Cincinnati.Com
ENQUIRER  |  POST  |  WCPO  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Customer Service
Currently:
47°F
Cloudy
Weather | Traffic
The Cincinnati Post
POST HOME
NEWS
ENTERTAINMENT
SPORTS
REDS
BENGALS
LOCAL GUIDE
MULTIMEDIA
ARCHIVES
SEARCH
 
DEPARTMENTS 
NEWS 
SPORTS 
BUSINESS 
LIVING 
OPINION 
KENTUCKY 
WEATHER LINKS 

RESOURCES 
Subscribe 
Contact Us 
Search 
Back Issues 
The Post Store 

U.S. & WORLD 
A.P. Top Stories 
A.P. In Depth 

SCRIPPS LINKS 
Do It Yourself 
Fine Living 
Food Network 
Home & Garden 

DAILY FIX 
Weather 
Traffic 
Giveaways 
Horoscopes 
Lottery Numbers 
Comics 
Crosswords 
Stahler 

SPORTS 
Bengals 
Reds 
Golf Guide 
Hockey 




 
<!---##CCI#[Text Tag=head Group=All]--->Suit against Roach to proceed <!---##CCI#[/Text]---> Suit against Roach to proceed

By Kimball Perry
Post staff reporter

Former Cincinnati Police Officer Stephen Roach isn't immune from a wrongful death lawsuit because he was an officer when he shot and killed a fleeing black teen in 2001, an act that sparked rioting in Cincinnati.

That was the ruling this week of a federal judge who said a wrongful death lawsuit filed by Angela Leisure, mother of the teen, Timothy Thomas, could proceed.

U.S. District Court Judge S. Arthur Spiegel, in a Tuesday ruling, refused the request to dismiss Roach, now an Evendale police officer, as a defendant in the suit.

Leisure, representing her son's estate, filed the federal suit in May 2001, a month after Thomas -- who was unarmed and wanted on minor misdemeanor charges -- was chased through Over-the-Rhine by Roach.

Roach, in violation of Cincinnati police policies, was running with his gun pulled and his finger on the trigger when he shot and killed Thomas in a dark alley.

Charging that Thomas' killing was symptomatic of a police force that too often disrespects and mistreats black men, a group of blacks began a protest days later that exploded into riots.

The suit was filed against Roach and the city of Cincinnati, which asked the judge to throw out the suit.

Roach contended he was immune from the suit because he was doing his duty as a police officer.

Spiegel disagreed.

"Such immunity is an entitlement not to stand trial, not a defense from liability," Spiegel noted in his ruling.

The focus of Roach's request is based on the shooting being "accidental or inadvertent," Spiegel added.

Roach, however, has given several versions of the fatal shooting at different times.

Roach has said he saw Thomas reach for his waistband, perhaps when Thomas was hitching up his pants, and suspected he was going for a gun. He also has said he accidentally fired the gun when Thomas surprised him by quickly coming around a dark corner.

The suit accuses Cincinnati police of having a longtime, tacit policy of racial discrimination against black men that contributed to Thomas' killing.

Spiegel, in considering the legal concept that the issues must be viewed in light most favorable to Thomas' estate, ruled those allegations can be part of the suit.

City officials also asked the judge to dismiss the city from the suit, claiming sovereign immunity as protection.

Spiegel has instructed both sides to prepare more in-depth legal arguments on the city's request.

Trial of the suit is set for January.


Publication Date: 05-09-2003




Click here for forecast

Post Features
Store at the Post
Store at the Post

Subscribe Online
Subscribe Online

Lottery Numbers
Lottery Numbers

HGTV
HGTV

Personal Finance
Personal Finance

Contact Us
Editor of
The Cincinnati Post

Editor of
The Kentucky Post

Webmaster

Sports Editor

Living Editor

Business Editor

Metro Editor

Kentucky Post
City Editor


LATEST NATIONAL,
INTERNATIONAL NEWS


Internal U.N. Audits Ignite Debate

At Least 7 Deaths Blamed on Calif. Storms

3 Dead, 1 Missing After Pa. Tugboat Sinks

Two Teens Gunned Down at Birthday Party

Sailor Dies After Nuclear Submarine Mishap

2 Arrests in Fatal Miss. Hospital Shooting

Alleged Abu Ghraib Ringleader May Testify

Iraqi Body Not Yet Exhumed in Drowning

Train Car Leaking Toxins Patched in S.C.

Parish in Mo. to Keep Control of Assets

GIs Kill 8 After Convoy Bombed in Iraq

Abbas Sees 'Difficult Mission' After Win

Alabama Pension Fund, Bear Stearns Settle

Tsunami Rivals 9/11 in Corporate Donations

Nortel Vows to Deliver 2003 Results

U.S. Gas Prices Drop Again, Survey Finds

Nissan Expects Slower Growth in 2005

Cincinnati.Com
Search our site by keyword:  
Search also: News | Jobs | Homes | Cars | Classifieds | Obits | Coupons | Events | Dining
Movies/DVDs | Video Games | Hotels | Golf | Visitor's Guide | Maps/Directions | Yellow Pages

  CINCINNATI.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  POST  |  WCPO  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Customer Service

Need help? | Suggestions | News tips | Letters to editors
Web advertising | Place a classified | Subscribe | Circulation

Copyright 2005 The Cincinnati Post, an E.W. Scripps newspaper.
Use of this site signifies agreement to terms of service updated 12/19/02.

E.W. Scipps