Brenner Talks About Her Ordeal

Jaimé Morton: Offering a Connection

Editorial - Who is Family?

Letter from OITM Readers

Gay National News

Lesbians and AIDS

Killer Convicted in Anti-Lesbian Shooting

National Lesbian Conference in Fall of 1989.

NEVGALR Organizes for 1989.

Commentary - Build Bridges, Not Walls

Awards for Vi and Harvey

OITM's New Column

VT C.A.R.E.S. Benefit


Slide Show

The Intriguing Sounds of Jaime' Morton


Gay Trivia

Letters Home

Dear Aunt Gay

Killer Convicted in Anti-Lesbian Shooting

November 10 - On October 27, Adams County, Pennsylvania Judge Oscar Spicer convicted Stephen Roy Carr of first degree murder in a shooting that killed Rebecca Wight and critically wounded her lover, Claudia Brenner. In a move praised by Brenner, the gay community and victim advocates, the judge also excluded as inadmissable any arguments by the defense that the victims' sexual orientation and behavior provoked the attack.

On May 13, the two women were fired upon at their Appalachian trail campsite by Carr, whose attorney claimed in a preliminary hearing that Brenner and Wight "provoked" the attack by performing sexual acts in front of him, and otherwise teased him. While acknowledging that she and Wight had made love at the campsite, Brenner insisted that they both thought they were alone, and described the accusation that they provoked the attack as "not only untrue but insulting." In a statement released to the press, Brenner asserted that "Rebecca and I were lovers... Nothing about who we were or our love for each other could be considered motivation for the outrageous, inhumane violence that Stephen Roy Carr perpetrated against us." Commented Kevin Berrill, Director of the NGLTF Anti-Violence Project, "While the criminal justice system's handling of this particular case was better than usual, we should all be outraged at the attempt by Carr's attorney to blame Brenner and Wight for provoking the attack. It is another revolting example of how our society seeks to shift responsibility for anti-gay violence from the victimizers to the victims."

Carr waived his right to a jury trial in exchange for an agreement by the prosecution not to seek the death penalty and to drop several lesser charges. Although he has not yet been sentenced, Carr faces life imprisonment without parole. An appeal by Carr's defense attorney is expected.

Commenting on the sentence, Brenner stated that "a life sentence with no parole in a maximum security prison, while not compensating for our tremendous loss and pain, is the appropriate response to a nightmare that nothing can ever make right." Brenner also praised the handling of the case by the local prosecutor and police, describing them as "respectful and professional... All those involved never wavered in the investigation and prosecution of the crime. Most gay people who are victims of violence do not receive the kind of treatment that I received." Brenner also called for greater visibility as a means of countering anti-gay violence: "The only really helpful position we can take is to be open about our lives and to share our loves and losses with all people we come in contact with," she said. "This attack is the worst nightmare of every woman and every gay person; it is the ultimate violation of our right to live and love as we choose," said Berill. "In the face of this ordeal, Claudia has shown incredible strength and will and dignity. Her decision to speak out about the attack - and the bigotry that led to it - is an inspiration to lesbian and gay people everywhere."

  Copyright Mountain Pride Media