March 08, 2005

RAIN • 60° F
Advertise  Subscribe


   Site Map
   Front Page
   Nation/Politics
   World
   Commentary
   Editorials/Op-Ed
   Metropolitan
   Sports
   Business
   Special Reports
   Special Series
   Technology
   Entertainment
   Books
   Food
   Wash. Weekend
   Travel
   Family Times
   Culture, etc.
   Civil War
   Weather
   Corrections
   Photo Gallery
   TWT Insider
Stock Quotes
Symbol Lookup
   Classifieds
   Home Guide
   Auto Weekend
   Employment
   Health
   Services Directory
   Market Place
   Tourist Guide
   Holiday Gift Guide
   International Reports
   Archive
   Subscription Services
   Advertise
   About TWT
   Contact Us
   TWT Gift Shop
   National Weekly
   Insight Magazine
   The World & I
   Middle East Times
   Tiempos del Mundo
   Segye Ilbo
   Segye Times USA
   Chongyohak Shinmun
   Sekai Nippo
   GolfStyles
   World Peace Herald
   Times Color Graphics
   Arbor Ballroom

 

Top Stories
Italy didn't plan safe escape for hostage
Mexico seeks protection for illegals
Aspirin can cut risk of strokes in women
Bush to call for global support on Mideast
Court backs immigrants in job lawsuit
District's truancy numbers don't add up  
D.C. gas prices static despite national jump  
AP Breaking News
Millions Gather in Rome for Papal Funeral
Saddam's Old Foes Become New Iraqi Leaders
Pfizer Halts Bextra Sales at FDA Request
Guard Testifies He Saw Jackson Molest Boy
GOP Leaders Weigh New Social Security Plan
Bush Issues Regrets to Italy Over Death
Gay U.S. Soldier Wants to Serve Openly
Food Banks in Appalachia Try Diet Fare
Reports: Media Companies to Buy Adelphia
DiMarco Leads Rain-Delayed Masters by 1
UPI Breaking News
61% in Japan want constitutional revision
Writer Frank Conroy dead
Cairo bombing aimed at tourists
UPI NewsTrack TopNews
Vatican making final preparations
WH sends England nomination to Senate
Report: Grandma killed Rilya out of mercy
Dog-sledder apologizes for shooting dogs

Out to sea


By Ed Feulner

Thanks to American intervention, the fate of Iraq and Afghanistan now can be determined by their own citizens, rather than by brutal tyrants. Ironically, though, while the Bush administration spreads democratic rule overseas, it may be taking a critical step to undermine American sovereignty.
    During her confirmation hearings, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was asked if the administration would favor signing on to the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea. "The convention, as it now stands, serves our national security interests, serves our economic interests, and we very much want to see it go into force," Miss Rice replied. This just goes to prove that, in Washington, a bad idea never goes away. It is just tabled until everyone forgets why it was such a bad idea.
    The facts are simple and are the same today as in 1982 when President Reagan first rejected the Law of the Sea treaty and Donald Rumsfeld (then a special presidential envoy on the treaty) said why: It does not serve our national security or economic interests, and we should make sure it isn't ratified.
    Admittedly, Miss Rice isn't the treaty's only supporter. Last year, it passed the Senate Foreign Relations committee. Even some members of the U.S. military are on board. As Michael Mullen, then vice chief of naval operations, told a House committee, "We must be able to take maximum advantage of the established and widely accepted navigational rights the Law of the Sea Convention codifies to get us to the fight rapidly."
    But, in fact, the Navy stands to gain little from the treaty. As Adm. Mullen also testified, the U.S. already complies with large parts of the agreement: "If the U.S. becomes a party to the Law of the Sea Convention, we would continue to operate as we have since 1983. The convention's rules in this regard do not change the rules the Navy has operated under for over 40 years under the predecessor 1958 treaties to which the United States is a party, governing the territorial sea and high seas." Treaty or no treaty, we'll keep doing what we're doing.
    Though there's not much for us to gain, there's plenty to lose. In October 2003, Defense Department official Mark Esper told the Senate other nations could use Law of the Sea treaty to curtail American military operations, though these maneuvers are supposed to be exempt. China, for example, likely would quickly try to use the treaty to stop U.S. naval war games.
    It's not only the military that's at risk, though. If ratified, the treaty would create virtual governments outside American control but would exercise power over American interests.
    For example, Section 4 of the treaty would establish the International Sea-Bed Authority to exercise executive and judicial control over almost all the world's oceans and seabeds -- nearly 70 percent of the planet. Its new authority would have power to tax American interests engaged in various maritime endeavors. Only U.S. lawmakers should be able to decide how -- and how much -- to tax Americans.
    If the treaty went into effect, the result would resemble the United Nations: The U.S. would foot the bill for about 25 percent of the organizations set up under the treaty. But blocks of nondemocratic nations could limit our actions easily.
    Let's be frank: These international bureaucracies don't work. The U.N. already is dealing with a sex scandal in the Congo, genocide in Sudan and the Oil-for-Food fiasco in Iraq. Why would we want to create more unaccountable international bureaucracies and put them in charge of our oceans?
    As former Secretary of State George Shultz noted last year, nations create international organizations to serve their common interests, not to govern them. The current system works well and is in our national interest. It's time to sink the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea, once and for all.
    
    Ed Feulner is president of the Heritage Foundation.
    



Personalize Your News with The Insider

Subscribe to the daily or weekly printed edition

Print this article   E-mail this article


Get Copyright Clearance Reprints and Permissions
Copyright 2005 News World Communications, Inc.

 
Advertising
 
   
 
Assisted Living Care
Auto Insurance Quotes
Mortgage Loans, Rates
Auto Insurance
Product Supplies
All Equipment
Rifle Scopes
  Coffee Pots
Used Cars For Sale
Dental Plan Directory
Debt Consolidation
Free personals
Shopping
Flower delivery

All site contents copyright © 2005 News World Communications, Inc.
Privacy Policy
 
Commentary