we have met the enemy and he is US
(with apologies to Walt Kelley.) here are a few of the latest homeland insecurity stories and matters somewhat related: Homeland Security opening private mail: ‘In the 50 years that Grant Goodman has known and corresponded with a colleague in the Philippines he never had any reason to suspect that their friendship was anything but spectacularly ordinary. But now he believes that the relationship has somehow sparked the interest of the Department of Homeland Security and led the agency to place him under surveillance.
‘Last month Goodman, an 81-year-old retired University of Kansas history professor, received a letter from his friend in the Philippines that had been opened and resealed with a strip of dark green tape bearing the words “by Border Protection” and carrying the official Homeland Security seal. “I had no idea (Homeland Security) would open personal letters,” Goodman told MSNBC.com in a phone interview. “That’s why I alerted the media. I thought it should be known publicly that this is going on,” he said…
‘…Goodman is no stranger to mail snooping; as an officer during World War II he was responsible for reading all outgoing mail of the men in his command and censoring any passages that might provide clues as to his unit’s position. “But we didn’t do it as clumsily as they’ve done it, I can tell you that,” Goodman noted, with no small amount of irony in his voice. “Isn’t it funny that this doesn’t appear to be any kind of surreptitious effort here,” he said…’
John at Americablog says it best: ‘Fifteen years after we defeat the Soviet Union we become them.’
hey John, 9/11 changed everything!. fave comment: ‘…we sent in our little Manchurian Candidate, and you all ate it up. A failure in his private life, a miserable shit of a man, and still almost half of you voted for him!!! Beautiful!!! Diebold did the rest. and so many of you were so happy to sell your country down the river that it was easy as apple pie. *snicker*
‘Even when we made “Free Speech Zones” and Town Hall Meetings by appointment only — the most “patriotic” of you all fell for it!!…We gave you Pravda, and the Red States gave us a hug!!! And since we have not been a part of the arms race for the last twenty years, we’ve saved a lot of money. The gap in the last five years with Comrade George’s drunken spending and ill conceived war…. HAHAHAHAHA!!!! Just wait until you realize that Russia never dissolved, it was all just smoke and mirrors. Now we own you suckers!!! Back In The U.S.aS.R. Red Dawn is coming for you all.’
and ‘…Homeland Security has 180,000 employees who can’t get a truck full of water to New Orleans! They should pay back all of their salaries! Now we have all of these people opening our mail. The money to pay them is coming from our pockets. They are making us pay to have our rights taken!…’
yup — we’re all paying for this shit of course, but dig this: MSNBC is asking people to vote ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on ‘Do you support allowing Customs and Border Protection to open private correspondence sent to U.S. citizens from abroad?’. right now, 17% say ‘yes.’ i’ll betcha anything that the 17% are white, think they’re Christian, ’support’ the troops with ribbons and shit and live in the midwest and/or fly over country in small towns — not from our unprotected coasts or other urban areas. but truly, this is amazing to me, people — so keep on watchin’ Big Brother on TV, (and forget the real Big Bro’ snooping around in your personal shit); keep on buyin’ stuff y’all don’t need and thinkin’ that the current admin will keep US safer by taking away our rights and privacy. and totally forget what Benjamin Franklin said: ‘Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.’ forgotten? good. |-(
next up: Canuck yanked off Mexico flight: ‘A Canadian citizen on the U.S. no-fly list is demanding answers after receiving no explanation for why he was yanked off a flight his family was taking to a dream vacation in Mexico. Sami Kahil, his wife, Rima Masri, and their two sons, Karim, 8, and Adam, 6, where bound for an Ixtapa vacation to celebrate the couple’s 10th wedding anniversary when Mexican officials pulled him off the Air Transat flight on Thursday, he said after returning home early yesterday morning.
“They told me I was wanted in Canada but they didn’t tell me why,” said Kahil, 38, who was born in Lebanon but moved to Canada 20 years ago and is now a citizen and has a Canadian passport. “I said to them, ‘Canada wants me? I just came from Canada and nobody said anything to me there,’ ” the shoe store owner recounted, adding he’s never had so much as a parking ticket…’
but dude, you’re totally guilty of having a Middle Eastern-ish name, right? and your skin’s prolly brownish, so you’re guilty of that as well and so’s the rest of your family (maybe not little ‘Adam’ cause his name is English — if that’s his real name). does anybody know how much this shit costs US? who cares, right? cause we’re the world’s richest country and the money funding the DHS couldn’t be used for better things.
