Headlines    First Look    The Dotted Line    E! News
Ashlee in Synch on "SNL"

by Joal Ryan
Oct 11, 2005, 2:15 PM PT

It's a draw: The singing Ashlee Simpson is as big an attraction as the non-singing Ashlee Simpson.

Overnight ratings for Saturday's Saturday Night Live in which the pop star vocalized without incident were on par with last year's career-threatening hoedown on the same show.

a d v e r t i s e m e n t

Watch The Vine @ E! Online

While total viewers numbers weren't available early Tuesday, NBC said the telecast pulled in ratings virtually identical to the October 2004 SNL in which 6.4 million witnessed Simpson pull a jig when her pre-recorded backing tracks took an unscheduled solo.

On Saturday, Simpson, 21, performed two songs in the manner befitting the "live" in the NBC comedy show's title: "Catch Me When I Fall" and "Boyfriend."

Simpson, for one, was pleased with her return to the SNL studio. "I feel good about facing one of [my] biggest fears, and feel even better knowing you were all there right behind me," she wrote on her Website.

If audiences have been loath to forget Simpson's tape machine ways--they booed her at the Orange Bowl--then the entertainer hasn't been able to shake the experience, either. On Saturday's show, Simpson said she wrote "Catch Me When I Fall" after last year's SNL snafu. And according to the Los Angeles Times, at least one other track off the singer's I Am Me album (due out Oct. 18), "Beautifully Broken," is also about the screw-up.

As an aside, "Boyfriend" supposedly is about the young love triangle of Simpson, Wilmer Valderrama and Lindsay Lohan--a trio that likely would score big ratings, live or on tape.

Elsewhere in the TV week ended Sunday, per Nielsen Media Research:

  • ABC's Commander in Chief (eighth place, 16.9 million) is pulling rank on Tuesday nights, as evidenced by CBS' lagging Amazing Race: Family Edition (31st place, 11.2 million). But Commander creator Rod Lurie won't be around to celebrate--he's been replaced as day-to-day executive producer by Hill Street Blues vet Steven Bochco.
  • The summer was no fluke: CBS' non-sexy NCIS (ninth place, 16.9 million) is hot, now up more than 15 percent from last season.
  • Two and a Half Men (16th place, 14.2 million) has yet to equal one Everybody Loves Raymond for CBS on Monday nights.
  • ABC's Invasion (29th place, 11.4 million) has slowed, now down about 30 percent from its premiere.
  • Oh, for the good old days of last season when getting killed on Wednesday nights meant 11.1 million watched NBC's The West Wing (56th place, 8 million), now getting killed on Sunday nights.
  • So, much for one serial killer's delusions of grandeur. The CBS docudrama The Hunt for the BTK Killer (50th place, 8 million) ran a distant fourth Sunday night.
  • Here's a scary story: ABC's Night Stalker (73rd place, 5.9 million) down 17 percent from its pretty dead premiere.
  • The ABC Tuesday comedies According to Jim (50th place 8 million) and Rodney (58th place, 7.5 million) delivered "strong audience retentions," which aren't really like laughs, but apparently important nonetheless.
  • What does Jennie Garth know--and does she have pictures? The WB canceled Don Johnson's would-be comeback, Just Legal, after a 105th place finish (2.9 million) and three airdates. Garth's What I Like About You, meanwhile, motors on for the netlet after a 115th place finish (2.1 million) and 71 other episodes that were just as little-watched.
  • In other WB news, Related (105th place, 2.8 million) is no Gilmore Girls (73rd place, 6 million).
  • The just-concluded So You Think You Can Dance (50th place, 8.2 million) was no Dancing with the Stars.
  • 'Tis the TV year of a teen idol's discontent. First, Chad Michael Murray split from One Tree Hill costar/wife Sophia Bush. Then, his WB drama's third-season opener (98th place, 3.5 million) was down 20 percent from last season's average.
  • Inconceivable was un-ratable last week. NBC canned the fertility drama before it even turned three episodes old. In its absence, The Apprentice: Martha Stewart (69th place, 6.3 million) became the network's least watched original series.

Overall, CBS and ABC split honors--the former was the most watched network among total viewers (averaging 12.8 million); the latter was the most watched network among viewers aged 18 to 39.

NBC (9.7 million) ran third in both races, with fourth falling to Fox (8.4 million), despite strong ratings for the first round of the baseball playoffs.

The WB (3.8 million) topped UPN (3.3 million).

Here's a look of the 10 most watched prime-time shows for the week ended Sunday, according to Nielsen Media Research:

1. CSI, CBS, 28.8 million viewers
2. Desperate Housewives, ABC, 26.1 million viewers
3. Lost, ABC, 22.4 million viewers
4. Without a Trace, CBS, 21.2 million viewers
5. CSI: Miami, CBS, 18.7 million viewers
6. Grey's Anatomy, ABC, 18.1 million viewers
7. Survivor: Guatemala, CBS, 17.9 million viewers
8. Commander in Chief, ABC, 16.9 million viewers
9. NCIS, CBS, 16.9 million viewers
10. Law & Order: SVU, NBC, 16.2 million viewers

 Related Links
News: Ashlee's SNL do-over
News: Martha up, her TV boss down
News: Gruesome ratings plague Night Stalker

all news stories  more features

Bad Girls of Reality TV: A THS of kickass chicks; 8p

today's news
FIRST LOOK: The News in Brief

Bond Hot for Eva, Mads About Baddie

Scott Stapp, Kid Rock's Too Candid Camera

Lisa Marie Goes Fourth into Marriage

fresh features
Answer B!tch: Why do actresses let it all, er, hang out on the red carpet?

The Awful Truth: Tasty tidbits on who should be canoodling with whom

Watch with Kristin: The cast of Grey's share their reactions to the ratings boost

The 2006 Oscars: Predictions and insights into H'wood's biggest night

 help   about E! Online   site map   membership   newsletter  
Use of this site signifies your acceptance of the Privacy Policy and
Terms of Use.
Copyright  2006 E! Entertainment Television, Inc. All rights reserved.