CBS News Text Videos The Web  
    The Early Show  |  CBS Evening News  |  48 Hours  |  60 Minutes  |  CBS Sunday Morning  |  Face The Nation  |  Up To The Minute  |  Build Your Own Newscast








Advertisement

EDITOR'S PICKS

David Martin Dispatch: Raw Pictures Could Blur Differences Between Haditha And My Lai
30 Years Later, How Much Has Changed?

10 Plus 1: Off Camera With Mario de Carvalho
CBS News Cameraman Shares His Experiences Behind The Camera

In The Wake Of The CBS News Tragedy, What To Make Of The Critics?
On Critics Who Accurse Journalists Of Covering Conflict From Their Hotels

A Day In The Life On Capitol Hill
A Behind-The-Scenes Look At CBS News Covering Congress

Lara Logan Helps Put Iraq Coverage Into A Broader Perspective
CBS Correspondent Discusses Challenges Of Covering Iraq

Behind The Mic With Dan Raviv
Behind The Scenes During The 'Morning Drive' With CBS Radio News Correspondent Dan Raviv

'I Use The Shuffle Feature Because I Like To Shake Things Up*'
Some Thoughts On An Excess Of 'What's On Your Ipod' Stories

  Public Eye Home
  Public Eye Bios
  E-mail Public Eye
  Send In A Tip
  About Public Eye

 Public Eye RSS Feed
 CBS News RSS Feeds

+ Add To Favorites



BROWSE TOPICS

+ In The News
+ CBS News Issues
+ Outside Voices
+ Stuff We Like
+ Media Issues
+ 10 Plus 1
+ What Was Andy Thinking?
+ Blog Buzz
+ Behind The Scenes
+ E-Mailbag



BROWSE AUTHORS

+ Hillary Profita
+ Brian Montopoli
+ Vaughn Ververs
+ Dick Meyer



BROWSE ARCHIVES





BLOG ROLL
+ About The Blog Roll

media
CJR
Cyberjournalist
Editor & Publisher
The Editors Weblog
Lost Remote
Media Bistro
Media In The Mirror
Media Matters
Media Nation
Media Research Center
NRO Media Blog
Romenesko

others
The Anchoress
Buzz Machine
Captain�s Quarters
Crooks And Liars
Daily Kos
Global Voices Online
Michelle Malkin
The Moderate Voice
Powerline
Talking Points Memo
The Plank
Vodkapundit




June 8, 2006Next Post | Previous Post


There Are Two Sides To Some Of The Stories That Pictures Can Tell

Amateur historians like myself mark the beginning of the �television age� with the landmark 1960 presidential debate between the handsome, cool and charismatic John F. Kennedy and the sweaty, swarthy and five o�clock-shadowed Richard Nixon. Of course you�ve heard that Americans listening to the exchange on the radio narrowly picked Nixon as the victor whereas those watching it on the new-fangled picture-box favored Kennedy by a wide margin. Unfortunately for Nixon in that oh-so-close election year, an estimated 70 million viewers tuned in to watch instead of listen.

Today, as we endlessly debate and discuss the rise of the �Internet age,� nobody can deny that what made television a media king nearly 50 years ago still reigns supreme today � pictures. Seeing is believing. And that point was driven home once again this morning as the world woke to the images of a boogeyman�s corpse in Iraq. As powerful and important as such images can be, however, it�s worth examining the circumstances under which the U.S. government and media use them.

(APTN/US Military)
When Iraqi and U.S. officials announced the death of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the al-Qaeda terrorist who had become Iraq�s most-wanted man, they produced a picture (framed even) of Zarqawi�s lifeless body as evidence of the achievement. In the picture, the eyes were shut, the face pale but, except for a few scrapes, relatively clean. It certainly appeared Zarqawi had escaped meeting one of those 500-pound, laser-guided bombs head-on. But there were other pictures released as well, not all quite so camera-ready. There was also much made by the U.S. military of the video footage showing the targeted bombs taking out the safe-house where the terrorist sat.

Of course, we Americans haven�t always reacted with such glee when it comes to such images. When dead American soldiers were dragged and paraded through the streets of Mogadishu, kicked and nearly torn apart, our military and leadership recoiled with horror. The 1993 episode, part of the �Black Hawk Down� misadventure in Somalia, drew rebukes like this from Senator Trent Lott: �Americans have no desire to see their men and women degraded, killed and defiled by lawless infidels who drag the bodies of Americans through the streets to be kicked and spat upon.�

Interesting choice of words � �infidels� � considering current events. Similar outrage was given voice during the first Gulf War, when Saddam Hussein began parading U.S. POWs in front of the cameras, leading then-President George H.W. Bush to call it a �direct violation� of the Geneva Conventions and claim: �America is angry about this, and I think the rest of the world is." In this war, we�re not even allowed to see pictures of flag-draped coffins returning from Iraq. One wonders what the reaction would be if the dead body of an American general one day ended up on an endless Al Jazeera loop.

There are legitimate reasons for releasing the Zarqawi pictures and bombing footage but even those are not encouraging. Simply put, the people of that region, maybe most of the world, must see to believe. I�ll leave it up to others to debate what that says about either America�s credibility or warped cultures elsewhere (both a factor IMHO). It�s an issue we�ve encountered before. Despite some criticism, the U.S. defended the release of images showing a dazed Saddam going through a lice-check after his capture. They were important, it was argued, for Iraqis to see that this dictator who ruled through fear had been reduced to a common criminal.