Author of book critical of Karl Rove can’t get off aviation watch list (i’m shocked — shocked, i tell you): ‘Houstonians familiar with the work and character of former KHOU-TV Channel 11 reporter Jim Moore will be as surprised as he was a year ago to learn that the government had placed his name on the watch list designed to keep suspected terrorists off U.S. airliners. Moore is also the co-author, with Wayne Slater, of the best-selling Bush’s Brain, a critical examination of the role of political adviser Karl Rove in George W. Bush’s ascension to the presidency.
criticising Karl Rove? guilty of treason! case closed — next! *cough* anyway, ‘As a result of his inclusion on the list, Moore cannot get pre-printed boarding passes and must submit to time-consuming security checks of his identity before boarding commercial flights. In his predicament, he joins a 4-year-old boy stopped at Bush Intercontinental Airport last month and Northfield, Minn., Police Chief Gary Gordon Smith, who also has been unable to get his name removed. Such politicians as U.S. Sen. Ted Kennedy, D-Mass., and U.S. Rep. Don Young, R-Alaska, wound up briefly on the Transportation and Security Administration watch list created after the 9/11 terrorist attacks. The TSA watch list and a more restrictive no-fly list include the names of between 70,000 and 160,000 persons.
‘A lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union caused the Justice Department to release documents indicating confusion over how names were put on the lists and how to remove them. An FBI agent characterized the lists “as virtually worthless — garbage in and garbage out.”
are there any competent people left at DHS? lemme see, once upon a time there was Paul Redmond: ‘After a long career at the CIA, Redmond became the Assistant Secretary for Information Analysis at the Department of Homeland Security. When, according to Notra Trulock of Accuracy in Media, he reported, at a congressional hearing in June 2003, “that he didn’t have enough analysts to do the job… [and] his office still lacked the secure communications capability to receive classified reports from the intelligence community… [t]hat kind of candor was not appreciated by his bosses and, consequently, he had to go.” Resigned, June 2003.’
la la laaaaah! tough shit, Paul — we can’t hear youuuuu! back to James Moore, ‘After being on the watch list for a year, Moore has yet to get an explanation of why he was put on it or how he can get his name removed. “My friends tell me it is just more government incompetence,” he wrote in an Internet posting. “A tech buddy said there’s no one in government smart enough to write a search algorithm that will find actual terrorists, so they end up with authors of books criticizing the Bush White House. I have no idea what’s going on.” Judging by the similar plight of dozens of other passengers, including children, it would seem that the TSA compilers of the no-fly watch list are equally clueless.’
James Moore in his own words: ‘…"Well, let me get this straight then,” I said. “Our government is looking for a guy who may have a mundane Anglo name, who pays tens of thousands of dollars every year in taxes, has never been arrested or even late on a credit card payment, is more uninteresting than a Tupperware party, and cries after the first two notes of the national anthem? We need to find this guy. He sounds dangerous to me…One last thing: this guy they are looking for? Did he write books critical of the Bush administration, too?”
‘I have been on the No Fly Watch List for a year. I will never be told the official reason. No one ever is. You cannot sue to get the information. Nothing I have done has moved me any closer to getting off the list. There were 35,000 Americans in that database last year. According to a European government that screens hundreds of thousands of American travelers every year, the list they have been given to work from has since grown to 80,000…’
Lean Left: ‘A critic of the president has just had his right to travel taken from him. There was no trial, he was not allowed to present a defense and to this day he can neither find out exactly why he was denied his rights or how he can have the situation rectified. Air flight is one of the primary methods of long distance travel in this country. Millions of people depend upon it to conduct their business. And yet it can be taken away with no recourse or notification and, at least in one case, in that looks to be a case of petty revenge against a critic of the government. How many others are on these lists because of their activism or public opinions? Since the process is secret, there is no way to know.
‘But we do know that peace activists have found themselves on this list before, with no way off of it. That can certainly appear to be sinister. At a minimum, it appears that the list is managed so poorly that innocent people are placed on it regularly. It is not outside the realm of conjecture to suppose that over-zealousness results in people engaging in protected activism and speech critical of the government on the list because of that activism. And if your livelihood depended on being able to fly, well, who would blame you for thinking twice about writing that op-ed or signing that petition? Especially considering that you could never get off the list?
‘Even if one assumes only incompetence, how did one terrorist attack turn us from a nation that joked about Russians showing their travel permits to a nation that took away the right of travel without justification or recourse? How did we let Bush’s fear dominate our policy to such a ridiculous degree?‘
cuz we’re all dumbasses? and serious protest was marginalised since right before Reagan a few years after ‘Nam? fave comments on this page (no direct links): ‘I am beginning to believe that George Orwell worked for the CIA and wrote all that stuff about Big Brother just to soften us up for when it really came.’ and ‘In a functioning democracy, this would be illegal. The question is, where do we look for justice when every venue is owned by BushCo?’
good question. more: ‘Can’t happen here? The lists have appeared (80,000-plus at least and growing). The willing commissars are in place (from the White House, Justice Dept, Pentagon, etc., on down to local deputy sheriffs). The military is dutiful. The pretexts are well-rehearsed. The national opinion has been conditioned into fear and submission (Do unto others…as long as it’s not done to me). It’s begun. When will it happen in full? Whenever a few people at the top feel it’s needed, if not this administration then during an even worse one. Only you can stop it — maybe.’
finally, ‘Again the illusion of security. Taking our swiss pocket knives, scissors etc. really makes us safe. Still no checking of the cargo carried on commercial flights. Our borders are as porous as swiss cheese, if in fact foreign nationals are caught, they’re given a court date and let go. A confederacy of dunces…’
The Wire-Tappers That Couldn’t Shoot Straight by Frank Rich: ‘…the White House’s over-the-top outrage about the Times scoop is a smokescreen contrived to cover up something else is only confirmed by Dick Cheney’s disingenuousness. In last week’s oration at a right-wing think tank, he defended warrant-free wiretapping by saying it could have prevented the 9/11 attacks. Really? Not with this administration in charge.
did anyone bother to remind self-appointed VP ‘other priorities = five deferments’ Cheney that there was this unimportant little memo called ‘bin Laden Determined to Strike Within the US’ just about a month or so before 9/11 and the preznit was busy ‘clearing brush’ nobody gave a shit?
‘On 9/10 the N.S.A. (lawfully) intercepted messages in Arabic saying, “The match is about to begin,” and, “Tomorrow is zero hour.” You know the rest. Like all the chatter our government picked up during the president’s excellent brush-clearing Crawford vacation of 2001, it was relegated to mañana; the N.S.A. didn’t rouse itself to translate those warnings until 9/12…
‘…The highest priority for the Karl Rove-driven presidency is…to preserve its own power at all costs. With this gang, political victory and the propaganda needed to secure it always trump principles, even conservative principles, let alone the truth. Whenever the White House most vociferously attacks the press, you can be sure its No. 1 motive is to deflect attention from embarrassing revelations about its incompetence and failures…‘
speaking of incompetence and failures, whatever happened to those anthrax attacks right after 9/11? the last thing i read was ‘The government successfully has stalled legal action over its role in the 2001 anthrax death of Boca Raton photo editor Bob Stevens. That’s a criminal case…’ so i guess we caught the perps and it’s all good, right?
Frank Rich: ‘…That’s also why the White House tried in May to blame lethal anti-American riots in Afghanistan and Pakistan on a single erroneous Newsweek item about Koran desecration — as if 200-odd words in an American magazine could take the fall for the indelible photos from Abu Ghraib.
‘Such is the blame-shifting game Mr. Cheney was up to last week. By dragging 9/11 into his defense of possibly unconstitutional bugging, he was hoping to rewrite history to absolve the White House of its bungling. And no wonder. He knows all too well that the timing of Mr. Bush’s signing of the secret executive order to initiate the desperate tactic of warrant-free N.S.A. eavesdropping — early 2002, according to Mr. Risen’s new book, “State of War” — is nothing if not a giant arrow pointing to one of the administration’s most catastrophic failures. It was only weeks earlier, in December 2001, that we had our best crack at nailing Osama bin Laden in Tora Bora and blew it…
‘…We don’t know whether the Bush order relaxing legal controls on the N.S.A. was in part a Hail Mary pass to help compensate for that disaster. Either way, all the subsequent wiretaps in the world have not brought bin Laden back dead or alive. Though the White House says that its warrantless surveillance has saved lives by stopping other terrorists since then, Mr. Bush has exaggerated victories against Al Qaeda as often as he has the battle-readiness of Iraqi troops. After he claimed in an October speech that America and its allies had foiled 10 Qaeda plots since 9/11, USA Today reported that “at least” 6 of the 10 had been preliminary ideas for attacks rather than actual planned attacks.
‘The louder the reports of failures on this president’s watch, the louder he tries to drown them out by boasting that he has done everything “within the law” to keep America safe and by implying that his critics are unpatriotic, if not outright treasonous. Mr. Bush certainly has good reason to pump up the volume now. In early December the former 9/11 commissioners gave the federal government a report card riddled with D’s and F’s on terrorism preparedness.
