TV News | RSS | Blogs | ePaper 1 Tevet 5767, Friday, December 22, 2006 9:13 IST | 
Jewish SinglesPlant a TreeCar RentalsJPost SimchasJPost StoreePaperChristian EditionAdvertise with Us
 E-mail Edition
 Kotel Cam Live
 AllJobs Israel
 Christian Edition
 Youth Magazines
 News Ticker
 Israel Alert
 Middle East
 Iranian Threat
 Jewish World
 Cafe Oleh
 Arts & Culture
 Real Estate
 Travel & Tourism
 Health & Sci-Tech
 In Jerusalem
 Special Reports
 Q & A
 Audio Programs
 Map of Israel
 Israel Resources
 Financial Tables
 Shabbat Times
 Media Kit


Eldan Rent-a-Car
The largest car rental company in Israel offers 20% discount.

All you want to know
About Jerusalem
Visit our Portal!

Join Free at
Where love happens! Join Now!

Earn a B.A. in Israel
Live in Israel Study in English

Great apartments
Exclusive apartments in best locations in Israel

Change your luck
Change your luck with one click - Really works!

Plant JNF Trees
Order online now

Careers at JPost

Passover Specials

Passover 2007
Join Rabbi Jonathan Sacks at the Le Meridien Dead Sea.

Lasko Kosher Tours
5 Magnificent Passover Resorts to choose from » Israel » Article

High Court: A-Ram fence is our defense

Talkbacks for this article: 17

A panel of seven High Court justices headed by retired Supreme Court President Aharon Barak on Wednesday rejected three petitions objecting to the route of the security barrier separating A-Ram from Jerusalem.

The barrier includes a two-and-a-half kilometer-long, six-meter high concrete wall running down the middle of the Jerusalem-Nablus highway.

"We did not find cause for intervening in the state's considerations," wrote Barak. "The state properly balanced all the factors that had to be taken into account. It is therefore justified in building the fence along its current route."

Most of the barrier around A-Ram has already been built, but the state had promised that if the court accepted the petitions, it would dismantle it.

In reaching its decision, the court unanimously rejected a petition submitted by The Association for Civil Rights in Israel, Bimkom - Planners for Planning Rights and a group of Palestinians living or working in A-Ram, who protested against the wall erected along Highway 60. It also voted unanimously to reject a petition filed by A-Ram local council head Sirhan Salaimeh protesting the same segment and another part of the barrier running along the southeastern part of the town and heading towards the Jewish settlement of Adam.

By eight votes to one, the court also rejected a third petition by residents of Dahyat el-Barid, a neighborhood of 18,000 residents in the southern part of A-Ram. The petitioners said they wanted to continue to be part of A-Ram and the West Bank.

Justice Miriam Na'or cast the dissenting vote in this petition, arguing that the barrier should run along the Jerusalem municipal boundary rather than bisect A-Ram and include a neighborhood which was not within the official city limits. The other justices included Barak, Supreme Court President Dorit Beinisch, Ayalah Procaccia, Edmond Levy, Asher Grunis, and Esther Hayut.

The most controversial part of the petitions focused on the wall running along Highway 60, on the section of the road which runs from Jerusalem to Ramallah and Nablus. The petitioners did not offer an alternative route, insisting instead that no wall be built and that the 58,000 residents of A-Ram, including a large number of Palestinians holding Israeli residency status, have direct access to Jerusalem, including the neighborhoods of Shuafat and Beit Hanina, and Bir Naballah, located in a West Bank enclave west of Highway 45 (the extension of Jerusalem's Begin Expressway).

Barak pointed out that the route of the western segment of the barrier along Highway 60 was located inside Israeli territory and therefore the government was empowered to build that part of the barrier. As for the segments of the barrier inside the West Bank, the military commander was authorized to build it since it was meant to protect Israelis from terrorist attacks.

Barak acknowledged that the separation barrier interfered with the quality of life and the freedom of movement of the residents of A-Ram, and was therefore illegal unless built for a proper reason, but he asserted that it had been. "Its aim is proper if it is done for military (not political) needs in order to protect the lives of residents of the territories or Israel," wrote Barak. "The barrier fulfills this condition. It is meant to protect the lives of Israeli residents in general and Jerusalem residents in particular from terrorist operations out of Judea and Samaria." He also found that there was no alternative route that was better than the one proposed by the army.

1 | 2 | Next »

Post comment | Terms
17. To #15 Sydney in Canada
Maria T - Canada (12/14/2006 06:04)
16. Reasons why
Sydney - (12/13/2006 22:39)
15. Responsibilty
Sydney - Canada (12/13/2006 22:32)
14. the high court should be ashamed but not because of this ruling where was your injustice walid awad when they allowed the deportation of 24,000 jews
jerusalemit - (12/13/2006 22:19)
13. Not facing reality, not taking responsibility
Raymond from DC - USA (12/13/2006 20:30)
12. A-Ram fence is our defense
mgarcia - (12/13/2006 20:12)
11. Re: #1 Walid
mgarcia - (12/13/2006 20:04)
10. Cut the crap, Walid
Gary - (12/13/2006 18:57)
9. Legal and moral responsibility
JJ - (12/13/2006 18:24)
8. #1 Walid Awad: "High Court"
Stan Goodman - Israel (12/13/2006 18:07)
7. Boor Balestinians... the stress...
M. Oz - USA (12/13/2006 17:20)
6. A-Ram fence is our defense
Jerry Phillips - USA (12/13/2006 16:50)
5. Response to #1
Elie - USA (12/13/2006 16:42)
4. Fence blocks Jews from their land!
Jon - England (12/13/2006 16:18)
3. A Ram
Alan - (12/13/2006 15:38)
2. What Was The Problem?
Guran Walker - Ur-th (12/13/2006 12:57)
1. High Court of Injustice
Walid Awad - (12/13/2006 11:22)


ISRAEL[ more » ]

Barrier route in and around A-Ram, north of Jerusalem.
Photo: B'Tselem

Aerial view of a section of the barrier is seen on the outskirts of Jerusalem.
Photo: AP [file]


Netanyahu: 'Israel not tired, Olmert is'
Comments: 86

Secular rabbis to be ordained in J'lem
Comments: 59

Mini-mosque to be built in Ben-Gurion
Comments: 57

© 1995 - 2006 The Jerusalem Post. All rights reserved.
About Us | Media Kit | Advertise with Us | Subscribe | Contact Us