For today's installment of "Card Corner," we turn back the clock forty years...
There must have been something about baseball in the 1960s that encouraged players to don the "jack of all trades" label for a day. The first two players in major league history to play all nine positions in a game performed the feat during the course of the rebellious and radical decade. On September 8, 1965, Kansas City A's rookie Bert "Campy" Campaneris, usually a shortstop and occasionally an outfielder, became the first man to accomplish the positional merry go-round, doing so in a 13-inning loss to the Los Angeles Angels. Three years later, a lesser known, but more versatile player, joined Campaneris as one of the game's unusual record holders.
Cesar "Pepi" Tovar started his professional career with the Reds' organization before being traded to the Twins in a 1965 deal. Almost immediately, Tovar's "happy-go-lucky" personality made him popular with three of the game's most important constituencies: the players, the media, and the fans. Tovar insisted that everyone call him "Pepi" or "Pepito," Spanish nicknames that exemplified his upbeat, energetic manner. As with most Latin American players of the era, Tovar faced limitations with the English language, but overcame them with his free spirit and his eagerness to communicate with the writers who covered his teams. "He was very articulate," says Bob Fowler, formerly a beat writer for the Twins. "Very good to talk to."
Tovar's outgoing personality may have contributed to his rather unusual personal life. According to the book, Seasons in Hell, rumors swirled that Tovar had three different wives in three different countries by the time he joined the Rangers in 1973. Three wives--and the ability to play every position on the baseball diamond.
Another one of Tovar's eccentric but less scandalous habits exemplified his caring nature. At the end of each season, Tovar gathered up all of his equipment rather than turn it in to the team. Collecting dozens of bats and balls and a myriad of gloves, Tovar shipped the items to his hometown in Caracas, Venezuela. Tovar usually told others that he wanted the equipment for his winter workouts, but in reality, he gave the equipment to underprivileged children in Caracas. If not for Tovar's generosity, many of the youngsters would have been left without the equipment needed to play.
In his first major league season, Tovar played sparingly with the Twins. He then moved into a kind of "super utility" role, playing almost every day, but usually at different positions. He might play second base one day; on another day he moved to shortstop; at times, he would patrol the outfield. Tovar quickly gained a reputation as a hard-nosed "play-me-anywhere" foot solider who approached the game with boundless enthusiasm and determination. (Although he was not a great defensive player, he was not as bad as his 1970 Topps card might indicate; the glove that Tovar is wearing in that photograph appears to have a major hole in the webbing!)
The undersized Venezuelan also impressed the Twins' brass with his speed, aggressive bat, and willingness to sacrifice his 155-pound body. Although he weighed relatively little, he had a strong, muscular build, with little body fat. He seemed to enjoy getting hit by pitches, which provided him with another way to reach first base. His willingness to cradle fastballs in his ribs reminded some of rough-and-tumble players like Ron Hunt and Don Baylor, who were also known for being frequently hit with pitches. "It was a proud thing with Tovar to get hit," says Fowler, "and not flinch. Even if Nolan Ryan drilled him, he refused to flinch. He'd run to first base and say, 'You can't intimidate me. You can't hurt me.' "
In 1967, Tovar enjoyed a breakthrough at the plate, scoring 98 runs while leading the American League in at-bats. The following season, with Tovar enjoying another solid season but the Twins well out of contention in the AL pennant race, team owner Calvin Griffith decided to use advantage Tovar's versatility for his own promotional purposes. Griffith outlined a plan that would have Tovar play one inning at each of the nine positions, including pitcher and catcher. Griffith decided that the Tovar "experiment" would take place on September 22 in a game against the Oakland A's.
Tovar began the game as the Twins' starting pitcher. Coincidentally, the first batter that he faced was Campy Campaneris, the pioneer of playing nine positions in a game. In his one inning on the mound, Tovar allowed a walk and committed a balk, but permitted no hits or runs. He also struck out Reggie Jackson, Oakland's top left-handed slugger.
In the second inning, Tovar became the Twins' catcher. Donning oversized catching gear that made him look like a Little League player, Tovar drew laughs from fans--the few that showed up--and fellow players as he took his position behind the plate. "It was absolutely hysterical," says Fowler, "because he came out in the catcher's garb, and the bottom of his chest protector almost dangled on the ground. The place was just howling with delight at the sight of Cesar coming out of the Twins first base dugout in that catching garb. It was just hysterical." Although he didn't look the part of a catcher, Tovar handled the job flawlessly, committing no errors or passed balls while recording a putout.
Having handled the two toughest positions on the field, Tovar then proceeded to make his way around the infield, starting at first base. He played each infield spot from the third through sixth innings, then moved to the outfield in the final three innings, playing left, center, and right in succession. Tovar played brilliantly in displaying his versatility; he completed the game with five putouts, one assist, and no errors--his only miscue being the first-inning balk. As a bonus, Tovar had a productive game at the plate, collecting a hit, a run, and a stolen base in three at-bats.
Forty years later, Tovar's position-per-inning stunt remains his legacy, obscuring the reality that he was a legitimately versatile player--and a good one, too. During a 12-year career that included stints with the Phillies, Rangers, Yankees, and A's (the same team that he played nine positions against, only now relocated to Oakland), Tovar played over 200 games apiece in the outfield, at third base, and at second base. He also made 77 appearances at shortstop, the most demanding of the infield positions.
Just as significantly, Tovar set the table as the Twins' leadoff man in the late sixties and early seventies, hitting in front of Hall of Famers Rod Carew and Harmon Killebrew and 1960s standout Tony Oliva. Playing in nearly 1500 games overall, Tovar batted .278, scored 834 runs, and stole 226 bases. He also gained a reputation as a late-inning killer of no-hitters, breaking up five potential pitching gems over his career.
On the night that Tovar died from pancreatic cancer in 1994, the Twins did not forget him; they announced his passing and a held a moment of silence for him at the Metrodome. Although their former player was never a star, he succeeded in making plenty of friends in the Twin Cities from the mid-sixties through the 1972 season. And for one day in 1968, Cesar Tovar assumed an intriguing place in baseball history.