Brett Favre has accomplished a lot in his 17-year career. But his performance in a win over the Lions left Alex Marvez in awe. Old reliable
Brett Favre has accomplished a lot in his 17-year career. But his performance in a win over the Lions left Alex Marvez in awe.
The 49ers offense has been stuck in first gear. That's ruined their season — and things may only get worse, says our NFL Czar. Going nowhere
The 49ers offense has been stuck in first gear. That's ruined their season — and things may only get worse, says our NFL Czar.
With two straight wins, Denver is 5-5 and tied atop the AFC West. Can the Broncos stay hot in Chicago? Go inside Week 12. Miles to go
With two straight wins, Denver is 5-5 and tied atop the AFC West. Can the Broncos stay hot in Chicago? Go inside Week 12.
About Peter Schrager
Peter Schrager is a frequent contributor for You can e-mail him at
MORE BY Peter Schrager:
 Week 13 Picks: Man vs. man vs. machine
 Buffet: Double trouble at Arkansas
 Week 12 Picks: Man vs. man vs. machine
See all articles >  
 GB @ DET Recap
 Schein's Turkey Picks
 Lions suffer third straight loss
Video Home
  Moss is more valuable than Brady
  Vick to start serving prison time
  Favre has plenty left in the tank
  Holmes officially retires from NFL
  Senator rips fans for halftime harassment
  Where have all the good QBs gone?
  Colts still biggest threat to Pats
  Giants LB Antonio Pierce, on Reggie Torbor subbing for the injured Mathias Kiwanuka:
  Patriot-less midseason awards
  'Pacman' set to take plea deal
View all headlines...
Buffet: The men behind The Man
Peter Schrager, Updated 55 days ago
 STORY TOOLS:                        





If you handed me an official NFL ballot and asked me to vote on the 2007 league MVP award at this very moment, I'd say three things:

1. That's awfully silly of you. It's only three weeks into the season, why are we voting on the MVP award in late September?
2. LaDainian Tomlinson and his 1.9 yards-per-carry is not in my top 50.
3. Umm ... I'm picking Brett Favre.

Yes, Tony Romo, Tom Brady and Peyton Manning would certainly get some serious consideration. But in the end, I'd be hard pressed choosing someone other than the ol' gunslinger from Gulfport, Miss. Sunday's performance against San Diego was downright magical. Favre willed his team to victory, as he's done 149 times before, and tied Dan Marino's career touchdown record with a game-winning, 57-yard strike to Greg Jennings in the final two minutes. It was just another chapter in a storybook season for No. 4. The slant pass has been working, the pump fake's never looked better and he's throwing the ball better than any quarterback in the entire league. And Green Bay is sitting on top of the NFC North at 3-0.

All you can eat

For the rest of Peter Schrager's Weekly Buffet, check out the Weekly Temperature, the Loose Ends and The Mailbag.

Over the past couple of years, there's been a simmering bit of Brett Favre-related nausea buzzing on the Internet. Revolting after years of idolization, there appeared to be a minor backlash of sorts against the future Hall of Fame quarterback. Writers and bloggers alike began hinting that Brett should hang 'em up; some calling him selfish. He waited until the middle of the spring in 2005 before deciding on whether to return for the 2006 campaign. He then chose Super Bowl week, of all times, to announce he'd return to the game this season. Though the majority of the mainstream media rejoiced over the news, there were some quiet whispers and rolling eyes questioning the decision.

Well, there are no questions now.

And at this point, it's hard not to just root for the guy. At 37, Favre's everyone's cool uncle who has the motorcycle and the list of one-liners. He's been around forever, knows all the tricks, and just loves the game. In an era where quarterbacks are handed the world before accomplishing anything (see: JaMarcus Russell, Matt Leinart) -- Favre's earned everything he's got. Every yard, every win, it's been all No. 4 in Green Bay. Seeing Favre under center, doing those wild pump fakes and celebrating in the end zone with a pat on the helmet after a score has become as much a Sunday tradition in this country as "The Simpsons" or "Meet the Press." He's been at the same job for a decade and a half, loves what he does, and has fun doing it. He's currently playing some of the best football of his career. If he stays healthy, there's no reason to believe he won't be back next year, doing the same thing.

Which leads to the 2007 Packers storyline nobody's really talking about: The guy wearing No. 12 on Green Bay's sideline.

