Blood Brothers
Burn Piano Island, Burn!
[ArtistDirect; 2003]
Rating: 9.1
I stand on one side of a great divide, surrounded by over-analytical obsessives in tattered, earthtone
clothes, our confidence or insecurity dependent on the obscurity of our record collections. We sigh in
disdain at the revelers across the chasm, their pink hair, studded belts and denim signifying clueless
victimization at the hands of made-up TRL rebels and one-word "garage" bands. We've been eying each other
with suspicion and contempt for years, but taking stock of the current situation, it seems that-- for their
uncritical record collections, contaminated by major labels and soundtracks-- the Manic Panic pagans are
having a lot more fun than the sheepish, socially retarded "aesthetes" around me.
Though I'm probably too old to party with the opposition, I'm lately having more fun observing their
exuberance than enduring the paranoid stares of a thousand overcautious pretenders to the tastemaking
throne. I'd been looking for a way out of here for months when I caught the daring stare of an obnoxious
21 year-old siren with-- naturally-- a Neurosis patch stitched to her bike bag. She led me away from the
shit-talking, permanently dissatisfied masses, her fluorescent jelly bracelets my beacon in pitch black,
until rounding a sharp corner, the flaming pyres of a mile-long overpass lit up the night sky. I crossed
this burning bridge last weekend, and learned I have Seattle's Blood Brothers to thank for completing this
monumental span, which Refused broke ground on some years back.
Blood Brothers' early singles and full-length debut This Adultery Is Ripe barely rose above forced,
bombastic screamo; they had moments, but were very late to a game played by Murder City Devils and
oversaturated with marginal acts like Sleepytime Trio. As with their recent tourmates Milemarker, however,
Blood Brothers grew in leaps and bounds, offering hugely improved compositions and a more authentic mania
on their second LP, last year's March On, Electric Children! They made the questionable/bold decision
to sample Nine Inch Nails' "Perfect Drug" on "Kiss of the Octopus", and closed the album with an exasperated
solo piano version of "American Vultures". Dramatic gear shifts like this are a dangerous dare: you either
drop your transmission or leave the competition in the dust. I'd lost sight of Blood Brothers since that
shift, and didn't know if they'd pulled ahead or fallen behind, but as soon as I caught Burn, Piano
Island, Burn in the rearview, I took my foot off the gas in defeated awe: they just lapped me.
Drowningman recently flipped the switch on hardcore with their lunatic math fury, but Blood Brothers take
it much farther, stripping away the violence and meathead confrontation, setting the high-pitched wailing
and tempo freakouts of grindcore against deliberate, menacing vocals informed by Ian Svenonius and The The's Matt
Johnson. Milemarker's Satanic Verses (which I savaged for its inconsistency) obviously drew
something from their approach, and though Pretty Girls Make Graves and Blood Brothers are friends, they're
hardly comparable; Burn, Piano Island, Burn is frighteningly slick in both production and technique,
but full of so much substance, its composite opposition is almost self-negating. This record is impossible.
After their half-minute statement of intent ("Guitarmy"), "Fucking's Greatest Hits" leads with a funk-era
Stevie Wonder guitar riff that-- incredibly-- works alongside a Jesus Lizard bassline, leading into a
bloodthirsty chorus that never lets up, flailing wildly out of the gates. While the album's title track
begins in even more overtly reptilian territory (borrowing from "Killer McHann"), it's also more controlled
than its spastic predecessor, slowing things down to a perceptible pace and showcasing the almost feminine,
metallic squeal that dominates the record, drawing Korn and Melt-Banana fans in equal number. Its central
choruses are among the catchiest moments on the record, maniac incantations from a surreal cut-and-paste
evisceration of society, hidden in its lyric sheet: "I buried my bride of eight-inch fingers deep in the
hungry quicksand/ I buried our child of pineapple skin where the generic sunsets sparkle so bland."
The lead single "Ambulance vs. Ambulance" is heavily evocative of The The-- in its calmer moments running
like "Infected" or "Jealous of Youth" at 45 RPM-- but its smooth, speedy verse is broken by a stabbing
pre-chorus attack, teasing before the song launches into a stratospheric four-chord chorus. For its
simplicity, the chorus is welcome relief from the murderous wailing and stop/start chaos that make this
album completely overwhelming on a straight listen. The breakdown is indicative of the album's sinister
intent, one of few moments you'll decipher without visual aides: "You'll never see your wife and children
again/ So tell us what was going through your head/ When you looked into their eyes and said/ "No thanks,
I'll take the hooker instead."
The swaying, reggae-tinged "Every Breath Is a Bomb" is an unfortunate low-light on this otherwise astounding
album-- think No Doubt on bad acid-- but beyond this ill-advised trip, the problem with Burn, Piano Island,
Burn is the very one they set out to solve: it's hard to take their chosen genre anywhere new. Of three
major breaks with expectation, two fail. In addition to the melting image of Gwen Stefani I'm stuck with,
"God Bless You, Blood Thirsty Zeppelins!" conjures Marilyn Manson-ian melodrama in its second half, as
overdone zombie choruses lead into chugging, straight-ahead radio rock.
In contrast, Blood Brothers' third experiment is stunning, and completely unexpected. "The Shame" begins
as a sedated march, a sincere twang ballad that gently rolls into a perfect dawn chorus for the lecherous
all-nighter in their wake: "Everything is going to be just awful when we're around." The reverse-guitar
ache and insistent snare rolls are unnecessarily interrupted, however, as a minute or so of the screamo
explosions we're more than familiar with by album's end come crashing down. Not to second-guess someone
else's art, but it would have made a perfect straight finale without the regression; that the song cuts off
in midstream is enough of a middle finger to convention.
Regardless, Burn, Piano Island, Burn balances so perfectly between commercial appeal and untainted
creativity that it's as if the band have been digitally inserted atop a mountain no man could conceivably
climb. Like their cutup album art, the Blood Brothers offer an incongruous marriage of humor, hate and
heresy, evidencing a dedicated collective of disparate and individual brilliance. This album will unite
clashing factions holding onto their illusions for dear life by reducing them to equally powerless spectators:
pretentious pontificates and preening poseurs look pretty much the same with their jaws on the floor.
-Chris Ott, March 24th, 2003