little green weblog

LGF web design > weblog > comments

heart of a flowerthe hypnotic eyethe freshmaker
search with: Google LGF
Users Online: 1023

Show All Entries
Current Weblog

FAQ
Referrers
Search Requests
Preferences
RSS
The Robot Pillory
Charles's Wishlist

lgf poll


Vote for the person, country, and/or organization you think most deserves the coveted Robert Fisk Award for Idiotarian of 2003. This is the final round; you are allowed one vote.

 

poll archives

another-big-attack
anthrax-responsibility
biggest-threat-to-peace
democracy-in-iraq
do-you-believe-arafat
do-you-feel-safer
first-to-blink
how-bad-is-it
how-is-tom-ridge-doing
idiotarian-finals-2002
idiotarian-of-2003-final
idiotarian-of-2003
idiotarian-of-the-year
idiotarian-runoff-2002
israel-military
military-action-iraq
retaliate-against-hamas
sharia-in-europe
shoe-bomber-al-qaeda
trying-ariel-sharon
what-about-johnny
what-to-do-with-arafat
who-do-we-attack-next
who-should-be-tried
will-iran-go-nuclear

lgf archives

january 2004
december 2003
november 2003
october 2003
september 2003
august 2003
july 2003
june 2003
may 2003
april 2003
march 2003
february 2003
january 2003
december 2002
november 2002
october 2002
september 2002
august 2002
july 2002
june 2002
may 2002
april 2002
march 2002
february 2002
january 2002
december 2001
november 2001
october 2001
september 2001
august 2001
july 2001
june 2001
may 2001
april 2001
march 2001
february 2001

scripts

lgf artmail
lgf referrers
build RSS v1.2

searches

Bookmarklets
CSS
Netscape 4 tips
PHP

support lgf

You don't have to pay to read LGF. But if you enjoy what we're doing here and you'd like to show your appreciation, you can use the Amazon or PayPal links below to drop some change in our tip jar and help us buy some groceries.

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

contact us

your email:

subject:

message:

Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.

colophon

This page contains validated HTML 4.01 Transitional code, with a validated stylesheet. (Or at least it used to; but allowing visitors to comment makes validation impossible.) If you're viewing us with Netscape 4.x, we may look weird. But not completely whack. We wouldn't do that to you. Weird but not whack, that's our motto. We're readable in just about any browser, but we look best in the ones that understand CSS.

If you need a modern standards-compliant browser (what are you waiting for?), here are three of the most popular (all free downloads):

Netscape 6
Mozilla
Internet Explorer

Everything you see in this weblog was developed and programmed by Charles Johnson, including but not limited to the random photos, slideshow, polls, user preferences, contact form, referrer list, daily statistics, site search, google news search, link management system, random Zappa quote, and last but not least, the weblog system itself, which includes a full commenting system with a recent comments list, automatic archiving, RSS generation for syndication, an email-an-article feature, and a whole bunch of editing and administration features behind the scenes.

Hosted by HostMatters

LGF T-shirts now ON SALE! Click here to fill out an order form you can print and mail with your payment, or pay online with PayPal. If you live outside the US/Canada, use this form instead.

Please help keep Little Green Footballs bouncing by donating whatever you can! We do this without pay, so the more donations, the more time we can afford to devote to LGF. Thanks for your support, and for helping make LGF a success.

Donate through Amazon.
Donate through PayPal.

If you'd like to mail a donation directly, instead of using Paypal or Amazon, and we'll reply with our Post Office Box address.


previous entry:
AP Distorts the Truth (Again)
current weblog next entry:
Whiplash

6/15/2003: Letters from Iran

I’m not fond of the BBC; in many ways they’ve become a tool of the world’s anti-civilization forces. But there must still be a few lonely souls laboring away in windowless offices, carrying on the tradition of Winston Churchill, because this page full of letters from Iranians about the growing protest against the mullahs’ regime is very much worth reading: Iranian protesters remain resolute. (Hat tip: Msimon.)

I had a telephone conversation with my nephew who is 22 and lives in Tehran. He told me that he had never in his life run the way he did two nights ago when he went to the demonstrations in Tehran. The vigilantes had ran after him with chains and clubs, the reason being that he saw them beating a girl to death and she was bleeding. He said four of them were at her and kicking her in the head, stomach and another one was beating her with the chain he had. So he shouted you sons of the bitches, leave her alone, you animals..... Then they ran after him and luckily he managed to escape from them.
Shahrokh Biniaz, Kuwait

PRESIDENT BUSH PLEASE HELP US
Ali M., Iran

I am one of the students of Tehran university. i am studying law. let me tell you that the protesters are not students. they are some workless people that all the time looking for trouble. nobody from our own faculty has been participating in this protest.
Mena, Iran

The ruling party in iran must start sharing power with the pro-democracy now before is too little too late like the former ruler, the shah.
mike bargani, iran

The vigilantes once beat me up because I was taking part in a protest. They didn't use weapons because I am 13. But they punched and kicked me in a violent manner.
Paya, Iran

The Iranian people have shown their urgent tendency for freedom. Now the US must start to support the demonstration by warning the Iran government not to act against the people. This enforcement from the outside and people's demonstration inside, will finally down the Iran regime. We are waiting for immediate support of the US.
Farshad, Iran


replies: 62 comments
Comments are open and unmoderated, although obscene or abusive remarks may be deleted. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.

 

#1   cba  6/15/2003 07:30PM PST

This letter had me lifting my jaw off my knees:

I absolutely reject the concept of "democracy" and "freedom" as nakedly false phantoms of the west. Who would ever want to be "free" when they could instead live in the glorious order and sanctified grace of Sharia? Why does anyone need to have an opinion for himself?
Shahin Shahida, Iran

That's sarcasm, right? Right?

 

#2   EE  6/15/2003 07:31PM PST

Shouldn't there be a stern warning about suppression of civil rights to this leading member of the axis of evil? I mean by the US. The UN cannot do anything any more; France will block us in everything.

 

#3   Julesk  6/15/2003 07:37PM PST

Such brave children. By my count, 3 letters in the BBC's selection asked for US intervention.

 

#4   its jake  6/15/2003 07:38PM PST

If anyone wants to see a VERY interesting reaction to all of this, discuss it with a Shi'ite.

They have a different spin on it all together. I suspect that they think all those emails to be plants from American agents, et cetera.

This is all a vast conspiracy by America to invade Iran, they say.

 

#5   reaganite  6/15/2003 07:39PM PST

PRESIDENT BUSH PLEASE HELP US Ali M., Iran

The one time all caps doesn't bother me...

 

#6   no daft  6/15/2003 07:57PM PST

Do not hammer the B.B.C.too hard.
They showed an episode of Spooks last week.

I think it is called M.I.5 in the U.S.

A mad mullah was enlisting young muslim boys to suicide bomb Birmingham.

That is England,not the U.S.

There were over 1000 odjections sent to the B.B.C.

They were from mainly muslims,as everyone knows
muslims do not commit suicide attacks.

 

#7   CastorOil  6/15/2003 07:59PM PST

The US mingling in the student upheavals would give the Iranian rulers an excuse to clamp down on their own people under the pretext that they are CIA agents. VOA could encourage the protesters, certainly BBC and others can join in, but revolution has to come from within, not from the outside - just like it did in Eastern Europe. Otherwise, there will be enough of them to react like the liberated Iraqis.
I am very sympathetic to the students and wish them all the courage they can muster.
Meanwhile, we should inspect the Iranian nuclear facilities, and make sure they are not too close to developing a nuclear bomb.

 

#8   Mike Nargizian  6/15/2003 07:59PM PST

I am one of the students of Tehran university. i am studying law. let me tell you that the protesters are not students. they are some workless people that all the time looking for trouble. nobody from our own faculty has been participating in this protest.
Mena, Iran

Did you notice that one?
There was also this one.

Protesters were shouting slogans but if we compare quantity and number of protesters with other demonstrations they do not have enough power to do something . I think elections in Iran are the first and last method to change things.
Mary, Iran

I was there tonight along with more than 20,000 people, counting those in cars who had come there for the students. People of all types - those with chador, from downtown, people with expensive cars, young and old. It was very nice. I hope the demonstrations get organised, and don't get to aggressive - we lose when it gets to aggressive, but we will win if this goes on at the current level for a few weeks. I hope the US attacks with cruise missiles some Sepah/Intelligence ministry buildings! And I hope at least some of MPs who have signed the letter against Khamenei, stand up strongly for people.
Hadi, Iran

I just don't buy the "I hope the US attacks with Cruise Missiles right after statying she hopes the demonstrations don't get "too aggressive". Either the emailer is pretty un-intelligent or a fake.
Excuse me my cynicism here, though it was printed by the BBC and had to make it through their "PC filters".

The Basij militiamen are like wild animals. They beat women and children. The special police forces are even worse. I saw a young man being hit by them while keeping on shouting "Down with Khamenei!" He didn't stop until he was arrested. Some might say this is the same as what happened in 1999, but this time is not going to be the same for Iranians. Nothing will stop us but a referendum for a regime change. We are tired of Mullahs. A new mullah like Khatami will never ever be able to kid us again. We seek freedom and we will gain it.
Farshad, Iran

Let's hope most Iranians including key ones in the military and police see it that way as well. I'm not so sure yet, this could just be another Tienneman Square for Iran.

 

#9   gary bruce  6/15/2003 08:00PM PST

Civil disobediance worked to bring down governments throughout Eastern Europe in 1989 because the working populations repeatedly took place in mass demonstrations that became the equivalent of general strikes, and thereby shut down all those countries.

It failed in China and has failed in Iran because the participants are mostly students and their public demonstrations take place in the capital city only.

Sorry to say, unless the students in Teheran can get other segments of Iranian society involved, the Mad Mullahs will win.

 

#10   foobar  6/15/2003 08:03PM PST

I have lived through so many of these things that I feel quite sad to read: Pres Bush, please help us.

I still remember Hungary-'56 ad infinitem. I wish them well. I hope they succeed this time. When they overthrew the Shah, they hanged a man-- I think his name was Ghazi-- who attended college in the U.S. At first, his former classmates were so proud of him helping the revolution. But then one day, the ayatollahs decreed that he must be hanged. His face is engraved in my memory forever. He seemed like a nice enough guy.

