navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
Sci Fi Wire: A News Service of the Sci Fi Channel
Toys & games
News Briefs & Links
Photo Gallery
 12:00 AM, 16-FEBRUARY-05
  SF Authors Sting Publisher

A group of more than 30 SF and fantasy authors, upset at one book publisher's marketing tactics and its derogatory comments about SF in general, perpetrated a hoax against the publisher, several members told SCI FI Wire.

PublishAmerica, based in Frederick, Md., purports to be a traditional publisher, not a so-called "vanity publisher," which charges authors a fee to print their books. But James D. Macdonald decided to test that assertion by coming up with an intentionally awful bogus book, Atlanta Nights by Travis Tea, to be written by several SF&F authors and submitted to PublishAmerica to test the publisher's standards. When the publisher accepted the book for publication, the writers revealed the hoax, and the publisher withdrew its offer of publication. "The fact that they'd attacked science-fiction and fantasy writers [as] untalented hacks provided the motivation and the avenue of approach," Macdonald said in an interview. On its Web site, PublishAmerica said, "[SF and fantasy writers] have no clue about what it is to write real-life stories, and how to find them a home."

Several young authors also have complained to Writer Beware, a Web site run by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, alleging that they were duped into signing with PublishAmerica, said Ann Crispin, a Washington, D.C.,-based author who volunteers running Writer Beware.

Macdonald conceived Atlanta Nights in the spirit of Naked Came the Stranger, a 1969 hoax perpetrated by Newsday columnist Mike McGrady and several well-known writers and critics, in which everyone wrote a chapter that was sexually explicit and deliberately inconsistent with other chapters. It was a runaway hit.

For Atlanta Nights, Macdonald asked several authors, including Sean P. Fodera and Victoria Strauss, to write the worst prose possible, using only sketchy details about characters and events to occur. The book was full of mistakes and inside jokes. There are two chapter 12s, no chapter 21 and a computer-generated chapter 34. Two authors wrote about a wedding of two characters, and there are many misplaced modifiers, malapropisms, spacing errors, incorrect descriptions and laughably bad writing (from Sherwood Smith's chapter 1: "Her [breasts] belonged to a beautiful face carved out of ice and whipped cream, with a pair of glowing emerald eyes"). Even the author's name was a joke when spoken fast.

As the group hoped and Macdonald said he expected, PublishAmerica offered a contract. "We'd suspected that they offer contracts to essentially anything that's sent them, and that they don't read submissions before accepting them," Macdonald said. After the group went public, PublishAmerica sent a letter of rejection. Asked to comment, a PublishAmerica spokeswoman asked that questions be e-mailed. As of press time, the publisher had not responded to SCI FI Wire's questions.

Macdonald said this isn't the end of sting manuscripts heading PublishAmerica's way. "Kevin Yarbrough sent in a manuscript that consisted of the same 30 pages repeated 10 times, and had it accepted," Macdonald said. "Dee Power has a sting manuscript that they've accepted. I'm sure that there are others in the works." Curious readers can buy Atlanta Nights, with proceeds going to the SFWA's Emergency Medical Fund.


RSS stands for Really Simple Syndication. RSS is a newsfeed that will let you access Sci Fi Wire with a newsreader such as Newsgator or Bloglines.

Get Feed

Get SCI FI Wire News delivered to your Palm or other handheld device!

Comments or questions about SCI FI Wire? Send us feedback, news tips or queries!

  More Headlines ...
  SF Authors Sting Publisher
  Dailies Prompted Cursed Reshoot
  Dragons Explores Species
  Straczynski Ends Trek Campaign
  Constantine Banned In Brunei
  Midway Jumps Into Adult Swim
  Intermedia Picks Up Call
  Stars Discuss Cursed Changes
  Straczynski Wants To Reboot Trek
  Sommers Enters Kingdom
  Nebula Nominees Announced
  Video-Game Nominees Announced
  Hauer Takes On Minotaur
  Norton Riding With Ghost
  New Matrix Game Announced

©2005, SCI FI. All rights reserved.

Jared Padalecki (House of Wax) and Jensen Ackles (Smallville) have been cast in the upcoming WB series Supernatural as two brothers who travel the country in search of the paranormal, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

A new, full-length trailer for the upcoming SF comedy Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy has gone up at

Sony announced that it has changed the release date of the SF action-adventure film The Cave to Aug. 19.


1. The Incredibles
2. Angel season five
3. Shark Tale
4. Charmed season one
5. Return of the King extended edition
6. Lord of the Rings trilogy
7. Bambi
8. Wonderfalls
9. Sky Captain
10. Star Wars trilogy

Source:, top-selling genre DVDs, 2/11/05