Logo

Home
Top News
Trials
People
Photo Galleries
Video
Court TV Extra
Primetime

13th Juror
Legal Help
Most Wanted
Chat
Message Boards
Newsletters

The Smoking Gun
Crime Library
Choices and Consequences

About Court TV
Store

Site Map
 
 
 
Updated Nov. 10, 2005, 11:33 p.m. ET

Judge tosses haunted house owner's 'Amityville' defamation suit
George Lutz
Ryan Reynolds played George Lutz in the 2005 remake of the classic spook show 'The Amityville Horror.'

LOS ANGELESA judge has ruled against former haunted house owner George Lutz, who claims he was defamed after being falsely portrayed in "The Amityville Horror" remake as an ax-wielding dog killer.

Lutz's real-life ordeal living in a spooked Long Island home was the subject of the bestselling 1977 book "The Amityville Horror," which inspired the film of the same name and several sequels, including a 2005 remake starring actor Ryan Reynolds as Lutz.

Lutz filed a defamation and breach of contract suit this summer against Dimension Films, MGM, United Artists, and the producers and screenwriters involved in the remake.

Lutz maintains that he was terrorized by demonic apparitions and voices while he and his wife and children lived in the Dutch Colonial home where an entire family had been murdered in their sleep in the early 1970s.

Story continues
advertisement

However, Lutz says he never killed his beloved Labrador retriever, nor did he chase after his wife and children with an ax, as his namesake character does in the film.

Lutz claimed he suffered "loss of reputation, shame, mortification and hurt feelings" from the movie's depiction of him as "a homicidal maniac."

But a judge sided with the defendants, saying that the film was a work of fiction protected under the First Amendment, and that it fell within California's anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation) statute designed to protect free speech.

"The remake of 'The Amityville Horror' is an activity of widespread public interest," Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu wrote in his order filed on Oct. 31. "It is a movie viewed by millions of fans and generating millions of dollars for the defendants who participated in writing the screenplay, producing the movie, and distributing the 2005 remake."

While the judge agreed with the studio's request to strike Lutz's defamation complaint under the anti-SLAPP law, SLAPPs are typically identified as suits filed by large corporations against individuals to intimidate or discourage public criticism.

Oprah Winfrey became a SLAPP defendant when she defeated a 1998 libel suit by Texas cattle ranchers, who claimed the talk show host sent the beef market in a downward spiral after telling viewers that she had sworn off hamburgers because of mad cow disease.

Judge Treu also upheld a release agreement Lutz signed nearly 28 years ago with the original film's producers, in which Lutz consented to allowing filmmakers to alter characters and agreed not to sue for defamation.

"We're disappointed in the ruling and we're exploring our options," said Lutz's attorney Larry Zerner. "In the meantime, the rest of the case goes forward."

The judge's ruling did not affect Lutz's breach-of-contract claim. The plaintiff says Dimension has yet to pay him a promised percentage of net and merchandising profits, as well as $50,000 once the film exceeded $10 million in box-office receipts. The picture has grossed more than $81 million since its April release, according to Lutz's June complaint.

Ronald DeFeo Jr.

In November 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. shot his mother, father, two brothers and two sisters as they lay asleep in their beds in the now-infamous white clapboard house with the jack-o'-lantern bay windows.

Lutz purchased the home a year later. After 28 days, he fled with his family in the middle of the night, leaving their possessions behind, never to return.

DeFeo, 54, is serving 25 years to life in prison. He was denied parole by a three-member review panel in September. His next parole hearing is scheduled for September 2007.

E-mail | Print



Shows On Court TV
Weekly Schedule
Today's Trials
Saddam Hussein on Trial

FL v. LaFave -
Florida Teacher Sex scandal

FL v. Smith -
Child Abduction Murder Sentencing

Primetime
The Investigators
8:00pm: "Fatal Passion" - A politician's love affair ends in murder.

Forensic Files
  • 9:00pm: "For Love or Money" - A blood spatter expert and a scuba diver carry out a millionaire's last wish.

  • 9:30pm: "The Talking Skull" - When a skull is found at a Boy Scout Camp, a forensic anthropologist recreates the face and leads investigators straight to the killer.

  • 10:00pm: "The House That Roared" - A missing woman's husband is trapped in a web of deceit.

  • 10:30pm: "Foundation of Lies" - A pile of concrete holds the clues to find a missing woman.

    *All times ET
  •  

     

    Contact us
    ©2005 Courtroom Television Network LLC. All Rights Reserved.
    Terms & Privacy Guidelines

     
    advertisement