I Was Almost a Stooge For National Plutocrat Radio
by Barry Crimmins
http://www.barrycrimmins.com
Sunday, February 23, 2003
On Tuesday afternoon (2/18/03),
I got a phone call from a representative of the National Public
Radio show On Point.
She told
me
she got my name from a friend of mine. She asked if I could do
a brief piece on the burgeoning field of aspirants for the 2004
Democratic
presidential nomination for a portion of the show called Radio
Diaries.
Because I am a professional and only torch bridges when absolutely
necessary, I refrained from telling her that I didn't need to have
my time wasted by NPR. Again. More often than not, when
NPR producers have asked me to write essays for them, they have
decided not to use them. Almost always this was because I didn't
come in
with
exactly what was in their mind's ear. A few year's ago
I recorded several commentaries at an Ohio NPR affiliate.
They
never
ran. I was
never paid
for
writing and performing them. I never received expenses for a few
rather long round-trips to do the work. Eventually it was explained
to me that the audio essays didn't run because I sounded too professional
to
give the commentary the authentic "regular person" feel
they desired. You see, as a long-time performer, I knew how to
sell what I said. They didn't think I sounded organic enough. And
so they
brought in other people who were easier to train to seem like they
were themselves.
On Point, a show that airs in a few dozen markets, emanates from
WBUR in Boston. I gained renown as a political satirist in that
town. I have written for the Boston Phoenix for years. I have
friends in the arts, academia, the media and the progressive
political community. I also know my share of cabdrivers, bartenders,
ticket-scalpers, construction workers and municipal employees.
I have received numerous awards for my community activism. I
started the first full-time comedy club in the Boston area in
1979. It is often referred to as the "fabled Ding Ho." A
lot of very talented people started their careers at that club.
The first film at the Boston Film Festival next month will be
Fran Solimita's When Stand-up Stood Out. It's about the early
days of stand-up in the Hub. Word has it I show up a few times.
If you do a Google search under the term "political satirist," at
least as of this morning, my website is the first place that
is suggested.I do not present this immodest collection of fact
for purposes of vanity but instead to expose the ineptitude of
NPR.
As ever, they approached me as if I were an unknown fledgling in
need of guidance. Within the first thirty seconds of the call I knew
two things: this woman had no idea who I was and what she wanted
me to say on the radio was utter pap.
Two years into the court-appointed Bush administration's destruction
of our way of life and the first call I received from NPR was a request
to belittle Democrats. Ostensibly they wanted me to make
fun of the fact that the field of candidates had grown very quickly
in recent
weeks. That's right; NPR was soliciting me to satirize democracy
for showing signs of vibrancy. And so this young producer tried to
steer me that way. She started by mentioning the size of the Democratic
field and then asked, "Do you think any of them has the stature
to take on George W. Bush?"
I said, "My dog Lloyd has
the stature to take on Bush." But then I allowed, "Of
course, I raised him myself."
We went back and forth and I said I could run down the field for
her. She reminded me twice that the game I was to bag was of the
Democratic variety. I said I'd put something together for her. I
requested a list of candidates in case I'd overlooked someone. She
sent the Dem roster and the next morning, I wrote the piece. They
had my script by midday Wednesday. I was supposed to tape it Thursday.
I figured if I got it in early, we could sort out any difficulties
with time to spare. Like I said, I'm a professional.
Here is what I sent them (minus a few typos and plus one slight change
in the Kucinich portion):
Radio Diary
Now that we have selected and ordered the hydrogen cars we will
be driving into the glowing future, it is none too soon to
begin considering
the field for the 2004 Democratic presidential primaries. Someone
asked me the other day if I felt any if the announced or potential
Democratic candidates possessed the stature to challenge George
W. Bush for the White House. When I regained my composure,
I realized
that my interrogator had queried in earnest. And so I began to
consider just who among the Democrats may be equipped to curtail
W's court-appointment
with destiny.
If the Dems nominate Connecticut Senator Joseph Lieberman, it would
set a precedent. With Lieberman on the fall 2004 ballot it would
be the first time a Republican faced a.....Republican in the general
election. Joe should do the honorable thing and challenge Bush in the primaries.
Dennis Kucinich, the firebrand congressman from Cleveland, Ohio,
gives great speeches and is a wonderful peace activist. He will
have to employ both of these gifts to keep himself out of a war
with fellow
Democrats over his sometimes-weak stance on reproductive rights.
The Reverend Al Sharpton lines up the most consistently with the
millions of Americans at the peace marches-- probably because he
is the only candidate to consistently attend peace marches. Nevertheless,
Sharpton’s primary opponents will likely be spoiling for a
Tawana Brawley.
Massachusetts Senator John Kerry says what Iraq needs is globalization
but has yet to explain how he plans to move Iraqi oil fields to
China. Kerry tells us he snookered Bush by voting for his war.
