internet solutions like Rebel.com's Net Winder OfficeServer, where stability and remote administration are top requirements.

Conventional wisdom says Linux is incredibly stable. Always skeptical, we decided to put that claim to the test over a 10-month period. In our test, we ran Caldera Systems OpenLinux, Red Hat Linux, and Windows NT Server 4.0 with Service Pack 3 on duplicate 100MHz Pentium systems with 64MB of memory. Ever since we first booted up our test systems in January, network requests have been sent to each server in parallel for standard Internet, file and print services. The results were quite revealing. Our NT server crashed an average of once every six weeks. Each failure took roughly 30 minutes to fix. That's not so bad, until you consider that neither Linux server ever went down. This test, coupled with our technical staff's extensive Linux and NT experience, leads us to believe that Linux truly is more stable than NT on uniprocessor servers.



Text continues...

Talkback:
2.4 will support large memory. ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 
"On low-powered, uniprocessor s... - Kirk Sanders
 
Linux 2.4 will support up to 64... - Oliver Henning
 
OpenSource benefits everyone. ... - Robert Flash
 
A check on the HP site shows Op... - Eric Fletcher
 
Just to dispel some myths here.... - Justin Penney
 
Correction: Linux has a journal... - Peter Bryant
 
LVM is available. If interes... - Mike Field
 
Might I suggest that the author... - Scott Marlowe
 
Hmm, looks like most of the wea... - Ben Wilson
 
Thanks for putting the the TCO ... - Sanjeev Sharma
 
COM APIs My Arse. To all of ... - Grega Bremec
 
TCO comparison is still wrong. ... - Ken Broadfoot
 
This story is a little old so a... - Kevin Forge
 
NT clusters only TWO computers ... - Scott G. Prive
 
TCO for Linux is a bit overstat... - Arne W. Flones
 
The lack of a common gui widget... - Michael Torrie
 
OK, Linux is good low end serve... - Roger Irwin
 
NT with SP3 is outdated since a... - Erik Putrycz
 
CODA for file sharing Althuo... - Richard Corfield
 
Your comparative admin costs ar... - Dave Fisher
 
IN defense of NT, I find it int... - Richard Hiltz
 
Ken Broadfoot had some doubts a... - Mike Avery
 
Clustering Software is availabl... - Neuroserve
 
OpenView on Linux is... shall w... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 
SANs JFSs, and so on. Yup, i... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 
NT4 SP3 are old. No one, not ev... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 
Where is BSD? This article igno... - Darby Daemon
 
TCO. Well, it's like this. ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 
Hmmmmm....something's wrong... ... - I.M. Batman
 
Here at a fortune 200 company, ... - Ralph Martelly
 
Sorry if this has been covered ... - John Frazier (Inprise/Borland)
 
I don't know about limited clus... - Paul Anderson
 
Always UP-OS/2Warp for Ecommerc... - David Kubit
 
It's already been said that NT3... - Da Dude Abides
 
If the NT server crashed every ... - Terry Mickelson
 
Since we're taking "wonderful" ... - Pat Chefalo
 
No E-mail address, location, an... - Joseph A. Klatt
 
Once again here you go .. WINDO... - Bubba
 
I have a Linux box at work and ... - Dave Winslow
 
Look at Freebsd at freebsd,org ... - Thomas J Starling
 
All this talk about Linux is go... - Darryl Lyle
 
NT Unstable? Easy to administer... - Eric Larson
 
Why aren't you running a Novell... - Ab Kurk
 
I like articles like this. They... - Tony Hall
 
You forgot to mention Macintosh... - Chris Briggs
 
I have WinLinux2000 installed o... - Annie
 
You need both for either server... - James Ottringer
 
The new SUSE is shipping with a... - Kevin Schaefer
 
X11 reduces TCO v-e-r-y much...... - Mark Aitchison
 
When the system can be as easy ... - Bryson Riordan
 
I did not see BeOS in the repor... - Tim Cox
 
Tim, BeOS isn't ready for the s... - Dan O'Bryant
 
After deploying numerous NT ser... - Anthony
 
I really appreciate the amount ... - Roy Nielsen
 
I just love all the hype about ... - JD Haas
 
I was reading the above comment... - Jim Dean
 
Rebooting NT.. I find it funny... - Richard Thomas
 
I've have seven NT machines run... - Tim
 
One of the earlier posts mentio... - Charles King
 
Why even bother comparing...Mic... - Eddie
 
I can't see why any server woul... - Dennis Achterberg
 
Can you trust Corel? Don't both... - Gergely Hajdu
 
check out staroffice! it does p... - peter lustig
 



 
 
Story Navigation
 
arrow
Can You Trust This Penguin?
 
arrow
Cheaper Than You Think
 
arrow
Linux's Holes
 
arrow
Fear Of Heights
 
arrow
Loose Links
 
arrow
What Else Did We Forget?
 
arrow
Desktop Linux?
 
arrow
Learning To Samba
 
arrow
The Bottom Line
 
 
Related Links
arrow
Caldera Takes Linux To The Next Level
 
arrow
Linux vs. Microsoft: The FUD Report
 
arrow
SCO and TurboLinux Join Linux Forces
 
arrow
A Linux and Windows Marriage
 
arrow
Microsoft Re-Fans The Anti-Linux Flames
 
arrow
Linux InfoPack
 
arrow
More Techno
 
 
Talkback
Have an opinion about this article? Post your comment on this page!

Sm@rt Tools
E-mail this story!
Printer Friendly

More on Sm@rt Partner
News / Opinions
Issues

Sm@rt Partner Update
Stay on top of all the news and special features by subscribing to our newsletter.

Enter your email:


or
Unsubscribe
Change Address






 Sponsored Links
SAVE $250  at University of Phoenix Online. Find out how.
CLICK HERE  PowerPoint® photos, illustrations, cartoons, templates
POWERHOUSE  Millennia MAX 933MHz&128MB SDRAM from $1749! Click here
Free $10  Brand Name PCs as low as $299! Handhelds as low as $85!
Books  Save with 1-Rate Shipping at Barnes & Noble.com!
GREAT PC  ClientPro Cn - 600MHz w/ 7.5 GB hard drive, from $1425!
 
 Everything Intel    Find Out More
It's FREE!   Buy a select Dellâ„¢, get a CD-RW or DVD-Rom upgrade! - Dell Small Business Center
Shop Now!   Gateway Home Computing Center - TOSHIBA
Shop Now   Gateway Business Center
 
 Featured Links
Best Buys  Shop Smart for scanners, digital cameras, monitors & more!
Free $10  Get $10 off your first order at Half.com. Laptops as low as $399!
FREE!  Get 50 free downloads, plus free email, voicemail & more
 
 Magazine Offers
FREE CDs  Click Here for your FREE TRIAL of Computer Shopper!
 

Tech Jobs |  ZDNet e-centives |  Free E-mail |  Newsletters |  Updates |  MyZDNet |  Alerts |  Rewards |  Join ZDNet |  Members |  SiteBuilder
CNET Networks: CNET | GameSpot | mySimon | ZDNet         About ZDNet 
  Feedback | Your Privacy | Service Terms | Advertise
Copyright (c) 2000 ZD Inc. All Rights Reserved. ZDNet and ZDNet logo are registered trademarks of ZD Inc. Content originally appearing in Sm@rt Partner Copyright (c) 2000 Ziff Davis Media. All Rights Reserved. Sm@rt Partner and Ziff Davis Media are trademarks of Ziff Davis Publishing Holdings Inc.