Yes, for the third straight season, Aaron Rodgers, a former bona fide college star at Cal and a first-round pick of the Packers in 2005, stands on the side with a clipboard, patiently, but respectfully, waiting his turn. Rodgers had a terrific camp this summer, and by all accounts, is more than ready to be an NFL starting quarterback. Yet, while the other first-round quarterbacks in his draft class -- Alex Smith of San Francisco and Jason Campbell of Washington -- are now entrenched as the starting quarterbacks of both the present and future of their respective franchises, Rodgers waits his turn to get a shot. And waits. And then waits some more.

Tom Petty once said that the waiting is the hardest part.

Rodgers likely knows about that all too well.

Of course, he's not the first to endure such a fate. In fact, Rodgers is just one card-carrying member of a rather wide-ranging club. When a guy starts 241 consecutive games, there's bound to be a group of players who've backed him up. In Favre's case, the list is a virtual "Who's Who" of NFL starting quarterbacks from the past decade and a half. There are Super Bowl QBs, wily veterans and longtime journeymen. Some were college legends, others relative unknowns. A few went on to have prosperous careers elsewhere; others never quite got their chance.

There's a recurring skit on "Saturday Night Live" about the "Five Timers Club". Nineteen people have hosted the program at least five times, and the number's become kind of a benchmark. Five-timers include names like Alec Baldwin, Christopher Walken, Steve Martin, John Goodman and Danny DeVito. When Tom Hanks referenced the club in a 1990 monologue, he held up a shiny card, noting "The fifth time you do the show is the most special time of all, because you get this ... a membership card in the Five-Timers Club. Come with me ... I'm gonna give you a chance to look in on one of the most exclusive clubs in the world."

The "Favre Backup Club" could quite very well be the NFL equivalent to the "Five Timers Club". Though names like T.J. Rubley and Rick Mirer likely won't bring about any memories of Bart Starr, there's something to be said for this elite group of men. If they do not have cards proving their membership, they probably should. I want to suggest a yearly gathering for all of Favre's former backups. They could all gather in Racine on a random Saturday, eat some of the world's finest cheeses, and then watch "There's Something About Mary" on loop. Can't you just see Steve Bono chuckling over a few brews, howling "Man, that hair gel scene just never gets old!"?

Card membership and fictional yearly reunions held in Wisconsin suburbs aside, let's check out the top 12 members of this very exclusive club:

12. Craig Nall

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 2002-2005
Most Known For: Leading NFL Europe in passing as the quarterback for the Scottish Claymores

11. Ty Detmer

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1992-1995
Most Known For: Winning a Heisman Trophy at BYU

10. Doug Pederson

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1995-1998, 2001-2004
Most Known For: Holding Donovan McNabb's seat warn in Philly, as the Eagles starter in 1999.

9. Don Majkowski

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1992
Most Known For: The coolest nickname in sports history, "The Magic Man".

8. J.T. O'Sullivan

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 2004
Most Known For: Serving as Jon Kitna's replacement in Week 2's "miracle" Lions-Vikings game

7. Steve Bono

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1997
Most Known For: Countless Chris Berman nickname jokes involving Cher.

6. Rick Mirer

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1998
Most Known For: Being the No. 2 pick in the 1993 NFL Draft

5. Danny Wuerffel

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 2000
Most Known For: Winning the Heisman Trophy in 1996

4. Aaron Brooks

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1999
Most Known For: Either the 2000 NFC divisional round 31-28 upset of the defending Super Bowl champion Rams ... or being that Michael Vick guy's cousin.

3. Mark Brunell

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1993-1994
Most Known For: Heroic upset of the Broncos in Mile High while quarterback of Jaguars in 1996.

2. Jim McMahon

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1995-1996
Most Known For: A Super Bowl ring in 1985 ... and a starring role in the "Super Bowl Shuffle" video

1. Matt Hasselbeck

Years of Service behind Mr. Favre: 1999-2000
Most Known For: Leading the Seahawks to an NFC Championship and a spot in Super Bowl XL.
 STORY TOOLS:                        





And that's just the start of it. We didn't even get to Bob Gagliano and Henry Burris!

The fact of the matter is this: Rodgers is not the first quarterback to spend his Sundays on the Packers sideline watching Favre take snaps. Among those 12 alone, there are multiple Pro Bowls, playoff wins, and Super Bowl rings. Rodgers is still only 23-years-old, and if anything, his time learning from ol' No. 4 is for his own good.

Even if he is forced to wait a bit.

After all, what more could you ask for? He's learning the ropes from the league's current MVP.

Main course | Weekly temperature | Loose ends | Mailbag >> Feedback | Press | Jobs | Tickets | Join Our Opinion Panel | Subscribe
Other Fox Sites >> | FOX News | News Corp.
© 2007 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use
Portions Copyright © 2007 STATS LLC. All rights reserved.