Justice Dept. subpoenas AMD, Nvidia
Published on ZDNet News: December 1, 2006, 9:41 AM PT
The U.S. Department of Justice's Antitrust Division has issued subpoenas to Advanced Micro Devices and Nvidia as part of an investigation into potential antitrust violations.
AMD announced that it had received its subpoena on Thursday afternoon, and Nvidia made its corresponding announcement on Friday morning. No specific allegations have been made against either company.
Both companies have stated that they intend to cooperate with the investigation.
Gina Talamona, a spokeswoman for the DOJ, said the agency is looking into possible anticompetitive practices within the "graphics processing unit and cards" industry. She declined to comment on specific companies involved in the investigation or what was sought in the subpoena.
This would appear, at first glance, to exclude Intel's huge integrated graphics business. Intel is actually the largest supplier of PC graphics technology by virtue of the integrated graphics chips that it ships with its chipsets. An Intel representative said the company did not receive a subpoena from the DOJ related to the investigation.
AMD, best known for its microprocessors, entered the graphics processor industry in October with its $5.4 billion purchase of Nvidia rival ATI Technologies. Nvidia unveiled its new GeForce 8800 graphics cards for high-end PCs several weeks later.
Analysts were puzzled about the nature of the investigation. Unlike the memory industry--the subject of recent DOJ investigations into anticompetitive practices--there are only two main players in the market for add-in graphics technology. Nvidia and ATI, now part of AMD, have always been thought of as fierce competitors not inclined to work together outside of industry standards associations, said Dean McCarron, an analyst with Mercury Research.
Jon Peddie, a longtime graphics industry watcher with Jon Peddie Research, said he hasn't heard any complaints from customers of Nvidia or ATI about anticompetitive practices such as price-fixing. He noted that the graphics cards from each company that offer similar performance often cost roughly the same. This could potentially come off as price-fixing, but really reflects the nature of a two-supplier business, he said.
The DOJ successfully prosecuted the DRAM (dynamic RAM) industry in 2004 and 2005 for colluding to fix prices in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Some executives were sent to prison and companies such as Infineon and Hynix paid hefty fines. More recently, the DOJ has been looking into the SRAM (static RAM) industry, looking into companies such as Sony, Samsung, and Mitsubishi.
Talkback - Add your opinion
There are other players still in the graphics processor field, Via technologies comes to mind first, and isn't there a current card based on an AGEIA chipset?
If graphics cards are a high markup item, int this industry, people will pop into the market like lions in to feast on a wildebeast.... (Read the rest)
Latest Hardware Content
- Blu-ray DVD drive no bonus for some PS3 buyers
- Sun puts 16 cores on its 'Rock' chip
- The Apple phone flop
- The next notebook battery? Lithium polymer
- Shareholder activist to join Gateway board
- Subscribe to Feed
|Motorola's buying spree|
|CIO Patricia Morrison discusses the IT challenges of acquiring large companies, such as Good Technology and Symbol Technologies.|
- Diggers Digg cash? So do many other 'users'
- Can open source content make money?
- Wither the Microsoft service pack
- Innovation in media: Join us on the frontier of real-time multimedia blogo-journalism
- Cuban: High-def may kill the Internet video star
- See all ZDNet Blogs »
Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors
- Pushing Security to the Perimeter with ProCurve
- ProCurve's Identity Driven Manager provides the IT organization with the ability to manage access to their network resources in a highly flexible, scalable and reliable manner.
- Read the IDC report to learn how to regain and maintain control>>
- SOA Leadership Roundtable
- Do you want to know what companies like QUALCOMM and Washington Group International have already done to successfully adopt SOA? Watch this event with experts from leading companies as they discuss their challenges and keys to success.
- Stream the on demand replay to learn more >>
- Solaris Adds Predictive Self Healing for x64 Systems
- Find out how Predictive Self Healing capability in the Solaris 10 Operating System enables servers to explain errors and failures occurring on a network and help avoid catastrophic downtime.
- Read more about Sun server design innovation >>
blogs from our sponsors
Whitepapers & Webcasts
- "Timber!" in ECM: The Content Management Silos are Toppling Burton Group
- Taking Authorization to the Next Level Burton Group
- IT Applications - Less Is More Burton Group
- Improving Agility, TCO, and Security with Agentless Job Scheduling BMC Software
- Integrating and Automating Composite Applications BMC Software
- Got Legacy? Four Fates Await Your Applications IBM
- ERP for Midsized Enterprises
ZDNet Quick Poll
Which of the following forces will impact your mid-sized organization the most over the next 2 years?
See which factors ZDNet readers think will have the most impact
you should know about implementing an ERP system
These pointers and caveats will help guide your ERP efforts.
Learn more at TechRepublic
From our sponsors
- SAP for Midsize Enterprises
Making the benefits of industry-tailored business applications more affordable and easier to manage for midsize enterprises has always been a priority at SAP. In fact, nearly 60% of all SAP installations are in organizations with annual revenues of less than $500 million.
Learn more about SAP solutions for midsize enterprises
- Sponsored By
- From our sponsors