Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., July 14, 2006 Tamuz 18, 5766 | | Israel Time: 04:23 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition Diplomacy Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Bookmark to
Anti-Zionist, pro-Israeli
By Jill Cartwright

British Jewish journalist Arthur Neslen doesn't feel comfortable being in Israel - and not because of the stifling heat. Rather, his discomfort stems from political and ideological reasons. It wasn't easy, he says, to follow a path that led to a situation where he is in effect living here and "accepting benefits as a Jew over an indigenous population that has very few rights."

Neslen, 38, was the London correspondent for Al, the only Jew on staff, and for the last five years was the international editor of the leftist magazine Red Pepper. He is currently in Tel Aviv writing for The Economist's Web site and for several other international publications, and is also promoting his new book, "Occupied Minds: A Journey Through the Israeli Psyche," published by Pluto Press in March.

Before embarking on writing the book, Neslen had never set foot in Israel, but it had always been a fixture in his life, he says, from early childhood, through university and into his professional life. "I couldn't ignore the impact Israel and the politics of Zionism were having on my life and on the life of Jews in the Diaspora" - a Diaspora, he adds, whose identity is rapidly disintegrating and which is clinging desperately to Israel for survival.


"Diaspora identity is eroding," Neslen says matter-of-factly. "Both because of Zionist politics and because of demographic reality." With the increase in assimilation and decrease in anti-Semitism, Israel has become the totem around which all Jews gather. "After all," he continues, "apart from religion and a beautiful but atrophying culture, what else is there? The one thing people can always revert back to, especially in the media age, is Israel. The way of playing out the psychodrama, not just in communal terms but even family terms, is Israel."

But talking critically about Israel in the Diaspora has become impossible, he feels. The terms of the debate have become so emotive, so visceral, so "completely out of control" that one of the leading motives behind writing his book was to turn the spotlight back on Israel, back to those who were creating the context within which he, his family, his history and culture were being understood. "The only way I felt I could provide a critique," he says, "was to hold up a mirror of Israeli society to the Diaspora.?

Settlers and sex workers
That mirror is "Occupied Minds," a collection of some 50 interviews with Israelis, conducted between 2003 and 2005. Neslen chose his subjects carefully and fairly to represent a broad cross-section of Jewish Israeli society, from settlers to sex workers, soldiers to social workers.

He spoke with Labor politicians such as Amram Mitzna, right-wing rabbis such as Safed Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu, and teenage anarchists; even Larissa Trembobler (wife of Yigal Amir, the assassin of Yitzhak Rabin?) has her say. ("I think she's misunderstood," Neslen admits, hastening to add, "very confused, but misunderstood.")

His journey took him from talks with Holocaust survivors, displaced immigrants, typecast Mizrahi actors, depoliticized DJs to parents such as Daniella Kitain, whose son was killed in the Lebanon helicopter tragedy, and Arnold Roth, whose daughter was murdered in the Sbarro
pizzeria bombing in Jerusalem.

The result makes for compelling reading.
Moving, passionate, sometimes desperate, but always deeply personal accounts. Some are in-depth, others just one-page vignettes; stories of loss, stories of faith, stories of suffering, all clearly presented alongside black-and-white pictures of the interview subjects, as if the reader can almost hear them speaking. That is exactly the impression Neslen was aiming for.

"I wanted to make the book as unmediated as possible," he explains. "I wanted to allow a direct relation between the reader and the person being interviewed. And in that sense I think [the book is] as objective as it can be, even when it was dealing with people whose views I utterly detest."

Of which, he admits when pushed, it seems there are quite a few.

But the book is definitely not a leftist rant against Israel and what emerges is not a crass statement against the country's politics, but rather a very real picture of the human complexity that clamors for attention on this small piece of land.

"I tried to humanize people," says Neslen, "and I did want to humanize Zionism. If you can't humanize your enemy, you become the enemy. And I do see political Zionism that starkly - as an enemy."

There are no Israeli Arabs interviewed in the book. Why is that?
"It's a book specifically about Israeli Jewish identity. If you start talking about Israeli identity, I think you have a problem. Many Palestinian citizens of Israel would not define themselves as Israelis; they would call themselves Palestinians. Some wouldn't; they would call themselves Israeli Arabs, but for me to take that position and say you are Israelis is making a statement I wasn't prepared to make."

Neslen's original intention had been to end the book with an interview with "some stoned Israeli on a beach in India," someone who had lost any connection with Jewish identity. "That would be the coup de grace of Bundist polemic," he explains, "Zionism as a modern-day Golem that has destroyed the very people it was created to protect." However, he dropped the idea as it was "too overt." Anyway, he says, "I couldn't afford the plane ticket."

