MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail  |  Shopping  |  Money  |  People & Chat
Web Search: 

 
Print | E-mail | Discuss | Alerts | Newsletters | RSS | Help   
Home
News & Politics
Campaign 2004
Arts & Life
Business
Sports
Technology
Travel & Food
Slate on NPR
Output Options
About Us

Search Slate

Advanced Search



press box    Media criticism.

The Jayson Blair Project
How did he bamboozle the New York Times?
By Jack Shafer
Posted Thursday, May 8, 2003, at 2:45 PM PT

Jayson Blair: faking it

Jayson Blair: faking it

What can you say about a trusted professional who makes stuff up and publishes it as fact?

Last week, New York Times reporter Jayson Blair joined Janet Cooke, formerly of the Washington Post, the New Republic's Stephen Glass, the Boston Globe's Patricia Smith, and Jay Forman in Slate as journalists who got caught embellishing, exaggerating, and outright lying in print. The will to fabricate cuts across disciplines, with academics and scientists inventing data, too. Last year, Emory University history professor Michael A. Bellesiles resigned following an investigation of charges that he concocted evidence to support his book Arming America, and Bell Labs fired researcher Jan Hendrik Schon when it discovered he made up scientific data and published it.

The unmasking of a counterfeiter tends to inspire busy discussions of his motive. In the case of Blair, who is black, observers such as Mickey Kaus speculate that affirmative action may have pushed Blair to a position of responsibility before he was ready for it. The busted fabricator almost always cites personal or emotional problems, and sure enough, Blair struck that note last week, telling the Associated Press, "I have been struggling with recurring personal issues, which have caused me great pain. I am now seeking appropriate counseling. ..."

Those seeking to "understand" the liars' behavior tend to blame the liars' employers, making the liar the victim. The bosses pushed him too hard, or they took a young, promising journalist and threw him into the deep end—beyond his known abilities and experience—way before he was ready. Folks rush to swaddle the liar and his motives in psychobabble instead of placing the onus where it belongs.

No single explanation can cover every case, but my guess is that most liars make things up for the simple reason that they don't have the talent or the ability to get the story any other way. According to the Washington City Paper account, Blair repeatedly concocted specifics, both sensational and mundane, while covering the D.C. sniper story. He didn't really need to: Other Times reporters were on the story, too. My guess is that Blair made stuff up because he didn't know how to wheedle gossip out of prosecutors and cops, he didn't know how to put two and two together and make the next call to find news, and he didn't know how to take notes and report the facts straight.

Jonathan Chait, who worked with Glass at the New Republic, remembers that Glass wasn't really much of a stylist: Glass' stories read beautifully because the late Michael Kelly poured his genius into them before publication. Kelly would often remark on reading a Glass first draft of how great the story was but that he needed more detail. As it turned out, Glass wasn't much of a reporter, either. Instead of digging for more, he conjured the effects he thought Kelly wanted. A little closer to home, a similar thing happened at Slate when I edited Jay Forman's monkeyfishing piece. When Forman, who did go monkeyfishing, turned in a first, flat draft about his Florida Keys adventure, I encouraged him through several rewrites to add more writerly detail to increase the piece's verisimilitude. Forman complied, inventing numerous twists to the tale and even confessing intense remorse for things he never did.

The lesson I learned isn't to refrain from asking writers for detail but to be skeptical about details that sound too good or that you had to push too hard to get the writer to uncover or that are suspicious simply because any writer worth his salt would have put them in his first draft. All that said, it's almost impossible for an editor to beat a good liar every time out.

Blair, like Glass, Cooke, Smith, and Forman, got away with making things up for as long as he did because journalism is built on trust. As New York Times Executive Editor Howell Raines told the Washington Post today, "Frankly, no newspaper in the world is set up to monitor for cheats and fabricators." When an editor gives somebody a notebook and pencil and tells him to go out and report, it's a little bit like giving somebody you barely know a loaded gun. You expect him to use it wisely and honestly. But one slip, and there's hamburger all over the wallpaper! Hence, most reporters don't make things up because 1) they're as ethical as Jesus Christ or 2) they know they'll get caught.

The Blair revelations should distress everybody who creates or consumes copy. How many prevaricators lurk out there? But the wrong takeaway from the Blair-Cooke-Glass-Forman disasters is to assume that young people can't be trusted to report. Instead (and how about this for drawing a happy face in a mound of manure?), their sordid experiences in the journalism trade indicate that so many young people get caught making stuff up because you can't get away with it for very long. Journalism ain't perfect, but it loves to eat its sinners.

******

Send your lies to .

Jack Shafer is Slate's editor at large.
Photograph of Jayson Blair courtesy of the New York Times.

Slate
More press box
Previously Thought To Be True
A modest proposal for the New York Times and other media.
posted June 4, 2004
Jack Shafer

E-mail Confidential
Who's afraid of Time Inc.'s legal disclaimer?
posted June 1, 2004
Jack Shafer

The Accidental Editor
The Los Angeles Times lifts from the Washington Post.
posted May 27, 2004
Jack Shafer

Mini Culpa
The New York Times finally concedes its WMD errors.
posted May 26, 2004
Jack Shafer

Judy's Turn To Cry
The New York Times prepares an "Editors' Note" about its prewar WMD reporting.
posted May 25, 2004
Jack Shafer

Search for more Press Box in our archive.

What did you think of this article?
Join the Fray, our reader discussion forum
POST A MESSAGE READ MESSAGES


News & Politics


Today's State: Missouri
Like all Midwesterners, Missourians believe they reside in the most authentically American of places. I grew up in Kansas... More
News & Politics


D-Day OD
This year's onslaught of D-Day hype—a continuous barrage of World War II nostalgia stretchi... More
Arts & Life


The Late Bloomer
One of the peculiarities of the Nielsen ratings is that Jay Leno's Tonight Show crushes David Letterman... More


TOP HEADLINES
MSNBC
WashPost: Kerry plan could cut premiums

U.S., Britain want Iraqis able to oust troops

Bush seeks European cooperation on Iraq

U.S. soldier killed in Baghdad blast

    Try MSN Internet Software for FREE!
    MSN Home | My MSN | Hotmail | Shopping | Money | People & Chat | SearchFeedback | Help   
    ©2004 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Terms of Use Advertise TRUSTe Approved Privacy Statement GetNetWise Anti-Spam Policy