These insidious crackpots-- the ayatollahs-- stole their revolution from them and immediately started executing lots of the poor zhlubs who naively helped put them in power. It's totally disgusting to the point where it is obscene.

 

#11   Philly G  6/15/2003 08:08PM PST

Wait, you mean the BBC accidently let this article slip through it's "AmeriKKKa is Eeeeeeeeeeevil and controlled by the Joooooooooooooooooos" campaign?

How'd that happen?

 

#12   Alex de Large  6/15/2003 08:09PM PST

It's great to see people fighting for freedom, fighting against the Islamist insanity. And always good to see a recovering idiotarian:

Twenty-five years ago when I was in my 20s , we protested against the Shah and brought in these maniacs (religious leaders). Now the students are finishing the job and hopefully will finally bring democracy into our country. Please remember this struggle started in 1915 so we are very patient nation.
Alex Far, Australia

 

#13   Elizabeth  6/15/2003 08:17PM PST

I hope and pray these people will be alright and that they'll suceed. I don't think Washington will go in to help them--just give them encouragement over the tv.

The man at the LA Iranian tv station on CNN yesterday said they don't want troops to go in anyway--they just want pressure put on the Mullahs to stop beating up the protesters and encouragement from Washington.

I hope this is not going to be Tianamen again.

 

#14   CastorOil  6/15/2003 08:17PM PST

Civil disobedience is a poor match to tanks and bullets, as was demonstrated in Tiananmen. It would certainly help to have the army on your side, or an usurping faction of the government. I speak in general terms, not knowing if such revolutionary power exists in Iran. Otherwise, it may take another few years of mullah rule, and more dead dissidents.

 

#15   Susan  6/15/2003 08:19PM PST

I think the Iranians are getting there. Maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but they are getting there.

 

#16   zulubaby  6/15/2003 08:24PM PST

Mike Nargizian (#8)

From the letter you quoted:

We are tired of Mullahs. A new mullah like Khatami will never ever be able to kid us again.

That is a key factor in this, that the Iranians are no longer willing to allow themselves to be duped by the mullahs.

We seek freedom and we will gain it.

I wish them strength to finally accomplish what has been a long fight for their freedom.

 

#17   bic  6/15/2003 08:28PM PST


(they are some workless people that all the time looking for trouble.)

Is that "workless" people or "worthless" people? Maybe it got mixed up in the translation.

Sorry, that was truly mean of me.

My sister married an Iranian in 1987, and they divorced (no children) in 1994. I liked my brother-in-law well enough and he told me many horror stories about Iran after Khomeni took power from the Shah in the late 70's. He said many people in Iran did not want to become too "Western" and that helped drive the Shah out of power. However, he also said that they got exactly what they asked for (extremists and fundamentalists) and he didn't have a whole lot of sympathy for his own countrymen.

 

#18   Tatterdemalian  6/15/2003 08:34PM PST

Rule #1 of the real world:

You cannot attain the USA's degree of wealth and accomplishment, without adopting the USA's bourgeois western values.

Anyone who fears "westernization" is dooming themselves to live in mud huts forever, and it is not the US's fault at all.

 

#19   Sideshow Ben  6/15/2003 08:50PM PST

I recently took a course at my university on "Iran and Modernity," taught by a very well-known Iranian law professor and "dissident." He is/was also a self-avowed socialist, and served prison time in the '70s for protesting against the Shah's regime. But what struck me most about the class was his announcement on the first day: that he regrets the actions he took against the Shah, and that he and all the other "lefitst intellectuals didn't know how well we had it."

As an Iranian refugee, I'm all for this insidious theocracy that forced me and my family out of Iran coming to an end. I just hope it doesn't beget something much worse.

In the meantime, may God be with the students and their cause.

 

#20   justdanny  6/15/2003 09:19PM PST

I hope I'm not the only person concerned about this issue who reads Iraniangirl every day.
Where baghdad blogger salam pax is a dumb ass wanabe commy spoiled little baathist prick. I believe Iraniangirl is legit. And her coverage of these recent events is pretty riveting, if you keep in mind shes a high school kid.

 

#21   heretic  6/15/2003 09:58PM PST

American Soliders = Tools of God

'In their silenced, fearful ranks, many in Iraq's army long harbored one overriding, unspoken goal. "We wanted to see Saddam fall at any cost," Abdul-Zahra said. "And we believed no one could overthrow this man, except for God and the United States." '

http://www.latimes.c...

Democracy

Whiskey

Sexy

 

#22   Bob  6/15/2003 10:11PM PST

God, I hope this doesn't turn into a repeat of '91, with the Bush Administration helping to incite a revolt and then standing on the sidelines as it turns into a bloodbath. Hopefully Bush Jr. has learned a few lessons from his father's mistakes. I'm quite sure that Colin Powell and the crew of amoral halfwits he presides over at Foggy Bottom have not.

 

#23   Skeptical  6/15/2003 10:13PM PST

America help us, help us.

Then freedom comes to pass.

Years later...."Down with America." American is scum."

Back to square zero.

The fundamental consciousness of these people needs to change and change some more.

America help us. Help us.

Then... fuck you America. Stop corrupting us.

Why don't they leave America alone!

Ask France for help. The French are so enlightened.

Ask Germany. Ask Austria. Ask Switerland.

Leave America alone. We're busy.

