From an early age we are taught that knowledge comes from
teachers. So it has become common to seek 'enlightenment' from
someone else. Sadly this can sometimes lead to a commodimizing
of spirituality. Even to the point of making salvation - renamed
'awakening' or 'enlightenment' - a marketable item offered up
by those wishing to teach.
"The true guru knows you need nothing, not even him." -- Nisargadatta Maharaj
"There is a false sense of liberation that aspirants
reach that very few ever go beyond." -- Ramana Maharshi, when
asked about spiritual teachers
"When asked about those he sent to teach, Papaji said
that the purpose was to have them point the way to Lucknow, not
to pose as awakenened teachers. When asked further about these
people, Papaji said that none of them where enlightened or even
temporarily enlightened. Papaji said that many can fool others
into thinking they are liberated but they are the false coin.
When asked about the experiences that so many people had in Lucknow,
he said they were false experiences. Papaji said he met only
two Jnani's in his lifetime. One was Ramana Maharshi. The other
was a man who appeared from out of the jungle into the town of
Krishnagiri." -- Poonja, quoted from
the book'Nothing Ever Happened' by David Goodman
"It is common to demand entry into Enlightenment through
someone else. This renders it needful to make clear that NOBODY,
not even the best of gurus, can bestow final and lasting realization--a
glimpse is the most he can possibly pass on and there are not
many with that capacity. Even in such cases, his disciples must
work diligently and win it themselves." --Paul Brunton
(quoted from 'The Guru-Disciple Relationship'>
"What about religions, teachers, gurus?"
"If they can help in the quest of the Self. But can they
help? Can religion, which teaches you to look outside yourself,
which promises a heaven and a reward outside yourself, can this
help you? It is only by diving deep into the Spiritual Heart
that one can find the Self." -- Ramana Maharshi (quoted
from 'Here lies the heart' by Mercedes De Acosta)
"Real Enlightenment definitely is not on sale at the
corner store, it doesn't contain preservatives, and isn't wrapped
in plastic. Absolute surrender to God, or the Universe, is the
greatest gift, the "pearl of great price," and it will
never be cheap. That is why one should question the ersatz gems
that pseudo-spiritualists so readily sell in their fancy packages.
If one wants the real thing, one must learn about counterfeits;
otherwise, one is showing off a rhinestone to God, convinced
it is the Hope Diamond." --Mariana Caplan
"The one who explains, lies.
How can you describe
the true form of Something
In whose presence you are blotted out?
And in whose being you still exist?" -- Rabi'a al-'Adawiyya
It seems that the pauperisation of satsang culture began
after the death of Poonjaji. Many of his followers started to
claim that Poonjaji approved their 'Awakening.' It seems that
they just took him too literally. It is an Advaita custom to
say 'you are already Awakened.' This is however more a teaching
device than a reflection of reality. And even if some of his
disciples had a glimpse of Awakening, Poonjaji knew very well
that in most cases neither it was permanent nor the final state.
--Aziz Kristof
"Anyone who wants to repackage enlightenment for mass consumption
must first create the illusion that it's comfortably within the customer's reach.
It may be true that the price of truth is everything, but
true don't pay the bills. In the commercial model, the price of truth is whatevery
you can comfortably afford. ... seekers will gladly pay to be reassured that,
common sense aside, they can wake up without quitting the dream. ...
I know that no spiritual teacher leads to enlightenment because there is
no leading to enlightement. There is no teaching of enlightenment. Hence
the inevitable outcome we see all around us - everyone's grooving on the gurus
and everyone's getting more and more spiritual, but nobody's waking up." --Jed McKenna
Teaching is a tricky thing. It can ensnare
both teacher and student within invisible walls of reassurance. It is
not at all difficult to convince thirsty people that you have water. Especially
if you have first convinced yourself. And often a loop can occur -
wherein the teacher convinces the student who convinces the teacher who
convinces the student and so on. A dynamic occurs where both are convinced of
the rightness of what is being said and both reassure one another that they
are uncovering truth. --Peter
Over the years the members of our little group of friends here
in the islands have met many teachers, both well known and otherwise.
Most offer a satsang of some type. Some of the teachers have
many students, and travel around the world. Some earn a very
good living from their teaching and live lives of privilege.
Some make their living working at ordinary jobs and live ordinary
lives. Some are well known and famous, some are unknown and wish
to remain that way.
Every so often we receive email from someone to the effect:
'Hello. I am a fully enlightend teacher in the advaita tradition.
I awakened in the presence of my master and was instructed by
him to teach. I give satsang and would appreciate being listed
on your site." And sometimes we get notes that say something
like: "Why have you failed to list so-and-so. She is the
best known advaita teacher in the world. We are shocked that
you would not include her. Please correct this oversite at once."
To all of this we can simply respond that none of the members
of our little group here believe in teachers, least of all advaita
teachers. It can be
fun to listen to them sometimes, and we enjoy meeting new
friends at satsangs... but we have come to wonder why anyone would
want to lie in the arms of a priest, no matter how beautiful,
when one could be hugging God instead?