CNET Reviews

TVs Music Cell phones Cameras Camcorders Handhelds Desktops Notebooks Peripherals More »

MP3 Insider: An opinionated take on MP3 and the audio revolution.
Allow me to induce myself
By Eliot Van Buskirk 
Author of Burning Down the House
Senior editor, CNET Reviews
July 7, 2004

For the most part, we live in a free country. An example: Even though it's generally illegal to drive faster than 75mph on any road in the country, car manufacturers don't install electronic speed enforcers on vehicles. If you get caught driving too fast, resolving the matter is up to you and the highway patrol, and the police can't automatically collect money from Volvo every time your station wagon hits 71mph. But imagine what would happen if, before you were ever caught speeding, the highway patrol preemptively brought lawsuits against every entity responsible for your driving too fast. Volvo, your tire manufacturer, the movie Speed, the ad firm who made the car look fast, and even NASCAR could be sued for "inducing" you to speed.

Sound ludicrous? Consider Orrin Hatch's ill-conceived INDUCE Act 0f 2004, which essentially enforces similar rules in the world of digital music. (Quite bizarrely, the term INDUCE stands for inducement devolves into unlawful child exploitation--if you discover the connection between copyright infringement and the exploitation of children, please let me know.)

The act would illegalize anything that might make you more likely to infringe copyright. It's written in such overly broad language that you can't tell whether it would outlaw the iPod, tape recorders, libraries, the Internet, or just technology in general. After all, one could argue that all of these have made people more likely to commit copyright infringement.

To show what sort of inane lawsuits would be possible under the INDUCE Act, the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) drafted a mock complaint, in which Apple, Toshiba, and CNET are sued: Apple for manufacturing the iPod, Toshiba for supplying the iPod's hard drive, and CNET for my iPod review, in which I explain how to use the iPod to transfer music between two computers. The fake complaint accuses these three companies of inducing copyright infringement by conspiring to put an iPod in your hands so that you might, of your own volition, fill it with unauthorized copyrighted music.

If you like the iPod, the Toshiba hard drive, or CNET reviews, this act should scare the bejesus out of you. In fact, even if you don't like any of them, there's certainly some item in your life--a TiVo, a Xerox machine, the Ctrl-C keyboard shortcut, or an e-mail account--that you stand to lose if this act passes.

This isn't the first time something like this has happened. In 1984, Universal sued Sony to kill the budding VCR market, and in 1998, the RIAA sued Diamond in an attempt to demolish the burgeoning MP3 player market. Both times, the courts decided that since the Betamax and the Rio have substantial noninfringing uses, those devices are legal. But this isn't a lawsuit--it's an actual law that will be enforced in courts if it passes.

I have a neat solution to the whole debacle, using this chain of logic:

  1. The INDUCE Act makes an infringer out of anyone who "aids, abets, induces, or procures" someone else's copyright violation.

  2. This act is anticonsumer and antitechnology and, as such, has made its share of enemies.

  3. When people feel that a law is unjust, too broad, and makes no sense, they're more likely to break it.

  4. Therefore, this law will encourage people to trade more songs and purchase fewer legally.

  5. Since it encourages copyright infringement, the INDUCE Act will be illegal--under the INDUCE Act.

  6. Orrin Hatch should be the first person sued if the bill passes, for inducing people to infringe on copyright.

Clearly, there's something very wrong with the INDUCE Act. To help prevent it from passing, you can use the EFF's simple form to send a letter to your local representative, send a letter to an editor using's zip code-based editor finder, or just spread the word.

Eliot Van Buskirk is a senior editor for CNET Reviews and the author of Burning Down the House: Ripping, Recording, Remixing, and More!

VIC-20 becomes an MP3 player
Back in the early '80s, my first computer, the Commodore VIC-20, augmented its unbelievably paltry 20K of memory with an audio cassette drive that would record audible signals onto normal cassettes as a means of storing data. Now, there's another connection between the good old VIC and portable audio: the upcoming e-VIC, an MP3 player with 20GB of memory--more than a million times as much storage capacity as the good old VIC-20. 
The Register's article

What if a couple of skilled country musicians set out to cover several popular Radiohead songs in a hillbilly style? Wonder no more. 
Download the Rodeohead MP3, courtesy of

The 365 Days Project is back
These folks decided to post one free MP3 on their site every day. For a while, the archive was gone, but it's back now, thanks to UbuWeb. 
The 365 Days Project

Sony debuted the Walkman about 25 years ago, but the one that seemed most popular was its Sports Walkman line. Now you can pop an iPod into an old Sony Sports Walkman, using a kit--or pay $100 for to do it for you.
Sony's new iPod competitor, released on the 25th anniversary of the Walkman

"100% Legal MP3s," my foot!
This week, the column exposes online music sites that claim to sell you a lifetime of free access to all the music, movie, and software downloads you could ever possibly need. Here's why they're all 100 percent full of it.

Digital music without the computer
Sure, it helps to have a computer if you want to enjoy digital music. But it's not absolutely necessary. Here's how to enjoy those MP3s without a PC.

Bonnie needs an MP3 player
CNET handheld expert Bonnie Cha's desk is swamped with PDAs. Nearly all of them can play MP3s. But Eliot Van Buskirk thinks she needs a standalone MP3 player.

More commentary
Buzz Report
Molly Wood
CNET's index of top tech trends and terms.
Ask the Cell Phone Diva
Joni Blecher
The Diva talks back.
MP3 Insider
Eliot Van Buskirk
An opinionated take on MP3 and the audio revolution.
Consumer Alert
Rik Fairlie
CNET's tech-industry watchdog tells all.
Security Watch
Robert Vamosi
Don't get burned by viruses and hackers.
Fully Equipped
David Carnoy
The electronics you lust for.
The Digital Domain
John Morris
The lowdown on high tech.
Inside the Labs
Daniel Begun
A view of leading technology.
Works for Me
Rafe Needleman
A look at the latest technology for your digital office.
Living It
Brian Cooley
Dealing with technology in real life.
Get the Picture
Aimee Baldridge
Digital imaging notes from the field.
Pixel Perfect
Lori Grunin
The digital studio demystified.

TVs Music Cell phones Cameras Camcorders Handhelds Desktops Notebooks Peripherals More »