Find another shrink.

We're tired of your schizophrenic maddness.

Call 1-800-EUROPE

Call them.

Call them and they won't come.

Hmmmm....?

 

#24   finish arafat  6/15/2003 11:05PM PST

#19

All these leftist fucks confuse me. When we are getting controlled by a global socialist dictatorship, these clowns will probably be wishing that the United States, George W. Bush, Don Rumsfeld, and Paul Wolfowitz would come back to save the day.

These intellectuals will not realize how good they have it until it is too late.

 

#25   Tatterdemalian  6/15/2003 11:09PM PST

#23-

Maybe that's why God no longer answers prayers.

"I'm tired of your mortal shit. Go ask Zeus to do it."

 

#26   Chris  6/15/2003 11:17PM PST

Hmm, a link I found from Realpolitik.us:

http://www.washingto...

The Administration speaks out in support of the demonstrations...

 

#27   Uzi  6/15/2003 11:26PM PST

Hi guys. I'm back (at least for a few days) if anyone remembers me.


This could be the big explosion that we've been waiting for, the one that Michael Ledeen and a few others have been predicting. The demonstrations have spread beyond Teheran, at least to Shiraz, according to Kol Yisrael (Israel Radio) Farsi language broadcasts. This could be the beginning of a new 1989 style revolution in Iran, or it could be the prelude to a huge bloody crackdown like the Tienenmien Square Massacre. It could go either way. It could even go the way of the Romanian Revolution, with the Revolutionary Guards -like the Securitate- putting up a fight or the way of the Russian Revolution, with a bloody civil war before things are settled.

My guess is that the Mullahs will "not go gentle into that good night", so things could get very ugly very soon. The Iranian army could be the key. It is less firmly controlled by the Mullahs than the Revolutionary Guard, less ideological and more likely to feel an obligation to defend the people rather than to the Mullacracy. For that reason, the army is not trusted by the government and its troops are not stationed in large numbers near the big cities. If the government sics the Revolutionary Guards on the demonstrators, the army could intervene on the side of the people. If they do, it could prove decisive. It could be the turning point that turns this into a successful revolution. (This pattern has been seen a few times in modern history. In the 1688 "Glorious Revolution" when part of James II's army crossed the lines to join William of Orange, James lost his nerve, fled the field of battle and hightailed it to exile in France. The same thing happened to Ferdinand Marcos in the Philippine "People Power" Revolution 300 years later).

One last point to pay attention to. Iran is not an ethnically homogeneous society; it's a multi-ethnic empire, like Yugoslavia or the old Soviet Union. Persian Shiites are only the lergest ethnic group, comprising about 50% of the population. There are Sunnis, Tajics, Turkmens, Arabs and others. The different ethnic groups are concentrated in different locations where they constitute a local majority. During revolutionary violence or regime destabilization, look for these ethnic differences to form cenrtipital forces pulling the country apart.

Stay tuned.

 

#28   zulubaby  6/15/2003 11:30PM PST

Uzi!

I've been wondering where you've been! Thank G-d you're safe (can't help worrying, it's the Jew in me :-)

 

#29   HULUGU  6/16/2003 12:23AM PST

mullahs swinging by their turbans from lamposts by july 9....inshallah dude

 

#30   Elizabeth  6/16/2003 12:36AM PST

Quite coincidentally, tonight on a CBC literary program called "Hot Type" the interviewer Avi Solomon (Canadian Jew) was interviewing Salman Rushdie (formerly of Iran, now of New York) author of "The Satanic Verses". Avi was asking him how he felt about all the terrorism we see and hear every day and the subject of the Israeli-Palestinian struggle.

Rushdie said that at the time he wrote The Satanic Verses he felt like a prophet crying in the wilderness. He said about the Middle East situation that the situation between the Israelis and the Palestinians is the biggest diversionary tool the fundamentalists have. They can blame everything that is wrong on either that situation or the US or both. Until people can either see around that or through the lie of that or the situation itself becomes peaceful so it can no longer be used to mask the ills that are inherent in fundamentalist Islam itself, the fundamentalists will continue to hide behind the M.E. situation and will refuse to change their destructive ways.

Right now the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is being used as a screen to divert scrutiny from Islam.

It was an extremely interesting interview, I just wish it could have gone on longer.

 

#31   Uzi  6/16/2003 12:59AM PST

Thanks Zulubaby. I've missed you all. (As to where I've been: the wife claims I've become an internet junkie and asked me to cut down. Now I'm reduced to posting from the office on slow work days.)

Mark Steyn's website (Steynonline.com) is linking to a website full of up-to-date- info out of Iran:

iranvajahan.net/english/

 

#32   Jan  6/16/2003 02:01AM PST

Time to send armor across the border and into Iran soon. That would show who's on whose side there... if the Iranians truly are tired of their oppressors they'll greet their liberators with open arms and turn against the mullahs... the islamic police state will crumble and crash in short order and the war will be quick and easy.

Or if not... if the Iranian eagerness to get rid of mullahs isn't true rejection of islamic values and anti-americanism... then that too will be readily apparent very soon. And then the Air Force can go in and bomb the country into stone age. Either way, no more uncertainty about where they stand and no more threat from Iran.

