10:25 PM PDT, May 4, 2007 Jobs    Cars   
Real Estate
   Apartments    Shopping  |   Weather    Traffic  

California | Local News

Print   E-mail story   Most e-mailed   Small Text Size Regular Text Size Large Text Size Change text size

Bratton oversees LAPD inquiry at critical time

Officers' use of force after pro-immigrant rallies occurs days before chief is up for reappointment.
By Patrick McGreevy, Times Staff Writer
5:27 PM PDT, May 2, 2007

Only days before officials will decide if Los Angeles Police Chief William J. Bratton deserves a second term, he found himself Wednesday overseeing another high-profile investigation into allegations of police abuse on his watch — this time, whether officers used excessive force against immigrant rights protesters in MacArthur Park.

Even as organizers of the May Day march called for the chief to be fired and police union officials winced when he said he was "disturbed" by some video scenes, Bratton was impressing others, including one member of the Police Commission, the body that will decide his fate, with quick and decisive action.

As he has done in the past, Bratton moved fast to get in front of the controversy, postponing a planned trip to El Salvador and holding two news conferences in two days to assure the public that the latest videotaped incident would be fully investigated.

In the frank style that made him a favorite of the tabloids when he headed the New York Police Department, Bratton told reporters early Wednesday that he was "disturbed" by videotapes that showed the confrontation and thought that the actions of some officers who used batons and foam bullets to clear the park were "inappropriate."

He later took a barrage of aggressive and challenging questions at a news conference at City Hall, where he voiced "regret" for the incident.

March organizers were not satisfied.

Javier Rodriguez, a leader of the March 25th Coalition, called for the Police Commission to reject Bratton's request for another term.

"He should be turned down. We should find someone with more sensitivity," Rodriguez said. "We firmly believe that there was a decision to attack the crowd. In any country other than the U.S., the man at the top would be fired."

Other community leaders, including Assembly Speaker Fabian Nuñez (D-Los Angeles), said they viewed the incident and the chief's handling of it as a sort of final exam.

"The speaker — and the entire city of Los Angeles — will be looking at the chief's handling of this situation before giving him a vote of confidence," said Steven Maviglio, a spokesman for Nuñez.

The incident also deeply concerned Police Commission President John Mack, who said he was confident in the chief's ability to thoroughly investigate the matter but was unsure what role it would play in the decision on the chief's tenure.

"That's something to think about," he said.

Still, others praised his actions and observers inside and outside city government said they did not believe that the controversy would derail Bratton's request to be given a second, five-year term.

Hours before the park incident, 13 of the 15 City Council members had endorsed Bratton for another term, and he was expected to enjoy smooth sailing when the Police Commission takes up the issue Tuesday.

That optimistic appraisal has not changed as a result of the MacArthur Park incident.

"He's handled it very appropriately," said Police Commission Vice President Alan Skobin. "He's on top of it. He's engaged and promising a thorough investigation. If anything, I think his handling of it has been a big positive."

The City Council voted unanimously Wednesday to ask Bratton to appear before the body within 30 days to explain what happened at the park, and how policy might be changed to avoid incidents in the future.

Even as council members said they were shocked by news videos showing the officers' actions, many singled out Bratton for his swift and forceful response.

"I want to thank the chief," Council President Eric Garcetti said. "This wouldn't have necessarily triggered the involvement of the Police Commission because it is not a life-threatening use of force."

Added Councilman Jack Weiss: "It is very clear we have a chief who is determined to get to the bottom of it, and get the facts out immediately. This is not your father's LAPD, and this is not your father's chief."

Even Councilman Herb Wesson, who likened the incident to the police beating of civil rights leaders in the South in the 1960s, praised the chief's response.

"I'm proud that the chief said quickly that some inappropriate actions took place," Wesson said.

But the chief's comments concerned officials in the union representing officers, who worried that they were forceful only to appease police commissioners who would decide whether he would be reappointed.

"There is a feeling he is forgetting his own comments of the past that police work is sometimes ugly and that there should not be a rush to judgment," said one Police Protective League official, who spoke on condition that he not be identified because his statement had not been approved by the union board.

Experts said they believed that the incident would not derail the chief's application for another term.

It would take something "much more scandalous" that directly involved the chief to upset his request for a longer tenure, said Jaime A. Regalado, executive director of the Edmund G. "Pat" Brown Institute of Public Affairs.

"It doesn't hurt him," Regalado said of the latest incident. "He still has 13 votes in the City Council. If he loses one or two that won't make a difference. And he still has widespread community leadership support."



Message Board
READERS WEIGH IN: Share your thoughts on the police response to the MacArthur Park protesters.

People did not hear the orders to disperse because of the noise. Others could not understand the orders given in English. Reporters were obviously not a theat to anyone except to those who fear their cameras. Even the chief of the LA police agrees that what they did was wrong ... but you don't?!
Submitted by: How Sad 5:36 PM PDT, May 4, 2007
The LAPD is criticized if they do something, and criticized if they don't. We need to get off their backs and respect the service they continue to give to all of us. Stupid counter-establishment culture always goes after people sacrificing for the service of others.
Submitted by: Standing with the Man 5:32 PM PDT, May 4, 2007

May Day Protest
Photo Gallery

MacArthur Park clash
Photo Gallery

Related Stories

More California News
- Turf war stops at the ER
- Arrest made in Weiss swastika pasting
- LAPD cut back forces at park rally


Copyright 2007 Los Angeles Times      Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Home Delivery | Permissions | Contact

Partners: Hoy | KTLA | Careerbuilder.com for jobs | Cars.com for autos | Apartments.com for rentals | ShopLocal | FSBO (For Sale By Owner) | Open Houses
Boodle.com for Grocery Coupons | Houses for Rent | Recycler for Free Classifieds