If he can
sell that to voters, he should have no trouble debating Dubya.
Senator John Edwards of North Carolina is running as the multimillionaire
of the people. His background as a trial lawyer may cause him some
tribulations. It’s fine when Dr. Bill Frist assists accident
victims with medical care but it is positively un-American to assist
the accident victim in recovering damages for trauma and debilitation.
Isn't it?
Regardless of what you may have heard, should former Vermont
Governor Howard Dean win the presidency, he will not hire
Tom Poston to be
the White House handyman. He may however bring along an agenda
that includes peace, health care and gay rights to Washington.
His opponents
may experience primary discomfort if they don't adopt the views
of this country doctor.
Former Illinois Senator Carol Mosley-Braun’s friendship with
the late and unlamented Nigerian dictator Sani Abacha might have
caught the eye of the Democratic Leadership Council, which is always
on the lookout for candidates capable of collaborating with natural
enemies of rank and file citizenry.
Florida Senator Robert Graham could employ geography and gravity
in a duel with Dubya. Graham was the chairman of Senate Intelligence
Committee when he voted against the Iraq war resolution. It will
be hard to call that vote “uninformed.” While Florida
governor, Graham brought the state back to capital punishment in
stylish fashion by re -commissioning the antique electric chair Old
Sparky for executions. The Sunshine State recently replaced the relic
with a chair that goes above “medium-high.”
House Minority creator Dick Gephardt of Missouri outflanks Bush
on the right concerning Iraq, while providing a moderate
counterpoint
to Lieberman. On the stump, he's every bit as dynamic as Muenster
cheese.
General Wesley Clark may run on a platform of opposition to the US
becoming a colonial power. Dick Cheney is privately fuming that someone
leaked the minutes of his colonial power meetings to Clark. George
Bush thought Florida already was a colony.
If Former Colorado Senator Gary Hart enters the race he would
actually widen and shallow the field simultaneously. What
will his mantra
be this time? New & Improved ideas?
It may not be premature to consider the 2004 Democratic roster
but it is certainly too soon to narrow the field. I hope more
candidates
get in before the winnowing begins. Remember, today's joke can
be tomorrow's president. And vice versa.
With a commentary, I’m Barry Crimmins
Not bad for short notice. It was about as innocuous as I can be
while retaining the rights to my soul. I did make it clear that
I thought
the sheer volume of candidates was a good thing. And there wasn't
a millimeter of slack for Bush.
I didn't hear anything from On Point that afternoon. Early in the
evening, I got an e-mail from the producer (or assistant or whatever
she is) saying that another person (and I am withholding the names
of these people as a courtesy to youth) would "give you
a call tomorrow morning to go over the piece with you. Thanks for
getting
it to us so promptly. We've been a little swamped today on this end."
I knew this meant trouble. "Go over it with you" was
the key phrase. It meant "scrap and rewrite."
I waited around all morning -- no calls. I had other pressing matters
to attend to, like the book I am writing for Seven Stories Press.
Nevertheless, as a writer/performer I am hardwired to get one task
done at a time. And so from Tuesday evening until Thursday afternoon,
I was distracted by this radio essay. It only
promised to pay a measly $100, but hey, I'm an artist and money isn’t
my primary concern. Still, this represented a profoundly insulting
fee.
Finally, at 12:15 PM, my promised morning call arrived.
A producer, this time a young man, started with tepid praise but
then told me
what they really wanted was a "satire" on the size of the
field. He said this as if I somehow couldn't understand the word "satire."
He sold his
point by using exaggerated emphasis, as if I needed help grasping
the concept that he thinks it's silly for so many candidates to be
in the running for the Democratic bid. "There are three
new ones this week! When will it end??!!" He was confident
at first but that didn't last long. I can be rather difficult, particularly
when I’m right.
I said I wasn't the person to write this "satire" because I encouraged
by the size of the field. It
demonstrated that pols have been emboldened by the grassroots opposition
to Bush. The millions in the streets have translated into more choices
for president because suddenly it's clear that W is vulnerable. It
means the field isn't being prematurely narrowed thereby excising
important views before the public can vote on them. It is good in
a democracy when there are a lot of candidates. I said I wouldn't
make wrong-headed conventional wisdom palatable by making it “wacky.”
I continued by saying that if they think the broadening field is
something to belittle, then they really don't possess much political
sophistication. A broad field was to be encouraged and celebrated.
It is an indication that the possibilities aren't about to be narrowed,
making it easier for the moneyed few to buy all the viable candidates.
I made a point of telling this fellow
that I understood that it was just his bad luck to have caught the
assignment of dealing with me and that this was nothing personal.
I actually felt sorry for the guy. He had one trump card -- he could
either put me on the air or not. I quickly trumped it by making
it crystal clear that they could put their show in an NPR tote bag
and
place it somewhere far removed from solar occurrences. I told him
that their money ($100!!) was not worth my time or talent. I
would
read
the
essay
I wrote
and
even clean it up a bit, if they liked. But I had neither the time
nor inclination to turn it into something in which I did not believe.
He said I didn't understand. They weren't looking for "commentary,” they
wanted “satire." Besides, this was a segment called "Radio
Diaries" and not meant for commentary. There were plenty of
other places to do that on NPR. He said they didn't really want a
rundown
of the candidates. Well then
why
the
question
of "stature?" And
why e-mail me the list of Dems with hats in or near the ring? To
make fun of the field of candidates for its sheer size would
be commentary. Hell, all satire is commentary.
And that's what
I do, ask
around.
I am a commentator. I said I understood that my act may not be appropriate
for their show but they needed to realize that their
show might not be appropriate for my act. Having run dangerously
low on italics, I was happy our call was nearly over.
He said he would talk to his "senior producer" and promised
to get back to me "one way or the other." He never did.
I politely sat around the rest of the afternoon waiting for the return
call. It never came. I wasn't surprised but it is annoying when people
don't keep their word. I wish I had read the On Point website before speaking
with this person. I'd have quoted its description of what Radio Diaries
are: "These personal essays written and narrated by listeners
allow fresh voices and fascinating viewpoints to be heard on public
radio..."
Slick production standards may make On Point sound sophisticated
and elegant but it is run by at least some rather impolite
and ignorant people. The representatives of the show I encountered
were extremely disrespectful of my time and talent. They were shook
up when I matter-of-factly dismissed their absurd
presumption that a broadened democratic process should annoy us.
Their desire to impatiently belittle something that wasn't immediately
obvious to them is right out of the Morning Zoo radio playbook.
So the next time you hear something called a “Radio Diary” on
On Point, remember that although “diary” implies
that personal views are being expressed, on this show the person
doing
the expressing may well be a stooge mouthing the none-too-thoughtful
opinions of the producers.
Finally, I write this as a means of informing people about how
the media sometimes works. I am not disappointed or injured.
I should understand that I don't
click with NPR. (save for way back when, when I regularly visited
a show called Heat, hosted
by the wonderful John Hockenberry) So if anyone is to blame,
it's me -- for allowing my time to be wasted. I just
figured
I'd
take
a
shot
and
try to smuggle some content onto American airwaves. Maybe next time.
And oh yeah...
They want satire? How about:
Welcome to Nothing Considered But the Stuff Our Corporate
Sponsors Want Considered on National Over-privileged Caucasian
Radio.
NOCR -- The network that allows you to feel that a $45,000 car and
a social conscience aren't mutually exclusive.
Let the world know you care -- put your NOCR Sticker on your LandRover.
National Over-privileged Caucasian Radio,
formerly National
Plutocrat Radio, is member-supported --
just like a country club.
Our news division is running dangerously low on sound effects. Please
give now so that we can hear festively clad native women removing
clay bread pans from wood-burning ovens deep in the heart of the
Amazon. Think of how diminished your day would be without the sounds
brought to you on NOCR.
We have several exciting new premiums for contributions to our funding
drive that will run from now through Beach Season.
For a donation of just $250 you’ll a gift basket from Archer-Daniels
Midland, the multinational concern that mutates America's Breadbasket.
Archer-Daniels Midland --the innovative folks who have found a way
to make vegetarian food bad for you!
Upon receipt of your gift of $500, we will send you an official pair
of authentic NOCR kneepads, just like the ones our reporters at the
Pentagon and White House use!
Or give $1,000 and get a twelve CD set of out -takes from the Ken
Burns Takes Credit For Jazz series on our sister network National
Over-privileged Caucasian
Television, featuring Winton Marsalis and George Will discussing the good
old days before Negro Music got threatening. Perfect for listening while lounging
around your summer home or any of your other residences!
This is NOCR, we wouldn’t know a working person if
he or she knocked on
our back door.
Remember, if the announcer speaks in clipped phrases and with anal
punctuation and sounds as if he would rather wear a crisply starched
white shirt than have
magnificent sex, you're listening to National Over-privileged Caucasian Radio.
This reminder: NOCR complies with FCC statutes that require that
a portion of our on-air staff consist of people of color but you'd
never know it to listen
to the cookie cutter stodginess of our patter.
This is National Over-privileged Caucasian Radio, cue the regally
trill French
horns.
And now the News from NOCR, portions of which are not brought
to you thanks to the generosity
of our corporate sponsors…..
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Please click to sign up for the Barry's mailing list:CrimQuips
© 2003
Barry Crimmins
|