Pueblo Indian women enjoyed a powerful role in their matriarchal society for centuries, until
Spanish conquest enveloped their native homeland of New Mexico. The region boasted the earliest
Euro-American settlements, cities and political structures in North America. The Treaty of
Guadalupe Hidalgo, which ended U.S. conquest of the entire northwestern third of Mexico in 1848
guaranteed American citizenship to all former Mexican citizens in New Mexico. The property rights
of women, long guaranteed under the Mexican land-grant system, were also upheld by the treaty.
Nevertheless, New Mexico's women of all national origins remained disfranchised throughout the
entire western and nationwide suffrage campaigns. Despite valiant efforts by suffrage organizers
after 1915, New Mexico's legislature was one of the last to ratify the 19th Amendment to the U.S.
Constitution in 1920.
New Mexico's Anglo Protestant women were late to organize influential women's clubs, which did
not get off the ground until the 1890s. This movement left out large sectors of women in the state
who were of Indian or Mexican American ancestry. The influential Catholic Church, openly opposed
to women's suffrage in the 19th century, also tempered support for an early suffrage campaign.
The state's constitution, ratified in 1910, posed the most formidable obstacle to early suffrage.
The State Federation of Women's Clubs won the right to school suffrage. In turn, full voting rights
to Hispanic men were guaranteed. But the constitution required a daunting three-fourths majority of
voters in each county to amend the suffrage provision in the future. This legal barrier dashed any
hope of winning suffrage by popular vote, which had been the key to success in most other western
states.
New Mexico women focused on national suffrage politics instead. Alice Paul's militant
Congressional Union (CU), the forerunner of the Woman's Party, played a leading role in the state's
late-blooming movement. By 1915, the CU enjoyed a committed network of support, especially among
middle-class and elite Anglo club women in urban areas.
"They say it is very difficult to get the Spanish ladies out, but as I have one on the program
to speak in Spanish, I think they will come--and their husbands as well," reported the CU's lead
organizer, Ella St. Clair Thompson to Alice Paul in 1915. Her efforts to reach out to
Spanish-speaking women paid off, especially among elite women relatives of influential
Mexican-American politicians. Adelina Otero-Warren, the niece of the popular head of the state's
Republican Party, helped lead Mexican American women into the political mainstream. Bilingual
flyers and speeches in Spanish at public rallies brought support for suffrage among both men and
women in the Hispanic communities.
Otero-Warren enjoyed such a loyal following that she was chosen by Alice Paul to lead the
state Congressional Union in 1917. Her mission was to bombard the New Mexico congressional
delegation to win their support in the battle to pass the "Susan B. Anthony" (19th) Amendment.
With her help the amendment passed through Congress and to the states for ratification. New
Mexico women won full suffrage at last with the final ratification by the state legislature of
the amendment in 1920.
Women voted with enthusiasm in New Mexico, with participation rates of Mexican-American women
exceeding that of Anglo women or men. Nevertheless, the 19th Amendment did not guarantee
citizenship or the vote for the state's large population of Pueblos, Navajos, Hopis and other
Native American women.
New Mexico's suffrage story exemplifies the diversity of western women and their varied
interactions in the political world. Geography, religion, ethnicity and race have all played a
crucial role in how, why and when western women won the vote.
|