Ace of Spades HQ
Angry in the Great White North
Ankle Biting Pundits
Art of the Blog
Dust in the Light
In the Agora
Jim Miller on Politics
John and Ken
Kelly Jane Torrance
Kim du Toit
Little Green Footballs
Little Miss Attila
Mark in Mexico
Mary Katherine Ham
My Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
Outside the Beltway
Pardon My English
Real Clear Politics
Res Ipsa Loquitur
Right Wing News
Right Wing Nuthouse
Seven Inches of Sense
Sharp as a Marble
Tapscott's Copy Desk
The Right Report
Truth Laid Bear
View from the Right
Watcher of Weasels
WHERE IS BILAL HUSSEIN?
A year ago, I blogged about a controversial, Pulitzer Prize-winning photo taken by an unidentified Associated Press stringer in Iraq. More background from the blogosphere here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here. Do take the time to re-read them all. The context is important.
One member of the Pulitzer-winning AP team was AP stringer Bilal Hussein. Hussein's photos have raised serious, persistent questions about his relationship with terrorists in Iraq and whether his photos were/are staged in collusion with the enemy. I've learned of an intriguing news development that strengthens those lingering suspicions.
This afternoon, in response to a tip from an anonymous military source in Iraq, I contacted both the AP reporter embedded with the Marines in Ramadi, Todd Pitman, as well as AP's media relations office headquartered in New York concerning Hussein's whereabouts. No word from Pitman. But at 6:20pm EDT, I received the following e-mail response from AP:
We are looking into reports that Mr. Hussein was detained by the U.S. military in Iraq but have no further details at this time.
According to my tipster, Hussein was captured earlier today by American forces in a building in Ramadi, Iraq, with a cache of weapons.
I am still awaiting a response from the DOD's Combined Press Information Center and a Public Affairs Officer in Ramadi.
While we wait (and remember that the AP has a history of dragging its feet), a quick refresher on the Pulitzer Prize-winning photo controversy and Hussein's work:
The above image of an execution of Iraqi election workers, in broad daylight, on Haifa Street in Baghdad was taken in November 2004. D. Gorton, a former New York Times White House photographer who covered the Carter and Reagan administrations, provided an excellent summary and analysis of the controversy surrounding the photo at The Weekly Standard. Gorton concluded:
So this is where the story stands now: A photo "stringer" who is identified as an Iraqi national, who remains anonymous, makes an exclusive picture that is not corroborated by any other photographic news source. The image fits into a press meta narrative about the situation in Iraq prior to crucial national elections. The published photo sets up an immediate outcry in the blogosphere and is met by an institutional defense by the AP. That is followed by a series of misstatements by the AP on the distance the photographer was from the scene, culminating in a piece by AP's director of photography, who avoids addressing that very issue of proximity.
AP director of media relations Jack Stokes defended the photographer against questions about staging this way: "Insurgents want their stories told as much as other people and some are willing to let Iraqi photographers take their pictures."
As it happens, AP stringer Hussein has been a prolific photographic story-teller for the "insurgents:"
And another up-close-and-personal snapshot of a day in the life of the "insurgents:"
Many more graphic photos of Hussein's work here, including this chilling photo in the middle of the Ramadi desert taken by Hussein as triumphant terrorists posed with the body of just-executed hostage Italian national Salvatore Santoro on Dec. 15, 2004:
In November 2004, AP published a glowing profile of Bilal Hussein that was--surprise--critical of the American forces' assault on Fallujah.
Rusty at The Jawa Report (hat tip - OTB) updated the "continuing saga of insurgent propaganda" earlier this week and pointed to an excellent investigation of phony MSM war photography published by the National Journal's Neil Munro, who featured Bilal Hussein's questionable work prominently:
Thanks to digital technology, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are the most photographed in history. Photographers with digital cameras have provided, almost instantaneously, an enormous flood of accurate, dramatic, and even shocking images to people around the world. But the daily downloads of news photos include some that are staged, fake, or so lacking in context as to be meaningless, despite the Western media's best efforts to separate the factual from the fictional....
Well, here's something new: As I noted earlier tonight, Bill Roggio's investigation of a possible faked insurgent information operation in Ramadi published today warrants a response from AP. Roggio's report caught my eye especially when I saw one of the photos he posted...
Guess who I discovered took the picture?
You guessed it: AP stringer Bilal Hussein (scroll down on right-hand side).
So where is Bilal Hussein now?
And if he has in fact been detained by our troops, what exactly was he doing when he was taken into custody?
Working for the AP? Or someone else?
Update: The CBS News blog tracks the story.