• Show Search Options  • Search Tips

Section Front
E-Mail This StoryPrintable VersionTag With del.icio.usDigg This

Nash: Film No Whitewash

'Beautiful Mind' Mathematician Interviewed By Mike Wallace

60 Minutes Main Page60 Minutes Main Page
60 Minutes Video60 Minutes Video
Program FactsProgram Facts
Andy RooneyAndy Rooney
Contact InfoContact Info
Up NextUp Next
Tapes and TranscriptsTapes and Transcripts
DVDs from Amazon.comDVDs from Amazon.com

Wireless Alerts
E-Mail Alerts
RSS Feeds

For John and Alicia Nash -- an extremely private couple who still live in the non-descript house they've been in for 30 years -- there has been a dark side to fame: recent tabloid stories suggesting that Nash made anti-Semitic comments in the 60s.

JOHN NASH: I did have strange ideas during certain periods of time.

Typical, he says, of the paranoid rantings of someone in the throes of schizophrenia. But he is not anti-Semitic. Never has been.

MIKE WALLACE: Everyone with whom I talked who knows John, everyone say no. He is-- he doesn't feel that way about Jews at all.
ALICIA NASH: I've never heard him say anything like that.

The film "A Beautiful Mind" has been criticized for leaving out some other so-called "facts"- claims that Nash had been a bad father, and questions about his sexuality.

MIKE WALLACE: I've gotten so many questions about whether or not he's a homosexual.
ALICIA NASH: Let me tell you I've known him since I was 20. And that's just not true. So, I mean, I should know. What do you want me to do? I mean-- (LAUGHTER).
MIKE WALLACE: Alicia, the Oscars are a very competitive business.
ALICIA NASH: Absolutely
MIKE WALLACE: And it's been suggested that some of competing producers from other films that have been nominated have been spreading this stuff to the press.
ALICIA NASH: Of course. Undoubtedly.
JOHN NASH: But you see-- you-- you can't-- so-- you can't so well argue about these things. I've learned that it's better that I-- I don't talk about it.

As for questions about Nash as a father - after years of estrangement, he says he is now close with an older son he has from a previous relationship - even arranged for a cameo appearance for him in the movie. He also shared with him one quarter of the money he got for selling his story to the filmmakers.
Another quarter went to his and Alicia's son Johnny, who shares more than just a name with his father. He also shares a talent for math - Johnny earned his own PhD in 1985 - and, like his father, he suffers from schizophrenia.

MIKE WALLACE: What kind of a father was he?
JOHNNY NASH: Well, he wasn't around for the first ten years of my life, but when he came back at age ten, he was a very good father, yes.
MIKE WALLACE: Was there any doubt in your mind that you wanted to be a mathematician?
JOHNNY NASH: Oh, no. There was no doubt at all, yes. Mathematics.
MIKE WALLACE: You wanted to follow in your father's footsteps?
JOHNNY NASH: Absolutely. To do honor to Dad, to follow in his footsteps, that was always my-- my life's dream my entire life, yeah. You know, and I-- I still felt that I could equal him, that I could-- I haven't done so yet, but I'm trying to.


All About OscarAll About Oscar
It's the biggest prize in the world of movies. Here are nominees, photos, fashions, past winners, and more.

March 17, 2002

(CBS) Dr. John Nash, the Nobel Prize winning mathematician whose life is portrayed in the Oscar-nominated film “A Beautiful Mind,” denies being anti–Semitic. His wife denies he's homosexual. And a son denies he's a bad father.

Critics of the box-office hit, based on a biography of the same name, have accused the filmmakers of leaving out significant details of his life.

But in an interview with correspondent Mike Wallace of the CBS News program 60 Minutes, Nash, who suffers from schizophrenia, his wife, Alicia, and son Johnny deny these allegations, which have made this Academy Award contender controversial in recent weeks.

This is the first time Nash has spoken out since the movie was released.

He tells Wallace he began hearing voices when he was in his thirties. “I thought of the voices as . . . something a little different from aliens. I thought of them more like angels . . . “It’s really my subconscious talking, it was really that…I know that now,” says Nash.

Was he anti-Semitic?

“I did have strange ideas during certain periods of time,” Nash concedes. Typical, he says, of the paranoid rantings of schizophrenics.

But, says Wallace, Nash is not anti-Semitic, and never has been. “Everyone with whom I talked who knows John, everyone say no. He . . . doesn't feel that way about Jews at all,” Wallace says.

Nash’s wife Alicia adds, “I've never heard him say anything like that.”

What about the charges that Nash is homosexual? Alicia Nash says no. “I’ve known him since I was 20 and that’s just not true…I should know,” she says.

Nash denies it, too, but won’t discuss it. “I’ve learned that it’s better that I don’t talk about it,” he tells Wallace.

