$bbtitle
AAPL: 190.86 ( +2.3196 ) AppleInsider RSS Feed
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Class-action charges Apple with illegally tying iPods to iTunes

By Kasper Jade

Published: 10:00 AM EST

Apple Inc. in a new class-action lawsuit is charged with illegally tying iPods to its iTunes Store in order to forge a monopoly over the digital media market so it can inflate prices, exclude competition, and force consumers to continue to buy into its closed ecosystem.

The 19-page formal complaint, originally filed in a Florida circuit court back in August, has since made its way through a Florida district court to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California upon Apple's request, as similar cases have been pending before a judge in that court for over two years.

The suit was brought about by Florida resident Frederick Black on behalf of all Florida residents who have purchased an iPod or downloaded media from iTunes and faced restrictions, such that they cannot transfer content purchased from iTunes to a non iPod digital music player, nor can they download digital content from other online vendors to their iPods.

Those limitations are not only frustrating, but unreasonable and illegal under Florida's antitrust and unfair trade laws, Black alleges, as consumers who may lose or break their iPod are unable to transfer songs purchased from iTunes to a different brand of player. Therefore they are forced to either purchase another iPod or forgo their right to use content already purchased from the iTunes service.

Music and video content purchased from iTunes comes wrapped in Apple's copy protection layer dubbed Fairplay, which precludes its use on non-Apple hardware products. Although Apple could license the technology to other hardware manufacturers, it chooses not to so that it can continue to limit competition and maintain its monopolistic share of the digital media market, Black alleges.

Similarly, he says, Apple could have licensed the right to use Microsoft's widely deployed Windows Media format or negotiate inter-cooperative agreements to use a copy protection system that is industry-wide, but instead chooses to limit competition and maintain its dominant market share.

Black also charges Apple with intentionally disabling built-in support for the rival Windows Media format from chips used in its earlier iPod models -- such as those from PortalPlayer and SigmaTel -- in order to control what content is available to consumers. The Cupertino-based company's "sufficient economic power" also allows it to "influence the third-party companies who provide the digital content to the online retailers," he adds.

"[Apple], by controlling such a large part of the portable digital media player market, the online music market and the online video market, maintains sufficient economic power in these markets to control consumer pricing in these markets, which has resulted in consumers paying higher prices," Black's attorneys at Tripp Scott wrote in the complaint.

Apple is specifically charged with three formal counts, which include violations of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practice Act, attempted monopolization in violation of the Florida Antitrust Act, and monopolization in violation of the Florida Antitrust Act.

Apple is "in possesion of monopoly power in the portable digital media player market, the online music market and the online video market and has the power to control prices in these respective markets and has been able to exclude competition from these respective markets," the suit claims. "Through its tying practices, Apple has conducted itself through unfair methods of competition, anticompetitive conduct, unconscionable acts or practices, and unfair or deceptive acts or practices in conduct of trade or commerce."

The suit adds that Apple has done all this with "the purpose of eliminating competition" and that its actions are "not for legitimate business purpose."

Black is seeking damages in excess of $15,000, a court order awarding treble those damages, attorneys' fees, and any further relief the Court may deem proper. He's demanding a trial by jury.

119 Comments ]  [ Tell a Friend ] [ Print ] [ Story Link ] 

Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
Windows 7 multi-touch; iPhone limit raised; TomTom iPhone GPS?
Apple job description mentions multi-touch, cameras, remotes
Overly cautious Microsoft spurs first-ever Zune shortage
Second-gen iPhone in final phase; Apple TV update planned - report
Apple announces television content on iTunes Canada
Apple's Leopard to boost Mac sales while Dell, HP slump: report
Microsoft Office 2008 for Mac goes gold, ships next month
NBC hitches onto download service from Apple rival SanDisk
Apple to launch TV downloads on iTunes Store Canada
iPhone on right track, but won't knock iPod sales yet -- report
First year Apple TV sales fall below expectations
Apple, Nintendo gadgets lead holiday search queries in Europe
In-depth review: can Amazon's Kindle light a fire under eBooks?
MacMall offers huge savings on iMacs, MacBooks and MacBook Pros
AT&T; expands iPhone distribution; AmTech on Dell; West 14th
Apple retail stores bound for Brazil, Mexico City
Booming Apple sales strain supply, will beat estimates - report
Briefly: Dell at Best Buy; Mac Pro and 10.5.2 at Macworld?
Apple sub-notebook to retail for $1500, 3G iPhone by June - report
Rumors: iPhone update to add disk mode, iCar project on hold
Apple's 14th Street Manhattan flagship store revealed (photos)
Apple filing details multitasking touch-screen for mobile gaming
Report: iPhone outpacing rivals in Europe without 3G
iWork dents Office share; Nokia/Universal music; iPod giveaway
Parallels rolls out Premium Edition for Mac, official Leopard update
Google launches new Web app for iPhone users
Intel to launch Penryn mobile chips ahead of Macworld
France's Orange sells nearly 30,000 iPhones in five days
Verizon sides with Google; new Get a Mac ad; iPhone speed boost?
High-quality unboxing photos of Amazon's Kindle eBook reader
Apple to beat bullish December quarter guidance after all - analyst
Apple validates 13-inch LED backlight units ahead of ultra-portable
German court re-locks iPhone; Adobe's Flash 9 with H.264 support
iPhone leads in web stats; Brazil Apple stores; more
Apple close to movie distribution deal with Fox - report
Apple, AT&T; sued over iPhone's Visual Voicemail feature
Steve Jobs to headline Macworld San Francisco 2008
Apple drops NBC television shows from iTunes
German court to rule on iPhone; Apple confirms NYC opening
Amazon to fill Apple's shoes in Pepsi Super Bowl song promo?

AppleInsider Market Place

Sell your Laptop - working or not. Free shipping.: Get an instant online quote and sell your laptop today !

Believe in Office: Save Up To 25% on Office 2004 For Mac. Visit Our Site for Details!

IBackup - SMB Online Backup: IBackup is the preferred online storage and backup service of choice for SMBs for its ease of use, security and value. Offers automated backup and restore, file selection and securiy.

 
Advertisements







AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2006
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.