Dec 22, 2000 17:30 Hrs (IST)
As snow starts to settle in the northern hemisphere, a perennial symbol of the
festive season has been dismissed by a British academic as racist, sexist and
politically inappropriate for the 21st century.
For Birmingham University lecturer Tricia Cusack the snowman is unacceptably white
and male and his presence is "a reminder of masculine dominance, ordering and
surveillance."
Cusack's 15-page paper on the representation of snowmen in Christmas cards also
argues that they are "phallic symbols" which condemn women to second-class status in
society.
In the traditional setting of the front garden "snowmen symbolize man's domination
of the outside world -- while all women are indoors slaving over the Christmas
dinner in the kitchen," Cusack writes in the left wing periodical New
Formations.
"Is it accidental, in view of the Western narrative of active masculine domination
of nature/female, that out of virgin snow a male icon is built -- or erected?" she
asks.
"Some members of cultural minorities in Britain find the central power relationship
of Christmas threatening, not to speak of its whiteness -- a white Christ, a white
snowman," she adds.
Her answer is to create more "ethnic diversity" in snow people, so as to give snow
role models to the downtrodden.
On Thursday, one of Britain's largest Christmas card companies, Hallmark, said the
snowmen they displayed were neither racist, nor sexist. "We know from our research
that they're hugely popular with the public," said a company spokesman.
Children' author Raymond Briggs described Cusack's analysis of snowmen as sexist and
racist as "absolute rubbish." Briggs, the author of the popular children's book
The Snowman, added, "They are only white because snow is white and a female
snowman would be very difficult to do -- it would be very hard to model bigger hips
and breasts unless the snow was absolutely freezing."
"I would say my snowman is a non-sexual, non-racial being. It's got no sexual
characteristics and couldn't be other than white," he adds.
India Abroad News Service