If, as critics have charged, Nash ignored a son born of a long-ago relationship, he says he is close to him now and has given John David Stier a share of the royalties from “A Beautiful Mind.”

Buy 'A Beautiful Mind' on Amazon.
Another son, Johnny, who also suffers from schizophrenia and whose mother is Alicia Nash, lives at home with his parents. Johnny Nash says that, except for the mental illness that kept his father out of the home, he was a good parent. Nash returned home when Johnny was 10.

While Nash’s mental illness diminished through the 1970s and 1980s, his son, Johnny, showed increasing signs of the same illness. Nash believes his concern for Johnny may have led to his own partial recovery but also makes a poignant yet macabre analogy: “It’s possible. It’s almost as if a demon might have passed from one host to another.”

Johnny Nash says simply, “He was a good father. Yes,” in answering a Wallace question.

He’s also a PhD mathematician, and says he wanted to follow in his father’s footsteps. “That was always my life's (dream). . . I still felt that I could equal him . . . I haven't done so yet, but I'm trying to."

The New York Times said in its Saturday editions that some in the film industry say Nash is actually the victim of a whisper campaign whose aim is to scuttle the movie's Oscar hopes. It's a phenomenon they say has become increasingly common in the intense competition for Academy Awards.

"This may not be the worst year in Oscar history, but it's pretty low," Pete Hammond, a film historian and consultant for American Movie Classics, is quoted by the Times as saying. "To accuse the subject of a film of being anti-Semitic when you know that a lot of the people who will be voting on the Oscars are Jewish, well, that's really down and dirty."

The Times reports that the film's backers say the whisper campaigns, which reach a peak during Oscar balloting, are fueled by the Internet, by a fascination with tabloid-type scandals and by the rise of private Oscar strategists hired by the studios.

But even in that context, the campaign against "A Beautiful Mind" has struck many in Hollywood as particularly brutal, the Times adds.

"It's getting nastier," Mr. Hammond said. "It's like a political campaign now. You get these so-called Oscar consultants who go out there thinking, What kind of dirt can we dig up?"

Mrs. Nash says tells Wallace the allegations about her husband are “undoubtedly” being spread by supporters of other films.

Nash was born on June 13, 1928, in Bluefield, W.Va.; it became apparent when he was young that he was a genius. He studied mathematics, and became a brilliant Princeton mathematician in the 1950s. He then began to suffer from schizophrenia.

He suffered terribly on and off for years. In 1994, while in remission, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in economics for work he had done more than 40 years earlier while studying at Princeton.

Nash is still a working mathematician at Princeton.

The film has been nominated for a number of Academy Awards including Best Picture. Russell Crowe, who plays Nash, and Jennifer Connolly, who plays Alicia, also were nominated for Best Actor and Best Supporting Actress awards respectively.

© MMII, CBS Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved.

E-Mail This StoryPrintable VersionTag With del.icio.usDigg This

INSIDE 60 Minutes
Kurdistan: The Other Iraq
Bob Simon On How The Kurds Are Reshaping Northeastern Iraq
Nudity No 'Big Deal' For Dame Helen
Provenzano: The Phantom Of Corleone
Presidential Price Tag
• More

Extreme Heat And Humidity Blanket Nation
Highs In The 90s Expected From Western Plains To The East Coast
26 U.S. Troops Killed In 1 Week In Iraq
Fate Of 6 Trapped Coal Miners Unknown
Fed Leaves Interest Rates Unchanged
• More

Back To Top Back To Top


Go To CBS News Video


Watch Video60 Minutes  | Email this video

Watch Video60 Minutes  | Email this video

60 MINUTES VIDEOSAll 60 Minutes Videos

Watch VideoThe Other Iraq | Email this video

Watch VideoAn American In Kurdistan | Email this video

Watch VideoHelen Mirren, All Grown Up | Email this video

Watch VideoDame Helen On Nudity | Email this video


Watch VideoFlood Rescue In Cleveland | Email this video

Watch Video3 Days To Reach Trapped Miners | Email this video

Watch VideoBill Clinton Reaches Out | Email this video

Watch VideoNotebook: Teacher In Space | Email this video

More Video

CBS News - Most Popular

  • Show Search Options  • Search Tips
Wireless Alerts:  CBS News To Go  E-Mail Sign-Up:  Breaking News  |  Today On CBS News  |  60 Minutes  |  48 Hours  |  The Early Show  |  CBS Sunday Morning  |  News Summaries

Recommended Sites:  CBS Corporation  |  The ShowBuzz  |  Wallstrip  |  CBS.com  |  CBS SportsLine  |  CWTV.com  |  ETOnline.com  |  The INSIDER  |  CBS Store  |  CBS Careers  |  CBS Cares
Breaking News© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.