December 21, 2005

Judge Rules Against 'Intelligent Design'

by Michael Powell
The Washington Post

A federal judge barred a Pennsylvania school district yesterday from mentioning "intelligent design" as an alternative to evolutionary theory in a scathing opinion that criticized local school board members for lying under oath and for their "breathtaking inanity" in trying to inject religion into science classes.

U.S. District Judge John E. Jones III, a Republican appointed by President Bush, did not confine his opinion to the missteps of a local school board. Instead he explicitly sought to vanquish intelligent design, the argument that aspects of life are so complex as to require the hand, subtle or not, of a supernatural creator. This theory, he said, relies on the unprovable existence of a Christian God and therefore is not science.

"The overwhelming evidence is that Intelligent Design is a religious view, a mere re-labeling of creationism and not a scientific theory," Jones wrote in a 139-page decision. "It is an extension of the Fundamentalists' view that one must either accept the literal interpretation of Genesis or else believe in the godless system of evolution."

In November, voters in Dover threw out eight of nine school board members; the ninth was not up for reelection. The new school board, which favors teaching evolution, will not appeal the ruling.

Read the complete story (Some news sites require registration)

Related Headlines

September 27, 2007
Reinhold Niebuhr is Unseen Force in 2008 Elections
Religion News Service
September 27, 2007
Prisons to Restore Purged Religious Books
The New York Times
September 27, 2007
Appeal of 'Crosses' Lawsuits to be Heard Oct. 1
Las Cruces Sun-News
September 26, 2007
Polygamous Leader Found Guilty
Salt Lake Tribune
September 25, 2007
Judge: Sheriff Promoted Religion
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Religion and Politics 2008
Examine how the 2008 presidential candidates are faring in opinion polls and compare their stances on pressing religious issues, from abortion to the Iraq War.

New Profiles: Mike Gravel and Tom Tancredo

Email Newsletter

Stay informed with weekly updates from the Pew Forum.

See Newsletter Archive