Of course, an even touchier case was already part of the record when Saddam was pulled out of his spider hole. When his sons, Uday and Qusay, were killed in a firefight some months earlier, graphic pictures of their bullet-ridden bodies were available to nearly every man, woman and child in the world. The reason then, as is likely the reason for releasing the Zarqawi pictures now, was believability. Even then, according to a review of the coverage by Washington Post critic Tom Shales, many Iraqis were unwilling to believe those were actually the bodies of the demented men they were seeing. Over time, presumably, they have come to accept it.

Call it propaganda, information or verification. But however you see the use of images their double-edged nature is impossible to deny. While eager to show the world its conquests, the U.S. has worked just as hard to try and limit the damage that can come from pictures. Abu Ghraib is the clearest example of that of course. Even after most of the damage had been done, it took a lawsuit to pry more images out of the military. CBS News Pentagon correspondent David Martin recently warned that it could be pictures that will make the Haditha episode into a stark reality for most of the world.

Even opponents of the war have to acknowledge that Zarqawi�s exit from the stage is a good thing. If it takes pictures to convince the world that he has indeed been dispatched, then so be it. But it�s worth remembering that images can cut both ways.


Posted by Vaughn Ververs at 5:10 PM : June 8, 2006
Read more posts in Media Issues

 E-mail this story
 Printable version




Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not CBS News stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.



Comments
Vaughn:
As the "ombudsman blog" for CBS, how extensive an obligation to provide background info on a story do you think the media has? In this case, do you think its appropriate that no major news organizations have observed that the Bush administration rejected at least three chances to kill Zarqawi in 2003?


Posted by bibco2 at 11:06 PM : June 9, 2006
+ comment complaint




Posted by gardis72
"I know this is a very sad day for liberals. But for the rest of us, it's a victorious day, and I am ecstatic about the death of this horrifying terrorist. His picture must be shown to prove to the rest of Al Qaeda he's DEAD. I understand the liberal hand-wringing over it."
*****************************
I�m glad that someone can see victory in something coming out of Iraq other then the fleecing of our Federal Treasury�. �LONG LIVE BIG BOTHER!�



Posted by Mattcat25 at 11:02 AM : June 9, 2006
+ comment complaint




There's no way they dropped a bomb that reduced that house to rubble and the guys body was still intact. People WAKE up that's just IMPOSSIBLE. Did you see the pictures of the house?

This corrupt administration lies about EVERYTHING. Remember Jessica Lynch? I think one of Zarqawi 's guys killed him. Our troops had nothing to do with it. Sooner or later the truth will come out.

Posted by wesn08 at 9:02 AM : June 9, 2006
+ comment complaint




The insurgency in Iraq has demoralized. The picture of Zarqawi is proof that America is waging an air war against it. Certainly, Osama is now wary that if he is near the surface of the Earth, he could be killed. That is why he hides deep inside caves.

Posted by Antillo99 at 7:55 AM : June 9, 2006
+ comment complaint




"CBS News Pentagon correspondent David Martin recently warned that it could be pictures that will make the Haditha episode into a stark reality for most of the world."

What you didn't mention Vaughn, nor did David Martin, is the very real possibility that pictures can be staged, as we already have seen in this war, to say something far different than the truth. The real story that CBS and others should be covering in depth is the Arab culture and its regard, or more accurately its disregard for truth.

Here is a good read on the subject:

http://www.hawaiireporter.com/story.aspx?f882c1b8-aa42-431f-83a6-0066e7629ace


Posted by One_American at 3:09 AM : June 9, 2006
+ comment complaint




"CBS News Pentagon correspondent David Martin recently warned that it could be pictures that will make the Haditha episode into a stark reality for most of the world."

What you didn't mention Vaughn, nor did David Martin, is the very real possibility that pictures can be staged, as we already have seen in this war, to say something far different than the truth. The real story that CBS and others should be covering in depth is the Arab culture and its regard, or more accurately its disregard for truth.

Here is a good read on the subject:

http://www.hawaiireporter.com/story.aspx?f882c1b8-aa42-431f-83a6-0066e7629ace


Posted by One_American at 3:07 AM : June 9, 2006
+ comment complaint




I know this is a very sad day for liberals. But for the rest of us, it's a victorious day, and I am ecstatic about the death of this horrifying terrorist. His picture must be shown to prove to the rest of Al Qaeda he's DEAD. I understand the liberal hand-wringing over it. DIdnt' seem to bother you much when our civilian contractors were hung from a bridge in Falluja, never heard a peep out of you over that.

War is rotten. We didnt' start this war, They did. On Sept. 11, 2001. But we will finish it. Thanks to Bill Clinton's cowardice for 8 years, and you mentioned it, Black Hawk Down, the enemy thinks we're weak, soft, and not up to the task. AFter reading what you wrote above about showing the pictures, they have every reason to be hopeful, still.



Posted by gardis72 at 5:22 PM : June 8, 2006
+ comment complaint

+ Back to Top
+ Public Eye Home




    Wireless Alerts:  CBS News To Go  E-Mail Sign-Up:  Breaking News  |  Today On CBS News  |  60 Minutes  |  48 Hours  |  The Early Show  |  CBS Sunday Morning  |  News Summaries

    Recommended Sites:  CBS Corporation  |  The ShowBuzz  |  CBS.com  |  CBS SportsLine  |  UPN.com  |  CBS Store  |  CBS Careers  |  CBS Cares
    Site Map  |  Video Site Map  |  RSS Feeds  |  Help  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  CBS Bios  |  Internships
US News & World News
CBS News Text Videos The Web  

�MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.