print story print story |  email storylast updated: 7/26/2005

Bizarre Child Support Battle In Brooklyn

A child support battle that involves a hospital and a $9 million - it may sound like a soap opera plot but this real life drama is playing out in Brooklyn. The bizarre battle involves a fertility clinic at NYU.

Eyewitness News reporter Michelle Charlesworth is live on Manhattan's east side with the story.

This is a question for men tonight: what happens to sperm in a bank when you stop paying to keep it frozen? Can your estranged wife pick up the freezing bills and use your sperm, then come after you for child support payments? That is at the center of this lawsuit against a sperm bank a wife and a notary public.

This couple is currently getting divorced but before the relationship hit the rocks they were trying to have kids. According to court documents, Mr. Deon Francois' sperm was frozen at NYU. Then the break up happened - about two-and-a-half years ago. Mrs. Francois continued to pay $500 a year to keep the sperm frozen and underwent in vitro.

Mr. Francois says he didn't know about any of this, in fact, he didn't know that she was still trying to get pregnant. He thought that if nobody was paying to freeze the sperm, it would be thrown away and it was a non-issue.

John James, Deon Francois' Attorney: "He did not want a child at that time and he did not give any kind of written or oral consent for NYU to use the sperm, in fact didn't pay storage fees. He moved out, he forgot about the whole plan of having children with Chaamel."

But Mrs. Francois attorney says not only did her husband know, he was cashing thousands in refunds from the couple's insurance company - reimbursement for fertility bills that she had already paid.

Steven Gildin, Chaamel Francois' Attorney: "What do you do in a situation when a man relies on a woman who says 'I'm on birth control' but she's lying. Or what if the birth control just fails? Does that father then have the right to walk away from his financial responsibilies? It's the same thing."

Now the embryo is an 8-month old baby boy and a judge says Mr. Francois owes $150 a week in child support. What about a legal release to use the frozen sperm? She says he signed one, he says it's a fake.

What about a notary? She says it's notarized, he says it's a fake, and his attorney says his client has run out of money.

John James, Deon Francois' Attorney: "He wants to focus now on concluding the divorce matter and focusing on the case against NYU the notary and his wife. Well he needs to be compensated and he has to pay child support and it's going to cost maybe several million to raise a child in the 21st century."

No comment from NYU tonight and Mrs. Chaamel Francois is pregnant again and her attorney says he will go after Mr. Francois for child support because she became pregnant while they were married and that is what the law supports.

  • Message Board: Talk About This Story
  • Please Note that Video Clips in News Stories will Remain Active for 5 Days after the Story is Published

    Strange News Headlines
  • World's Highest Toilet Built In Australia
  • Big Nose Bandit On The Loose In Austria
  • Naked Gardener Denied Nude Burial
  • Man Pays Speeding Ticket With 12,000 Pennies
  • Worm Rancher Finally Gets Some Respect


  • Another Long, Hot Day For Jersey City Fire Victims
  • Search for Answers after Boy Dies on Water Ride
  • Huge Burst of Flames Tear Through Restaurant
  • Alleged Bank Robber Winds Up in the Water
  • Old Commercial Plant Catches Fire
  • Dean Faiello Pleads Not Guilty
  • Driver In Wild Police Chase Head to Court
  • Hofstra University Attempts to Ban Illegal Music Downloading
  • 'Snuppy' Not Your Average Puppy; He's Cloned
  • Martha Stewart's Home Confinement Extended 3 Weeks


  • Chief Justice Rehnquist Returns To Hospital
  • Al-Quida's Zawahri Threatens More London Attacks
  • Discovery's Crew Set to Honor Fallen Columbia Astronauts
  • Zambia to Deport Terror Suspect to Britain
  • Air France Crash in Toronto Most Likely Weather Related


  • Jackson Jury Member Publishing Book Saying 'He's Guilty?'
  • Yoko Ono Felt Hated By the World
  • Lachey Denies He's Splitting from Jessica Simpson
  • Shelby Lynne Very Intimate in New Album
  • Michael Jackson's Ex-Wife Wants To See Her Kids
  • Jennifer Aniston Speaks Out About Split With Pitt
  • Nicole Kidman Shortens Break for More Money
  • Sean William Scott Doesn't Mind Being the 'Dunce'
  • Julia Roberts Coming to Broadway
  • Jennifer Aniston Gets a Picture Break

  •  Friday, August 05, 2005

    Tonight at 5pm:
    Click for a Flash Preview!

    Be the First to Know! Get Breaking News Delivered to Your In-Box for FREE!!

    Your Email:

    Already a member? Sign in
    Get Your Accu-Weather Desktop Alerts
    Weather News You Need, & Breaking News You Want!

  • Scotland Yard Fuming Over NYPD Terror Leak
  • Crackdown On Shoddy Plastic Surgeries
  • Pataki Vetoes 'Morning-After Pill' Bill
  • New Jersey Bear Attack Caught On Tape
  • Man Charged With Providing Support To Terrorists In N.J.
  • Orioles Fire Lee Mazzilli
  • City Being Sued for Random Bag Searches

    HAZE   Currently: 80
    High: 94

    Metro Radar Northern NJ

  • Get YOUR Local Radar
  • 5-Day and Hourly
  • Bill Evans' Home Page

    Connecting with Kids: What You Can Do
    From insomnia to STD's to questions about when they're really ready for college: Kids face a long list of challenges every day. Here are resources for parents.
  •  BACK TO TOP  HOME | | | |
    Advertise on this Site | Contact Us
    Copyright ©2005 ABC Inc., WABC-TV Inc.
    Terms of Use, UPDATED Privacy Policy and Internet Safety Information for this site.