If Iranian population turns out to be hostile to it's liberators, there's no need to occupy them... invasion and occupation of a truly hostile country in difficult terrain would only turn into a another Vietnam.
Just merciless Douhetian destruction from above. Not precision strikes but total war as in Dresden, Tokyo, Hiroshima. Let the muslims all over the world see what happens to barbarians and savages that refuse to be civilized and quit being a threat. That's much better PR against hostile real and potential terrorist supporters than trying to appease people who can never be appeased.

 

#33   zulubaby  6/16/2003 02:06AM PST

Uzi (#31)

Perfectly understandable. Aren't we all internet junkies? :-) It's lovely to see you.

You mention Mark Steyn and this is completely off topic but a strange coincidence so I have to post about it. While just reading this article I thought to myself that it had the "bite" of Mark Steyn but didn't bother scrolling up to see who had written it until after I'd finished reading the entire thing! He is really something.

Hillary yawner never gets to the good part , is pure Mark Steyn.

(Did I mention that it is completely and absolutely off topic?)

 

#34   Eye Opener  6/16/2003 02:07AM PST

The Iran-wide General Strike has been long-set for July 9th, next month. July 9... what a Date! The Martyrdom of Him Whom Christ promised!

Nevertheless, what started as a simple, small group of disgruntled students protesting university policy has shown some remarkable legs, continuing night after night because it RESONATES with a very broad spectrum of Iranian citizens!

I'm all for breaking arms and legs of those 'cycle-gang thugs' who came in whip-chaining and clubbing! Cause them maiming-disabling pain, but DO NOT Kill them...

As the soldiers shouted in "Saving Private Ryan", "Don't shoot! Let 'em burn!" while those who'd tried to outrun an American flame-thrower leapt from their concrete-reinforced bunkers in flames!

As non-violently as possible... but I'm a doctor and a father. There are times when you have but moments to take effective action, even if it means cutting away living tissue to save the organism!

This next few days will be a real Eye Opener, indeed!

 

#35   db  6/16/2003 02:16AM PST

Just a shot in the dark -


All nations are democracies and their people determine their government.


The Soviet Union demostarted this, as did India, Iran, the United States, and the Philippines.

This is a doctrine that justifies general war and will make a few of the less pleseant countries realize that they will not suffer the fate of Afhanistan and Iraq, but far far worse, of the likes of Germany and Japan.

 

#36   Chana  6/16/2003 02:39AM PST

This is from the _NY Times_. The headline is theirs. It sounds like an elementary school writing assignment, like "How is a tree like a snowflake", "How is a cloud like cotton candy?", "How is a train whistle like a song?..."


NY Times
How L.A. Is Like Iraq

To the Editor:

The bloodshed in Los Angeles that Bob Herbert details in "Where Fear Rules the Street" and "L.A.'s Streets of Death" (columns, June 9 and 12) is downright sickening.

South and East Los Angeles are plagued by persistent unemployment and random violence, much like postwar Iraq. Will our government send peacekeeping forces into Los Angeles to confiscate weapons, restore order and rebuild the local economy?

Unfortunately, in this age of fervent tax-cutting, it seems that there's only enough money for nation-building in "strategically important" parts of the world.


GEOFFREY J. KING
Austin, Tex., June 12, 2003

 

#37   Eniac  6/16/2003 03:38AM PST

#1,

I absolutely reject the concept of "democracy" and "freedom" as nakedly false phantoms of the west. Who would ever want to be "free" when they could instead live in the glorious order and sanctified grace of Sharia? Why does anyone need to have an opinion for himself?

he's not being sarcastic... sounds like a full-blown islamic-hive-worker...

pretty scary shit if you ask me

 

#38   Geoffrey  6/16/2003 03:39AM PST

Here he is

He's just a little boy, what would he know about Iraq?

 

#39   Sorry, my Islamabad  6/16/2003 03:55AM PST

#23 Skeptical

"Call 1-800-EUROPE"

Priceless! I sprayed a mouthful of coffee all over my monitor reading that!

 

#40   Angelus  6/16/2003 05:13AM PST

PRESIDENT BUSH PLEASE HELP US
Ali M., Iran

i bet it really pained them to have to put this one in.

 

#41   Black_Flag  6/16/2003 05:38AM PST

Uzi:

I take it youre in Iran?

If so, be careful.

On a side note, my father in-law is (was?) a Shi-ite, he fled to the US when the Shah left Iran. He supports the US in the current conflict and supports democracy in Iran. Just thought I'd throw that bit out for review.

 

#42   CastorOil  6/16/2003 06:04AM PST

In all these un-democratic states there is a ruling class that has been created by the dictatorship and by which means the dictatorship is maintained. This ruling class apparatus is the nervous system of control, sustained and rewarded by material advantages, and thriving from the subjugation of the general population. Examples can be found in the military dictatorships of South America, in the former and present communist dictatorships, and in the religious dictatorships, such as those of former Afghanistan, Iran, the Gulf States, or thugocracies like the PA.
Assuming that people who don't belong to the ruling apparatus are aware of the inequity, and have no way or desire to swell the ranks of the apparatus, they will one day galvanize in order to share more of the power and the resources of their countries. But will they naturally veer toward democracy, or yet another form of dictatorship?
How many in Iran are at this stage: is it a small group of students and intellectuals, is it a number of ethnic groups, is it the silent majority? And if they succeed in overthrowing the mullahs, will they opt for democracy and peace with their Middle East neighbors, including Israel? Will they stop funding Hezbollah?
Undoubtedly, a democratic Iran is what we all wish for, here in the West. Hopefully, that's what the majority of Iranians wish for, too.