Instead the book closes with comments by Yaron Pe'er, a musician and Sephardic Jew, who plays on the beaches of Ras a-Satan in Sinai with fellow artists from Cairo and Lebanon, who have gathered to "drop their used skins and learn from each other." It is an interview of wistful optimism for a future without discrimination, divisions and the drive for material things.

"I wanted to end the book on an optimistic note," says Neslen. "I am anti-Zionist, but I'm pro-Israeli and I would like to see a situation where Israeli Jews were able to live here in peace, freedom and security."

Neslen, who is single, was born in Ilford and has lived all his life in or around London. His father is Canadian and his mother is from South Africa, a place he never wanted to visit "for the same reasons" he never wanted to visit Israel - "that I would be benefiting from someone else's misfortune and participating in their oppression."

He studied sociology at Manchester University and after graduation went on to become the London correspondent for

What was it like being the only Jew working at the Al Jazeera Internet site?
"I enjoyed working there. They treated me very well and I never personally experienced any anti-Semitic comments. There were a couple of times when I felt other writers were going too far and I complained to the editors about them and their stories were removed."

Such as?
"One writer would refer to the separation wall as the 'Holocaust wall,' which is obviously just preposterous, and also tended to go out of his way to get quotes from everyone he interviewed comparing Israelis to Nazis. My complaints almost always resulted in his reports being cut, taken down or otherwise amended.

"My editors at Al Jazeera were always fair and in fact interfered less with my copy than at other places I have worked - and were very understanding about my taking Jewish holidays off."

Bookmark to
'I'm the man'
Meshal declares he - not Abbas or Haniyeh - is the sole spokesman for the Palestinians.
Cantos de amor
Tel Aviv's World Music Festival 2006 will host four outstanding Latin musicians.
  1.   "coup de grace of Bundist polemic"; sounds good, means nothing 06:27  |  dante 10/07/06
  2.   Is this satire? 08:22  |  Proud Zionist 10/07/06
  3.   A dead Jew from a dead community 09:09  |  NS 10/07/06
  4.   This is a weird piece but still... 12:12  |  Proselyte 10/07/06
  5.   A garaduate of Sociology from Ilford! There`s radical chic 15:18  |  Avi 10/07/06
  6.   George Orwell lives here 15:28  |  BS meter 10/07/06
  7.   #3 - A dead Jew from a dead community? 19:46  |  Barry 10/07/06
  8.   anti-zionist pro-Israeli 20:22  |  Jake 10/07/06
  9.   Arthur Neslen had a cheap idea where he had none for the better. 21:32  |  Michael 10/07/06
  10.   Al Jezeera`s Uncle Tom 21:49  |  pace306 10/07/06
  11.   Anti-Zionist, pro-Israeli 23:54  |  Jerusalem Shmuel 10/07/06
  12.   Who is this guy trying to bulls--t? 01:11  |  A.K. 11/07/06
  13.   interesting piece 02:17  |  meriam 11/07/06
  14.   Jews are indigenous to Israel and Arabs to Arabia. 03:02  |  Palestiniansareamyth 11/07/06
  15.   And the point is? 05:52  |  AlexK 11/07/06
  16.   Palestinians are indiginous to Palestine 14:56  |  W.H. 11/07/06
  17.   I`m not buyinh his book 19:06  |  Tzvi 11/07/06
  18.   Mr. Shefa Amr 19:22  |  Tzvi 11/07/06
  19.   Arthur Nelson 09:45  |  Connie 12/07/06
  20.   How embarrassing 04:00  |  Jay Antonio 13/07/06
 Today Online
One killed, dozens hurt as Katyushas rain down in north
Responses: 169
IDF bombs Lebanese army bases, imposes sea and air blockade
Responses: 464
Editorial: 'No' to Lebanon War II
Responses: 216
Israel must take care not to open a third front with Syria
Responses: 111
The concept of 'restraint is strength' has proved fatal
Responses: 51

More Headlines
04:14 Israel targets Hezbollah stronghold in Beirut suburb
04:03 One rocket fired from Lebanon hits central Haifa; Katyusha rockets hit Nahariya, Safed and Carmiel
23:44 Authorities bar entry of ships carrying hazardous materials to Haifa port
01:32 Rice urges Israel to 'exercise restraint' in Lebanon campaign
01:22 Iran warns of 'fierce response' should Israel strike at Syria
00:34 IDF retrieves bodies of four tank soldiers killed in south Lebanon
23:36 Dozens of armed men try to forcibly open Gaza-Egypt border crossing
19:34 Iraqi parliament speaker: Jews finance acts of violence in Iraq
23:28 U.S. vetoes UN resolution condemning Israel's Gaza incursion
22:40 Israeli stocks lose only 4.3% despite battles, spike in oil price
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Israel Military Products
Israel Army Surplus and Online Store
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
The best way to enjoy Israel - Crowne Plaza and Holiday Inn Israel
Find your love online right here!
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved