About INQ7 | About the Inquirer | About GMA-7 | Advertise | Buy Content | Low Graphics | Site Map | Archives | Feedback | Article Index
SEARCH WEB INQ7 Powered by: Google
Today is Tue, Jul 25, 2006 , Philippines   
Hackenslash Grand SOHO Makati

Hot 7 Hiring
Jobmarket on SMS
Resumé Reserve
Job Alerts
PRC Exam Results

Ayala Foundation USA Features

Philippine Lotto Results
June 21, 2006
2 Digit Result: 22 25
3 Digit (Mid-Day Draw): 3 6 1
3 Digit (Evening Draw): 3 8 1
4 Digit: 7 9 0 2
6/45 Winning Numbers:
30 38 39 44 40 27
P 31,345,558.20

As I See It : How cheating was done in 2004 polls

First posted 00:34am (Mla time) Sept 28, 2005
By Neal H. Cruz
Inquirer News Service

Editor's Note: Published on Page A14 of the September 28, 2005 issue of the Philippine Daily Inquirer

BELIEVE it or not: The answer to the present political crisis is in the hands of the Presidential Electoral Tribunal (PET) and in the electoral protest of opposition vice presidential candidate Loren Legarda against Vice President Noli de Castro. President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo's problems emanated from a question of legitimacy. Is she the legitimately elected President? Or is she a fake President? The people's faith in her as the duly elected President was rudely shaken by the discovery of the "Hello Garci" tapes where she was caught in conversations with Election Commissioner Virgilio Garcillano, plotting to cheat in the last elections.

Fernando Poe Jr. died before his poll protest, alleging fraud and cheating in the last elections, could be heard, and the petition of his wife Susan Roces to substitute for him was dismissed by the PET. The question of who really won, Ms Arroyo or Poe, was left unresolved. Former Senator Legarda, claiming her rival, VP De Castro, also cheated

in the polls, filed an election protest. The protest of Legarda has started to move -- after lying dormant in the PET for more than a year -- and she is optimistic that the recount of the votes in six pilot provinces would be finished in six months.

How does that affect the question of Ms Arroyo's legitimacy? Also on the same election returns where the votes for the vice presidential candidates are recorded are the votes for Ms Arroyo and Poe. It would take no more than several seconds to look at the votes cast for the presidential candidates after tallying the votes for Noli and Loren. Thus, the questions of who won in both the presidential and vice presidential races could be resolved at the same time. For the cheating was a "Cheat One, Cheat Two" operation.

While it is true that there is no valid poll protest in the presidential contest, the PET can exercise judicial statesmanship in recounting the presidential votes at the same time it does with the votes for VP in order to resolve the crisis that is ripping the nation apart. The opposition can petition for the reopening of the Poe poll protest, and Ms Arroyo -- if she really won "fair and square," as she claims -- should welcome it. as that would finally prove her legitimacy. If she opposed it, that could mean only one thing: A recount would reveal the cheating.

In a PowerPoint presentation, Legarda and her principal witness, Segundo Tabayoyong, showed the Kapihan sa Manila forum last Monday how the cheating was done. It was simplicity itself and very easy to do. It was a new way of cheating, used for the first time in the elections of 2004. (Tabayoyong was a Questioned Document Examiner and former chief of the Questioned Documents Division of the National Bureau of Investigation. He has retired.)

Instead of changing the ballots at the precincts -- as was done in the past, which is difficult and labor-intensive -- the cheating was done on the election return (ER), the summary of the votes in the precincts. Election returns of a city or municipality are totaled in the Statement of Votes (SOV) which are, in turn, summarized in the Certificate of Canvass (COC) for the province. It is the COCs that are added by Congress to determine the presidential and vice presidential winners.

What the cheaters did -- Legarda and Tabayoyong explained -- was simply fill up new election returns, disregarding the ballots. These spurious ERs were prepared in advance, by a special force of about 200 persons in two places in Metro Manila (one in a hotel near the Edsa highway) and then sent to the provinces. Thus, the votes were already counted and the "winners" known even before the voting started. It didn't matter for whom the people voted. It was the special force that decided the winners.

The Commission on Elections has admitted that it overprinted 32,000 sets of these ERs before the elections. It has not explained fully what happened to these excess ERs. It is believed that these were the same fake ERs used by the cheating team. It was a systematic, well-financed, well-managed and well-supervised operation by professional cheaters, Legarda and Tabayoyong said.

The cheaters, however, made mistakes. And that gave them away. ERs supposedly coming from areas thousands of kilometers apart were filled in by the same hands, said Tabayoyong. The vertical tally bars ("taras") used to mark the votes on the ERs were written very neatly and not in the uneven manner when written in the precincts because of stress and haste. There are columns where there are totals of votes but no bars. There are totals that do not tally with the bars. Thumb marks used to close the columns -- so no new bars could be added afterwards-were small, purposely smudged to make identification impossible. Required signatures were missing. Some had only initials instead of signatures.

Of the approximately 5,000 ERs analyzed, 3,000 were found to be spurious.

The analysis also showed that the team gave De Castro an average of a 70-vote margin over Legarda, and Ms Arroyo, a 100-vote margin over Poe. Therefore, the 32,000 sets of overprinted ERs could translate to a vote-margin rate of approximately 2.1 million votes in the Legarda-De Castro contest and around 3 million votes in the Poe-Arroyo race. Thus, De Castro and Ms Arroyo had something like 2 million votes and 3 million votes, respectively, for "insurance." Even if their rivals won in other areas, the insurance votes made sure Ms Arroyo and De Castro won in the totals.

* * *

TODAY'S JOKE: Terrorists kidnapped Ms Arroyo and demanded ransom money.

"Pay us P500 million or we will set her on fire," demanded the ransom note.

The bankrupt government asked the people for donations. So far, the donations totaled 2,000 liters of gasoline.

PS: A group of businessmen offered to donate another 2,000 liters if Fidel Ramos and Jose de Venecia were included.

Copyright 2006 Inquirer News Service. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

View previous columns and related stories, video clips, and sites.

Print this story | Send this story | Write the editor

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk.
Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate.
Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer
Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets,
Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines
Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94

  Talk of the Town Stories

How much is human life worth?

Insurance sets lifetime value

Law awards P50,000 to heirs of crime victim


Other Stories

Editorial : Lost

The Long View by Manuel L. Quezon III : One voice for hope

Away with redundant tax incentives

Political Tidbits by Belinda Olivares-Cunanan : Mayors’ league on track re unicameral

Human Face by Ma. Ceres P. Doyo : A college for indigenous peoples

Viewpoint by Juan Mercado : No laughing matter

There's The Rub by Conrado de Quiros : Mirrors

Youngblood by Elliotte Jay M. Lagado : Force for change

Swindling case suspect not an AFP consultant

Other conference organizers not cited




Sense and Sensibility
Bambi Harper

The summing up

Elliotte Jay M. Lagado

Force for change

At Large
Rina Jimenez-David

Bless the ‘lukayo’!

Melinda Quintos de Jesus

The world’s ‘Development King’

Separate Opinion
Isagani Cruz

Father’s Day

Political Tidbits
Belinda Olivares-Cunanan

Mayors’ league on track re unicameral


Let tree fall where it leans

Passion For Reason
Raul Pangalangan

Latin America’s left turn: Will we follow?

Sounding Board
Fr. Joaquin G. Bernas, S.J.

The education crisis

Looking Back
Ambeth Ocampo

Aguinaldo’s education

Juan Mercado

No laughing matter


Hopes and dreams

Public Lives
Randy David

The fight against the Left

Ramon J. Farolan

Notes on East Timor

Human Face
Ma. Ceres P. Doyo

A college for indigenous peoples

Fr. Jerry M. Orbos, SVD


As I See It
Neal H. Cruz

Abandoned Lafayette pits are worse than Diwalwal

Denis Murphy

Old people in China

Kris-Crossing Mindanao
Noralyn Mustafa

The secret identity of Ferdinand Marcos

There's The Rub
Conrado de Quiros


Get Real
Solita Collas-Monsod


Amando Doronila

A sinister plan to butcher civilians

Reader's Advocate
Raul Palabrica

'Martyr' story

Pinoy Kasi
Michael L. Tan


The Long View
Manuel L. Quezon III

One voice for hope

Rebel without a clue
Patricia Evangelista

SMS to Dad

Property Guide

© Copyright 2001-2006 INQ7 Interactive, Inc. An INQUIRER and GMA Network Company
About INQ7 | Advertise | Buy Content | Low Graphics Version | Site Map | INQ7 Mobile | Help
News | INQ7money | Global Nation | JobMarket | YOU | RoadTrip| Hackenslash