 

#43   MikeO  6/16/2003 06:12AM PST

OT
Washington Post reports:

Egyptian mediators summoned all Palestinian militias today in a final push to persuade them to halt attacks on Israelis. Palestinian officials said they expect a truce to be declared very soon.
The Egyptians told militia leaders they have American guarantees that Israel will halt targeted killings of Palestinians suspected of involvement in violence, participants in the talks said.

If this is true, the development is troublesome: Bush administration has consistently expressed its belief that there should be no negotiations with terrorists.

 

#44   Barking Pumpkin  6/16/2003 06:36AM PST

Here's the "money" letter from those published in the BBC article:
I had the chance to flee Iran and escape to the US. Here I was able to get an education that would not have been allowed to me because of my faith. What scares me most is that I fear I cannot escape the strict enforcement of beliefs even here in the US. As more people become accepting of strict followings of Islam, I feel I may even have to flee here for my safety.

This scares me!

 

#45   dhimmi smits  6/16/2003 06:46AM PST

and since the iranian police are reluctant to use violence against their own, who do the mullahs import to put down crowds? ARABS!

 

#46   TheGreatSwami  6/16/2003 06:51AM PST

The situation in Iran will require finesse to swing it just right. First of all, the US can NOT get directly involved until the time is right. And that time has not yet come. The pot is simmering, we need to keep encouraging the protests indirectly through TV and radio. As the pot approaches a boiling point we need to be very clear, we support a democratic Iran. Bush himself needs to say these things, loudly. He also needs to be very clear, the US will NOT tolerate violence in keeping these protesters down. At the UN, merely for show because the UN is really worthless, we need to be clear, the US will not stand idly by while the protesters are attacked and killed. The problem is this, any future revolution can not be "tainted" by direct US involvement. As painful as it is and will be for the Iranians, they have to fight this fight. BUT when the pot starts to boil, it could get real nasty. The Mullahs will do everything they can to remain in power. When the real violence starts, then and only then, can we get directly involved. If they mobilize their Revolutionary Guards and the regular army does not move to stop them, then we destroy all military units. We make it very clear, if your military leaves their bases, we will destroy them. Preferably from the air (with SpOps support of course). For sure, we live in interesting times! I pray for the Iranians, may they find the freedom they want and deserve.

 

#47   RoughJustice  6/16/2003 06:56AM PST

Were other readers of Iraniangirl surprised by this :

generally the support of Police has been great, actually they never do anything against people & all that violence is from Basijis & members of Allah's group...I also heard that yesterday in one of Northern streets girls took off their veils & started chanting & policemen were even encouraging others to join them!

 

#48   RF  6/16/2003 07:07AM PST

Debka: Iran will have nuke by 2004. US to go before Security Council.

http://debka.com/art...

 

#49   Bill Jefferson  6/16/2003 07:09AM PST

Re: I absolutely reject the concept of "democracy" and "freedom" as nakedly false phantoms of the west. Who would ever want to be "free" when they could instead live in the glorious order and sanctified grace of Sharia? Why does anyone need to have an opinion for himself?

Either it is sarcasm, in which case we should do all we can to help the cause of the students and the general strikers due to take action July 9th.

Or, it is ernest. In which case we should do all we can to help the cause...

In addition to Iranian Girl, I am keeping track of Steppenwolf (http://steppenwolf.b...). Yeah, dry humor and sarcasm are practiced in that part of the world.

 

#50   Occasional Reader  6/16/2003 07:12AM PST

I read through this letter page, looking for statements like "Mr. Chirac, please help us", or "I wish France would support our struggle."

Oddly enough, I didn't see any.

 

#51   JLawson  6/16/2003 07:17AM PST

Perhaps they know what France would do...

Show up, wave a flag, then leave in order to make sure their uniforms stay pressed...

Intervene? Non...

 

#52   Axiom  6/16/2003 07:18AM PST

I half expect the gas pump to charge me an extra $5 for loving democracy lately. What the fuck Islamofascists?

 

#53   Kev  6/16/2003 07:39AM PST

I’m not fond of the BBC; in many ways they’ve become a tool of the world’s anti-civilization forces.

Yes, the only place where they have credibility is when they report on Mugabe (where they have nothing to gain from sucking up to him since he has declared the Beeb as one of his enemies along with anyone who has voted for him) and show reruns of Absolutely Fabulous on BBC America.

Iran may also be something of an exception given the turn of the wind. As far as these students go, I think, like Zimbabwe, Afganistan and Iran, they have nothing to gain from sucking up to the Mullahs. But then again, even for the left, backing the student movement in Iran is trendy enough a cause for the Beeb to give their client listeners what they want to hear.

 

#54   Kev  6/16/2003 07:40AM PST

#53 Kev 6/16/2003 07:39AM PST

My Bad: That should read "Taliban-ruled Afganistan"

 

#55   mickthemick  6/16/2003 08:06AM PST

#32 Jan

If Iranian population turns out to be hostile to it's liberators, there's no need to occupy them... invasion and occupation of a truly hostile country in difficult terrain would only turn into a another Vietnam.

This is precisely why the U.S. should not directly invtervene, especially militarily. The Iranians want overt moral support, and diplomatic pressure on the mullahs to reform, or step-down. Military intervention would have the effect of turing the Iranian population against the U.S., and it would only strengthen the mullocracy. Despite one letter writer' s desire to see "U.S. cruise missiles hitting Iranian intelligence" buildings, I don't believe that many Iranians seriously want this to happen. :-)

#40 Angelus

PRESIDENT BUSH PLEASE HELP US


i bet it really pained them to have to put this one in.

Wouldn't you like to have been there to see the pain on their faces? I'd like to show that letter to some lefties on this side of the pond, then watch them cringe! :)

Michael Ledeen's articles on Iran are always good, and here's today's contributions to NRO.

 

#56   Susan  6/16/2003 08:14AM PST

OT but interesting:

European oil companies get more Iraqi oil than the US;

http://www.telegraph...

But, but, it was all about the OIL!

 

#57   Occasional Reader  6/16/2003 08:40AM PST

Charles--I nominate Susan #56 for a hat tip! Great article, thanks Susan.

The six companies which won part of the shipment were Spanish refiners Repsol and Cepsa, TotalFinaElf from France, Tupras of Turkey, Italian ENI and US major ChevronTexaco.

TotalFinaElf... slowly I turned... Couldn't they just have awared TFE the outhouse-cleaning contract or something?

Meanwhile, Kamal Kharrazi, the Iranian Foreign Minister, said the US sanctions on Iran have cost American oil companies the chance to bid for $4 billion of new oil contracts.

It's very cheering to see a UK newspaper make this not-so-subtle connection. Yes, the US took a principled position on Iraq, and paid a real economic price for it; and yes, the US is taking a principled position on Iran, and is paying a real economic price for it.

 

#58   mickthemick  6/16/2003 08:57AM PST

Despite French opposition to the war, TotalFinaElf was awarded 2m barrels.

I hope all 2m barrels get dumped on Chirac's living room carpet. "No blood for oil" the lefties all sang? It was mostly U.S. blood....and the oil is freely flowing to Europe!!!!

Meanwhile, Kamal Kharrazi, the Iranian Foreign Minister, said the US sanctions on Iran have cost American oil companies the chance to bid for $4 billion of new oil contracts.

No, Kamal, guess again.....U.S. sanctions have cost your stinking mullocracy $4B in new oil contracts. Bravo to U.S. sanctions.

 

#59   Topher  6/16/2003 09:03AM PST

Sorry, 1-800-EUROPE is busy.

Because Charles linked to the Beeb, I actually took a look at the site again, when what to my wondering eyes should appear but a smiling idiot in shiny war gear.

Villepin said France "is ready to do what must be done," meaning that, although they could not tolerate using troops to eliminate a dictator and mass murderer, they are happy to send troops to prevent Israel from fighting terror.

If there is anyone willing to believe les putains de Pétain might be of any value in actually advancing peace, just ask Jan Mol about their performance in the Congo.

Before we descend to French bashing, let's recognize that US politicoes are thinking about sending in US troops, so long as they don't have to fight Hamas.

 

#60   yo  6/16/2003 09:52AM PST

first off, to poster number one, that guy was being VERY sarcastic. a different blog, maybe instapundit, discussed this.

the discussion on peace keeping troops is very enlightening. if even the u.s. is reluctnat to send in troops to battle hamas, you can understand why israel is reluctant to host such a force. the french troops would probably bake yassin and crew baguettes.

 

#61   Susan  6/16/2003 10:34AM PST

Check out this website on BBC Bias run by former Soviet refusenick Vladimir Bukovsky:

http://www.bbcbias.o...

A one-time SOVIET dissident, now living in Britain, thinks that the Baghdad Broadcasting Corp. is a Soviet-style Marxocracy. And he should know, shouldn't he?

 

#62   Topher  6/16/2003 01:59PM PST

More pisse talk from Villepin.

 


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

Link to LGF
LGF Button

never forget

LGF: 9/11 Stories
LGF: Tilly's Story
The Black Day
Remembering 9/11
The Legacy of Flight 93
Sept. 11: A Memorial
We Support You

Palestinians Celebrate 9/11

Middle East Maps

Myths & Facts: A Guide to the Arab-Israeli Conflict

Palestine Facts

An Engineered Tragedy: Statistical Analysis of Casualties in the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict

Palestinian Child Abuse Slideshow

Victims of Saddam

Media Contact Information

LGF News Feeds

world news

Israel Hits Back for Hizbollah Border Attack (Reuters)

Thousands of Iraqis March to Demand Elections (Reuters)

U.S., British, U.N. Experts Begin Disarming Libya (Reuters)

Sistani Ally Urges UN to Focus on Iraq Elections (Reuters)

Roadblocks await U.S. plans for Iraqi self-rule (USATODAY.com)

EU President Seeks Debate on Constitution (AP)

Bush Meets With Iraqi Council Members (AP)

Venezuela's Envoy: Rebel Talks Distorted (AP)

Woman Claims Control of Liberia Rebels (AP)