‘The front line of defense against terrorism is supposed to be the three-year-old, $40-billion-a-year Homeland Security Department, but news of its ineptitude, cronyism and no-bid contracts has only grown since Katrina. The Washington Post reported that one Transportation Security Administration contract worth up to $463 million had gone to a brand-new company that (coincidentally, we’re told) contributed $122,000 to a powerful Republican congressman, Harold Rogers of Kentucky. An independent audit by the department’s own inspector general, largely unnoticed during Christmas week, found everything from FEMA to border control in some form of disarray…’
uh oh… y’hear that, Osama? LOL, who’s surprised here? as a totally patriotic amerikan or whatever (U! S! A! U! S! A!) i think it’s time to go after the waaay unpatriotic Frank Rich (and the rest of his treasonous ilk) for helping the enemy. do we still have laws against sedition? i dunno, but Frank Rich should totally be hung — yes, by the balls — for giving aid and comfort to Osama Saddam the enemy, whatever his/her/its name is.
finally, in other news that has nothing — on the surface — to do with Homeland (in)Security, IRS Tracked Taxpayers’ Political Affiliation about which The Unknown Candidate writes: ‘What next? Now we find out the IRS is spying on us.
‘It seems that while hunting “down tax scofflaws, the Internal Revenue Service” has been collecting the political party affiliations of taxpayers in 20 states. According to Deputy IRS Commissioner John Dalrymple, “the party identification information was automatically collected through a ‘database platform’ supplied by an outside contractor that targeted voter registration rolls among other things as it searched for people who aren’t paying their taxes.” According to Dalrymple, “This information is appropriately used to locate information on taxpayers whose accounts are delinquent.”
‘An IRS spokesman claimed the information was never used as “there are strict laws in place that forbid it.” So which is it? Used? or not used? And WHAT RIGHT DOES THE IRS HAVE TO COLLECT THIS INFORMATION ANYWAY?!!
they don’t, dude, and you and i and millions more know it. ‘Senator Patty Murray (D-Wash), a member of an appropriations subcommittee with jurisdiction over the IRS called the practice an “outrageous violation of the public trust.” Murray was told of the practice by Colleen Kelly, president of the National Treasury Employees Union (not part of the IRS). According to Murray, the IRS “should not have that type of information.”
‘Even more troubling is that the IRS intends to start using private collection agencies later this year to go after back taxes. Kelly wants Congress to “suspend IRS plans to use private collection agencies until these questions have been resolved.” Cutting to the nitty gritty of the problem, Murray said, “No one should question whether they are being audited because of party affiliation.”
The Unknown Candidate: ‘Funny, I was audited for the first time in my life a few years ago, when I was actively campaigning for a democratic candidate…’ read the rest of his horror story here. and it is a horror story — i’m fucking totally disgusted. Digby: ‘I have long thought that privacy is a potent issue for Democrats and all these nasty revelations about Republican snooping and interefering in people’s personal decisions just make it more so. With the exception of a few sincere Goldwaterites who have all passed on, the libertarian strain in the Republican party was always just a simple cultural appeal on guns and taxes. History shows that they clearly favor big government that serves their corporate special interests and are more than willing to use the full force of the state at their discretion. (This is most vividly demonstrated by the new presidential infallibility doctrine on one hand and Terry Schiavo on the other.)
‘Between the Bedwetter Caucus and the Christian Right you also have a very large faction of the GOP that considers people with opposing views to be dangerous. The true philosophy of modern conservatism is about control and domination, not freedom and equality…this issue pertains to Republican (and, frankly, certain Democratic) partners in crime as well — the corporations and the “contractors” who are invading citizens’ privacy these days as if all information is not only public, it is also for sale.’
somewhat related in a weirdass wingnutty way, i now have absolutely no doubt that the mail-in absentee ballot for the last fucked US election arrived here late — a week after the ‘election’ — on purpose (i’d asked for one 3X, starting months before). this was apart from the fact that i had my sister in NYC mail me one ‘just in case’ and a week or so before 3. november 2004, i filled it out and sent it the fastest way from the UK to US — it cost me a bundle and i hope it was counted but i’ll never ever be sure).
Digby, again: ‘Finally, somebody in the press wakes up:
“But the climate of those years was so grim that half the Washington press corps spent more time worrying about having their telephones tapped than they did about risking the wrath of Rove, Libby and Cheney by poking at the weak seams of a Mafia-style administration that began cannibalizing the whole government just as soon as it came into power. Bush’s capos were never subtle; they swaggered into Washington like a conquering army, and the climate of fear they engendered apparently neutralized The New York Times along with all the other pockets of potential resistance. Bush had to do everything but fall on his own sword before anybody in the Washington socio-political establishment was willing to take him on.”
‘Oh sorry. Transcription problem. That was actually Hunter S. Thompson, in the October 10, 1974 Rolling Stone, writing about the Nixon administration. My bad.’
*bangs head into desk* trying to split on a somewhat upbeat ‘it’s funny cuz it’s true’ note, since i totally feel i have some halfass moral obligation not to depress people as much as i am over whatever amerikan news, check the Conservative Threat Level T-Shirt: i think we’re somewhere between orange (’church and state to merge’) and red (’return to middle ages likely’), but hey, it could be worse. i think. maybe. nah, who am i kidding? fuuuuuck.