This is the dilemma of Byron Leftwich. According to this Pete Prisco column, Jacksonville Jaguars fans harbor a little resentment toward Leftwich for nudging fan-favorite Mark Brunnell out of town, and now fans almost seem eager to put David Garrard back out there instead of dealing with another season of the inconsistent Leftwich.
Prisco seems to imply, though, that race might play a role in this, and I have my doubts about that. Lots of Jags fans wanted Garrard to take the snaps simply because he was more like Brunnell. He ran around in the pocket and tried to make plays. Of course, Garrard wasn't nearly as good as Brunnell, which is why Leftwich is the starter. It was one of those "Be careful what you wish for" situations, much like the calls in Carolina to bench Jake Delhomme for Chris Weinke, which turned out just as well for that team.
Leftwich is clearly putting in some effort to stay healthy this offseason, and he deserves at least one more shot to prove he's not a bust like David Carr. If he doesn't deliver this season, though, he might be better off trying to catch on with another team. Clearly, he won't be loved as much as Brunnell until he gets the Jags to an AFC Championship game. Hey, Brunnell did that in his second year. What's taking Leftwich so long, right?