Indonesia Plant Blast Kills 2, Hurts 68 (AP)

Former Sask. premier Grant Devine announces plans to run for new Tory party (Canadian Press)

Australian Leader Criticizes Schools (AP)

top stories

Democrats Spar in N.H. After Iowa Jolt (AP)

Bush Using Speech to Argue for His Agenda (AP)

Gephardt Quits Second Run for White House (AP)

Stewart Pleads Innocent As Trial Starts (AP)

Bush Meets With Iraqi Council Members (AP)

Israel Planes Attack Hezbollah in Lebanon (AP)

Crooner Dean Says Sara Lee Dropped Him (AP)

Shanghai Students Sue Over Kissing Video (AP)

Dow Falls 53, Nasdaq Gains 6 (AP)

Yankees, Soriano OK $5.4M, One-Year Deal (AP)

Democratic Rivals Battle in New Hampshire (Reuters)

Gephardt Quits Presidential Race After Iowa Defeat (Reuters)

Bush Wants Spotlight with State of Union Speech (Reuters)

Martha Stewart Pleads Not Guilty in Court (Reuters)

More U.S. Herds Quarantined Over Mad Cow (Reuters)

As Dean Slips, The Democrats' Drama Rises (washingtonpost.com)

Domestic Issues Hurt Bush in Poll (washingtonpost.com)

A Final Push On the Eve of Iowa Voting (washingtonpost.com)

Arms Issue Seen as Hurting U.S. Credibility Abroad (washingtonpost.com)

At Least 20 Dead in Baghdad Blast (washingtonpost.com)

news/opinion

ABC News
Arts & Letters Daily
The Asia Times
The Atlantic
BBC
CAMERA
CBS News
Chicago Tribune
City Journal
CNN
C-SPAN
DAFKA
DEBKAfile
Dhimmi Watch
Drudge Report
Faith Freedom International
Foreign Affairs Magazine
The Forward
FOX News
FrontPage
Google News
The Guardian
Ha'aretz
Hugh Hewitt
Honest Reporting
IMRA
The Independent
Institute for the Secularisation of Islamic Society
Israel Insider
Israel National News
Jerusalem Newswire
Jerusalem Post
Jerusalem Post Radio
Jerusalem Report
Jewish World Review
Jihad Watch
LA Examiner
LA Times
London Times
MEMRI
MSNBC News
National Post
National Review
New Republic
Newsisfree
New York Post
New York Times
New York Sun
NPR
The Onion
OpinionJournal
Daniel Pipes
Dennis Prager
Slate
Smarter Times
Mark Steyn Online
Straits Times
Stratfor
Sydney Morning Herald
The Telegraph
TIME
The Times of India
Town Hall
UPI
US News & World Report
USA Today
Washington Post
Washington Times
The Weekly Standard
Wired
Yahoo

anti-idiotarians

Show All

American Kaiser
Backspin
Baldilocks
Marten Barck
Richard Bennett
Roger Bournival
Moira Breen
Barry Briggs
BushtitBloggerzine
Common Sense & Wonder
Shawn Deats
Michael Demmons
Martin Devon
The Diablogger
Matt Drachenberg
Jonathan Edelstein
Jonathan Elliott
EuroPundits
Fatimah
Frank J.
The Gweilo Diaries
Brothers Judd
Evan Kaiser
Liberty Log
James Lileks
Dave Mader
Mideast: On Target
Michael Moynihan
Mudville Gazette
Andrew Northrup
The Occasional
Suman Palit
Tony Pierce
Eric Raymond
Dan Rector
Ribbity Frog
Chas Rich
Rick Richman
Stephen Rittenberg
Patrick Ruffini
Rodger Schuester
Segacs
Kathy Shaidle
Ben Shapiro
Joshua Sharf
UnlearnedHand
Eugene Volokh
Russell Wardlow
Matt Welch
Xipe

 frank says:

Let's just admit that public education is mediocre at best.

bloggage

Show All

A Jaundiced Eye
Aortal
Blogdex
Caterina
Design Is Kinky
Digital Punk
Exhalations
Inflight Correction
K10K
Kuro5hin
Memepool
Meryl's Notes
The Morning News
Plastic
Doc Searls
Slashdot
Snowdeal
Thraxil
Tomalak
Waferbaby
Evan Williams
Xplane
dammitalltohell.com
i.me.michael
kottke.org

web design

A List Apart
CGI Resource Index
coolhomepages.com
Cool Web Design
creativepro.com
CSS Master Grid
CSS Reference Table
Digital Web
Evolt
HTML Tag Reference
javascript.com
O'Reilly
php.net
PHP Builder
PHP Classes
PHP Resource Index
Publish
useit.com
W3C
Web Developer's Journal
WebMonkey
webreference.com
Website Abstraction
Webreview
Website Tips
WebWord

mac

Apple
Applescript Central
As The Apple Turns
MacCentral
MacEdition
MacFixit
MacSlash
Version Tracker

cycling

Lance Armstrong
VeloNews
Cycling News
Eurosport
Updates from OLN
ESPN Interactive TDF Map
AFP Live TDF Updates
BBC Tour de France 2003
Yahoo TDF Photos

LGF home | about | tools | portfolio | contact

© 2003 lgf web design
all rights reserved