part of the IBS network
Related To Story
Do you think 'Vamos A Cuba' should be removed from school libraries?

ACLU: Cuban's Freedom Fight Not Miami's First Amendment War

Organization Vows To Challenge Book Ban

POSTED: 4:38 pm EDT June 15, 2006
UPDATED: 5:03 pm EDT June 15, 2006

The American Civil Liberties Union of Florida is promising a fight over the Miami-Dade School Board's decision to remove a children's book about Cuba from public school libraries.

Lawyers and staff of the ACLU are preparing a legal challenge to the board's decision to remove "Vamos A Cuba" and 24 other books in a children's travel series from libraries.

Wednesday afternoon, the board voted 6-3 to take the books off the shelves.

In a statement, the ACLU said, "(The) precedent -- if allowed to stand -- opens the door to yank virtually any book off the shelf of a school library at the whim of a single parent and a school board judgment that there is some inaccuracy or omission in a book."

The ACLU maintains that the U.S. Supreme Court's response to controversial or unpopular speech is to add more information with different viewpoints, not enforce censorship.

The book contains images of smiling children wearing uniforms of Cuba's Communist youth group and a carnival celebrating the Cuban revolution of 1959. A parent who emigrated from Cuba said the book doesn't accurately represent life in the country, and asked for the board to remove the book.

Both a review committee and Superintendent Rudy Crew had recommended that the books not be removed from the libraries. Crew had suggested parental consent be required for borrowing the book, or that a sticker on the cover advise parents of the book's weaknesses.

One board member said he only supported the ban out of fear for his family's safety and to encourage a lawsuit by the ACLU.

The ACLU statement said: "The fight for freedom in Cuba cannot be waged as a war on the First Amendment in Miami."

Desktop Alert
Desktop Alert
* Breaking News Alerts
* Severe Weather Alerts
Click here to download Desktop Alert!

Premium Weather
Premium Weather
How will the weather affect you? Know for sure. Monitor storms, animate your forecast, create personal alerts! Try it now! or Log in here.

Sponsored Links
Links We Like
Keep cool this summer while you minimize your energy bill. Check out these great tips and enjoy a summer that is no-sweat. More Details

Want to boost your salary and promotion potential? Learn how to by getting an online degree. More Details

Does your resume have what it takes to get you into that interview? Find out with this quick quiz. More Details

Selling a car
Want to buy a used car but aren't sure what to look for? Are you afraid you might get a 'lemon' and overpay at the same time? Get some tips on how to get the best car at the best price. More Details

Links We Like includes a selection of information, tools and resources from our partners and sponsors.
Your Credit Report Experts recommend checking your credit report regularly. See where your credit stands with a FREE credit report and score!


© 2006, Internet Broadcasting Systems, Inc.
Click here for the IBS privacy policy, terms of use.
Click here for advertising information.
See All Internet Broadcasting Sites

Site Map