| The English language is like
a car. It needs four wheels to run smoothly. It can run
with three but it will be a very bumpy ride! The four
wheels of the English language include the semantics wheel,
the morphology wheel, the syntax wheel, and the phonology
wheel. Without a command of phonology or pronunciation,
individuals can still understand and speak the language,
but they may have a rough time of it.
ESL/EFL
teachers are realizing more and more that pronunciation
is just as an important component of language as grammar
and vocabulary and that the teaching of pronunciation
in a systematic way has been ignored for too long. It
is the often-neglected wheel in language instruction.
This
article is intended to provide EFL instructors with
highly practical information regarding the organization
and methodology in teaching English pronunciation to
non native speakers of English.
Program
goal
The goal is to teach ESL students to improve their pronunciation
of English and to reduce error patterns which interfere
with intelligibility. Intervention focuses on phonology,
stress, rhythm, and intonation.
Contrastive
phonology
In order to achieve success with ESL students, it is
helpful for the teacher to be aware of the specific
linguistic reasons for their difficulty in learning
English phonological rules. A comparison of L1 (native
language) and L2 (English) will show the similarities
and differences between the two languages. This information
is valuable to the student as well as the teacher because
it assures the students that their errors are completely
logical.
Formal
assessment
Once familiar with the linguistic reasons for a student's
English pronunciation problems, error patterns are predictable
and formal assessment is not a formidable task. Various
accent inventory tools, such as Dale and Poms Accent
Analysis, 1985 and 1994, can be utilized to assess phonological
competency in sentence contexts.
Order
of sound presentation
Consonants:
The options for selection of sounds or features
are numerous. A practical approach is to teach sounds
which interfere with communication most. It may be best
to begin with easier sounds such as voiced/voiceless
"th", final consonants, or voiceless plosives
[t] [k] [p] to establish a feeling of success. More
difficult sounds such as "r" might be saved
for later.
Vowels:
We recommend beginning with high front vowels, progressing
to low front vowels before tackling the high back then
low back vowels. Diphthongs and stressed/unstressed
"er" may follow.
At Miami-Dade Community College,
we have a series of three advanced ESL level courses,
each exclusively dealing with a component of pronunciation.
We deal with Consonants, Vowels, and Stress and Intonation
in separate courses.
Phoneme Production
Many ESL students produce sounds easily with minimal
auditory stimulation and explanation. However, when
there is difficulty in achieving correct production,
the following methods have been proven effective.
1.
Contrastive Phonology
This technique is used to show students similarities
between LI and L2. For example, we show Portuguese speakers
that the "a" in "casa" is the same
sound as [a] in "hot" and "father"
or that the "ch" in "chave" is the
same as the "sh" and "ti" in "she",
and "nation", respectively.
2.
Use of International Phonetic alphabet (IPA), Diacritics
and Graphemics
Orthography causes errors because of confusing English
spelling patterns. Thus the [a] in "watch"
is easy" for the student to produce, but when spelled
with an "o" as in "hot" may be confused
with [ou]. IPA, diacritical markings, and graphemics
("it's koooool in the poooool") are all visual
cues which supplement auditory stimulation.
3.
English Pronunciation Rules
Rules provide tangible information. Because English
has so few consistent pronunciation rules, ESL students
relish those that exist.
4.
Phonetic Placement Methodology
Phonetic placement and anatomical explanations are used
when all other methods fail. Multi-sensory methods are
helpful. It is useful for students to feel tension under
the chin for [I] and lack of tension for [I], or the
presence of vibration of the vocal cords for and its
absence for [s]. Looking in a small hand mirror and
seeing the tongue tip between the teeth for "th"
is immensely valuable.
5.
Auditory Discrimination Practice
This phase is an essential part of phoneme acquisition.
Minimal pairs are the heart of pronunciation work as
students generally confuse their target sound with the
replacement error (i.e., sit for seat, share for chair,
jet for yet, etc.). There are many effective auditory
discrimination drills. The following are examples of
the kinds the authors employ in their programs for Spanish
speakers, Japanese speakers, and international students
in general (Dale and Poms, 1985 and 1994).
Present
Minimal Words Pairs
The students must identify the word you say. The target
sound will vary. (Students see written words or sentences.)
Teacher says: Listen carefully and circle the word you
hear: "I see the mitt/ meat." "I see
the cot/cat".
Present
3-Word Series in which two are the same and one differs
The students identify which word is different. (Students
don't see written words.)
Teacher says: hot/hat/hot. Students underline number:
1 2 3.
Present
Sentences, occasionally mispronouncing a word with the
target sound
The students identify whether the target word in the
sentence was produced correctly or incorrectly.
Teacher says: Circle C (correct) or I (Incorrect): "I
like to swim in the pull". (Sentences are presented
auditorily; students don't see them.)
Teaching
sequence
Once the target sound is produced correctly in isolation,
instruction proceeds in the following sequence.
1. Words: Stimulation of sound
in words (listen and repeat after instructor); production
of sound in initial, medial, and final position.
2. Sentences: Production of
sound in phrases and sentences heavily loaded with target
phoneme (i.e. "The dean will see Steve at three.").
3. Structured and Spontaneous
Conversation: Dialogues, role playing activities, vocabulary
drills, question and answer drills, casual conversation.
4. Carry-over activities and
supplementary exercises for out-of-class practice.
Stress
and intonation
A contrastive phonological analysis will also yield
information about the differing supersegmental patterns.
For example, English has a stress-timed rhythm where
certain syllables are heavily stressed while others
are de-stressed or reduced. This concept of reduction
is new for most ESL students whose L1 is syllable-timed
where all vowels in all syllables are pronounced almost
equally, such as Japanese. They will have difficulty
producing schwa and may stress all syllables equally.
They will frequently avoid contractions, causing their
speech to sound stilted and unnatural. Intervention
focuses on correct use of stress in words and sentences.
Students are taught proper rhythm and encouraged to
use contractions and assimilative patterns (i.e. "I'll
have ham'n eggs.") in spoken language. Intonation
patterns may also be deviant when the student uses L2
patterns. Portuguese speakers, for example, use upward
inflections more than English speakers. This tendency
will be exhibited in English and must be replaced with
appropriate intonation.
Conclusion
A discussion of English pronunciation improvement methodology
would be incomplete without stressing the importance
of positive student/instructor interaction. ESL students
are proud of their cultural heritage and must be assured
that reducing their "accents" or bettering
their English pronunciation abilities is not the losing
of one's culture, but the improving of a skill. At the
same time, ESL students are often self-conscious and
frustrated about their accented speech and require continual
encouragement. We must provide a supporting, reinforcing,
and risk free environment and exhibit a strong sense
of humor. Students will delight in laughing "with"
rather than "at" each other when mistakes
are made. We will be rewarded with their enthusiasm
and appreciation for our efforts and interest in their
progress.
|