Published July 11, 2005
Who'll drive your freight?
A severe shortage of long-haul heavy-duty truck drivers is around the corner. A report
released last month by the American Trucking Association warns that the shortfall of
long-distance, or over-the-road (OTR), truck drivers is growing dramatically: from 20,000 in
2004 to 45,000 in 2009 to 111,000 by 2014.
Fleetmaster's Linnie Gregory: 'We may be headed toward catastrophe'
Contributing to the impending driver shortage is a combination of demographics, growing
national demand for shipped goods, a sky-high turnover rate among truck drivers (120 percent
nationally), erratic income, long stretches away from home, and a strong economy offering
more attractive job opportunities.
What does that mean for Blue Ridge Region businesses? "You can't sell what you don't have,"
says Pam Osborne, driver recruiter for Mid-Atlantic Drivers, a truck driver temporary agency
in Roanoke. "What good is a truck sitting in a parking lot without a driver?"
She adds a sobering thought: "In years past, we've had truckers strike over pay issues."
Indeed, one year ago, the Port of Miami was effectively shut down for two weeks as part of a
nationwide truckers' strike.
This is an unlikely scenario locally, says Osborne, because drivers are in a Catch-22
Even though the economy depends on them, they cannot risk losing any income. "They're not in
an industry where they can save a lot of money," she says.
"We may be heading toward a catastrophe," suggests Linnie Gregory, corporate secretary of
Fleetmaster Express, a regional carrier with 275 OTR drivers with headquarters in Roanoke.
"The truckload carriers have been hit the hardest."
The pressure to find drivers is intense because "we've become rolling warehouses-if we can't
get [the trucks] rolling, [products] can't get there."
"I talk to members weekly who say they have trucks sitting at their terminals because they
can't find qualified people to haul them," says Dale Bennett, executive director of the
Virginia Trucking Association.
Gregory confirms this. "We sometimes have as many as 15 to 20 trucks sitting idle because we
don't have the drivers."
"The recruiting wars are unbelievable between trucking companies," says Bennett. "There's a
joke going around that says, 'If a truck dealer could sell a truck with a driver, they'd
make a killing.'"
Tim Shepherd is vice-president for safety and risk management for Howell's Motor Freight in
Cloverdale. His company employs 180 drivers. He says there are many factors contributing to
the driver shortage:
* Poor quality of life. "Trucking is considered a third- choice job. The drivers are gone
all week from their families, they eat fast food, they have irregular hours, and they often
receive poor treatment from shippers and receivers."
* Retiring drivers. "A lot of our guys are older." Shepherd estimates that about 25 percent
of his drivers will retire in the next 10 years.
* Fewer younger entrants. "High school graduates can't come directly into the industry,"
because the minimum OTR driving age is 21. There's a three-year gap where they get
sidetracked by other opportunities.
* Weaker work ethic. He believes that the younger generation's attitude is: "We want it
* Razor-thin profit margins: "We're fortunate if we can make a nickel a mile," which makes
it difficult to increase salaries and benefits.
Gregory adds some more reasons for driver shortages: "There's a very high percentage that
just move around; some leave and come back, and some are leaving the trucking industry
"We're between a rock and a hard place," adds Bennett. "When the economy is not doing well,
we have plenty of drivers; when it's good, you lose the pool."
New anti-terrorism regulations are making the situation worse.
According to a recent article on TheTrucker.com, a trucking news site, "As of May 31 every
hazardous materials hauler, even those who have hauled hazmat loads for as many as 30 years,
must undergo a fingerprint-based background check." It is estimated that this requirement
will affect 84 percent (2.7 million) of current hazmat drivers.
"It's going to affect us a tremendous amount," says Jim Doss, recruiting and safety manager
for Harris Trucking Company in Madison Heights. The firm is a certified hazmat courier with
about 170 drivers. "Some drivers will not be qualified [by an investigation], or they will
be hindered by the additional expense and time [required by the process]."
Furthermore, he says, "There are only 12 offices where you can get the fingerprinting. The
drivers must drive to Roanoke or Lynchburg."
Why it matters
"It hasn't reached the critical stage yet," says Shepherd. "There are still enough drivers
to get product moved." But change may be in the works. If the driver shortage increases, he
says, "The carriers are going to have their choice of customers."
"The less desirable [shipping customers] won't be able to find a carrier," he says.
"Those shippers who pay a good rate, treat drivers well, pay their bills on time-carriers
will want to do business with them."
What will happen, he says, is that "we'll rank them. This shipper-number one-he'll get all
the trucks he wants; number 10 won't get any."
"It's happening already, to a limited degree," says Shepherd. "During our last safety
meeting, for the first time, we took a poll of the drivers, and asked them 'Which shippers
do you like best?'"
He also warns that consolidation within the shipping industry is going to decrease the
availability of freight carriers.
"The major shippers, such as Hershey or M&M; Mars, used to do business with dozens of
carriers. Now they want to limit the number of carriers they use. Therefore, they'll be
taking more driving assets off the streets."
"Potentially, the little guy down the street with one load may not be able to find a truck."
Shepherd describes how the situation will affect everyone: the shortage of drivers plus a
shortage of trucks will result in higher demand, leading to higher compensation rates to
attract drivers, followed by consumer price increases.
Doss describes it from another angle: "The shortage of truck drivers is like a shortage of
labor anywhere-the more productivity you have, the more income you can have."
What to do
"The overall industry has been making changes," says Doss. His suggestions:
* Insurance. Make insurance more affordable for carriers.
* Regulations. Ease up on the new hazmat regulations-"It adds a deterrent." He says it takes
an average of 90 days, plus an investment of $90 to $100, to get the necessary endorsements.
* Benefits. Increase benefits such as more home time, or being home at a regular time; focus
on driver quality of life.
* Fuel costs. These costs affect the profit margin, which means companies are unable to pay
* Training. There needs to be a focus on good, qualified schools, with better screening of
Duncan Quicke is the coordinator for the truck driver training school of Southside Virginia
The program is offered in South Boston and Blackstone, locations where many are seeking
retraining, he says.
But even with six training programs per year, the school graduates only about 100 drivers
from the two sites combined.
"We keep our programs small [about a dozen students each] to be more quality-focused."
He has two suggestions for addressing the driver shortage:
* Younger drivers. "An 18- year-old can get a commercial drivers license, but can't leave
the state or haul hazardous materials." He wishes there would be a pilot program, testing
the use of drivers between the ages of 18 and 21.
* Military experience. "Retiring military have a hard time making the transition into the
private sector because the Department of Motor Vehicles doesn't recognize their
Doss says Harris Trucking has responded to the situation by "increasing our mileage per
unit-driving each truck more miles, and getting even more productivity out of our
people-while still balancing driver quality of life."
The issue of quality of life comes up over and over again. "A lot of companies think pay is
the primary issue," says Shepherd, "but in my opinion, the pay attracts people initially,
but quality of life keeps them with you."
Yet, addressing quality-of-life issues makes the driver shortage even more acute.
He explains that in order to be home more regularly, freight runs are shortened and set up
as relays, with one driver handing the truck off to another.
But achieving this scenario would require an explosion in the number of truck drivers. "We
don't see it in sight," he says. "The bigger problem is making someone say 'I really want to
be a truck driver.' I haven't met anyone who's figured out how to do that yet."
(Deborah Nason is a contributing editor for the Business Journal. She lives in Roanoke
Printer Friendly Version