Skip navigation
sponsored by 

Would you have allowed Bill Gates to be born?

Advances in prenatal genetic testing pose tough questions

GATES
Microsoft's Bill Gates speaks to business leaders at the ninth annual Microsoft CEO Summit on May 19 in Redmond, Wash.
Robert Sorbo / AP
COMMENTARY
By Arthur Caplan, Ph.D.
MSNBC contributor
updated 12:33 p.m. ET May 31, 2005

Arthur Caplan, Ph.D.

E-mail
Who needs Bill Gates? No, I don’t mean who needs a gazillionaire corporate titan, a man whose company, Microsoft, took in billions of dollars last year by controlling nearly all the software used to run nearly every computer on the planet.

No, I mean, literally, who needs him?  If you could go back in time and stop the birth of the world’s most famous nerd, would you?

Story continues below ↓
advertisement

You probably answered my question with a "no." Whatever Gates’ sins may be, he is the father of a computer revolution that has brought much good to many people throughout the world. Add to that achievement his current generous philanthropic activities supporting some very worthy causes, such as vaccine research and a center for autism research in Seattle, and the case for having Bill with us becomes pretty persuasive.

(MSNBC is a Microsoft-NBC joint venture.)

But what if I told you it’s possible that Gates has a medical condition that accounts, in part, for both his tremendous achievements and for his "nerdiness?" Gates is widely reported to display many personality traits characteristic of a condition known as Asperger’s syndrome. Asperger’s is a mild version of autism, a more serious condition that renders many children unable to talk, be touched, communicate or socialize. While I certainly do not know if Gates has Asperger’s, his difficulties in social settings are nearly as legendary as his genius, so it's possible.

The perils of genetic testing
That said, if you had been Gates' potential mom or dad 50 years ago, what would you have done if you knew about his abilities and flaws before he was born? Would you have wanted a child that would go on to do great things but would have a hyper-nerdy personality? What if the decision about whether to have a child like him also carried a risk that he might be born with far more serious disabilities? Would you have decided to carry the baby to term?

The reason I ask these questions is that there is a good chance we will soon have a genetic test for detecting the risk of autism in an embryo or fetus. The development of such a screening tool raises the possibility that parents might one day have the option of preventing the birth of a child with even a mild case of the disorder.

The thought is very upsetting to many in the autism community, including Aspies For Freedom, an advocacy group for people with Asperger's that is pushing to make June 18 "Autistic Pride Day." In their view, those with autism are no more suffering from a disease than are people who are short or have lighter or darker shades of skin. They want autism treated as merely a difference not a disease. And they are aghast at the thought that anyone would abort a child because they might have any degree of autism.

An advantageous disorder?
In the past decade, there has been an explosion in the number of U.S. children diagnosed with autism. Less well known is that there has been a parallel autism epidemic in other countries, such as Ireland and Britain. Whatever the reasons for the increase in the number of cases, it is highly likely that autism has a genetic component. Scientists and doctors have not yet nailed down what the genetic contribution to autism is, but the fact that males are far more likely to be affected than females and that autism appears in certain ethnic groups more than others are strong indicators.

Like many genetic diseases, there is a broad range of severity associated with autism. And like some genetic diseases, such as sickle cell trait, there can be, in the right environment, an advantage to having a mild form.

Asperger’s is the least disabling form of autism and research is beginning to show that it may also account for the presence of some special capabilities in areas like mathematics, computer science and engineering. But the same genes may also create a person who is socially awkward, easily distracted, very introspective and in many ways withdrawn and solitary.

Rate this story LowHigh
 • View Top Rated stories

Sponsored links

Resource guide

Dating - Get two months free!

Home equity Wells Fargo

Get your degree online

Find your next car

Find your dream home today!

Find a business to start

Fast $7 trades, no limit

Check your 2007 Credit $0