Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 04, 2006 Tishrei 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:33 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to
IDF Major General Yiftah Ron-Tal. (Army Spokesperson's Office/ Archives)
Last update - 16:52 04/10/2006
IDF general urges army chief to quit his post over 'failure' of war
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent, and Haaretz Service

IDF Major General Yiftah Ron-Tal, in a rare departure from serving officers' customary avoidance of political statements in public, said Wednesday that Chief of Staff Dan Halutz should take responsibility for the failure of the war with Hezbollah, and leave his post.

Ron-Tal, former head of the IDF Ground Forces Command, hinted that he believed that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert should step down as well.

Halutz Wednesday summoned Ron-Tal to discuss his remarks, which were later condemned by the IDF Spokesman's Office in a harshly worded statement.


"Those who directed this war must take responsibility," Ron-Tal told Israel Radio, in an expression widely used as a euphemism for resignation, a usage Ron-Tal declined to deny at several points during his remarks.

"We did not win this war, and it is proper that those who directed it should take responsibility."

Ron-Tal said Wednesday he stood behind remarks he made inn an interview with a Chabad weekly, in which he said: "From the military standpoint, the war ended in failure, and the chief of staff, like other senior commanders, should take responsibility.

"All his life, he has prepared himself for the moment that he would direct a war, and he has no way to duck responsibility for the war and its results," Ron-Tal said. "I believe in taking responsibility, with all the difficulty and pain this generates."

Referring to the Chabad weekly interview, Ron-Tal said Wednesday "I stand behind this, and I think that there is little argument about this, that the commanders of the army should take responsibility for what happened in this war."

He called the decision to have the IDF implement the 2005 disengagement from the Gaza Strip "a serious mistake, for which we are still paying the price." Carrying out the disengagement harmed the army's training program and its readiness for the war with Hezbollah, he said.

Ron-Tal dismissed suggestions that his remarks were inappropriate for a soldier in uniform, saying that he was formally on leave prior to his retirement and had not been in an active command position in the army for a year.

But the IDF Spokesman's Office said in response "It is improper for an officer on retirement leave and receiving a salary from from the IDF to criticize the governmental echelon. The matter is graver still in view of the fact that the major general was a member of the General Staff and was a partner to all the processes and the decisions, among them the disengagement."

Bookmark to
Tipperary and back
The Baltic states are the success story of the former USSR.
Two steps back
Welcome to the flourishing republic of Belarus, the last Soviet dictatorship.
  1.   War 08:33  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
  2.   and take Peretz with you 10:03  |  SJ 04/10/06
  3.   Halutz should have long resigned 10:24  |  Kapule David Mabuta 04/10/06
  4.   Lebanese Communist 11:13  |  Krystal 04/10/06
  5.   Haaretz has censored the most critical bit! 11:29  |  David 04/10/06
  6.   Halutz 11:44  |  Cynic 04/10/06
  7.   war, Lebanese communist 11:47  |  an Israeli 04/10/06
  8.   responsibility 12:29  |  Jan Park 04/10/06
  9.   Of Officers and Gentlemen 13:45  |  Robert 04/10/06
  10.   Krystal & An israeli 14:04  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
  11.   TO LEBANESE COMMUNIST, KRYSTAL AND AN ISRAELI.. 14:20  |  Gabriel 04/10/06
  12.   IDF Statement is Bizzaire 14:33  |  Kapule David Mabuta 04/10/06
  13.   Carthaginians 14:57  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 04/10/06
  14.   To Gabriel 14:58  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
  15.   TO LEBANESE communist 15:21  |  Gabriel. 04/10/06
  16.   Lebanese communist 16:19  |  an Israeli 04/10/06
  17.   Lebanese communist 16:25  |  an Israeli 04/10/06
  18.   To Gabriel again 16:27  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
  19.   Listen to the Military 16:46  |  Alicia 04/10/06
  20.   To an israeli 17:03  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
  21.   Communists, Nazis, Fascists, and Islamofascists 17:07  |  Jake 04/10/06
  22.   Halutz 18:14  |  Cynic 04/10/06
  23.   Lebanese communist 18:41  |  krystal 04/10/06
  24.   To Jack, if my name was Jacob... 19:06  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
  25.   Krystal 19:29  |  Lebanese Communist 04/10/06
 Today Online
Amira Hass: It worked - the Palestinians are killing each other
Responses: 251
Bradley Burston: New torah of Transfer: Pay Arabs U.S. aid to leave
Responses: 42
Editorial: The settlers are expanding in West Bank, with state help
Responses: 60
UNIFIL says could resort to 'use of force beyond self-defense'
Responses: 113
PM to stress Iran nuclear threat in talks with Rice
Responses: 139
Hezbollah listened in on IDF beepers and cell phones
Responses: 78
Rosner's Domain
* The Israel Factor's second round: Gore diving, McCain rising
* "Republicans more pro-Israel" is absolute nonsense
* Poll: Should Israel "bolster" Abbas?
* When Coach Allen came to Tel Aviv

More Headlines
17:52 Rice: U.S. to 'redouble efforts' to help Palestinians
17:57 Abbas: 'No indication' of fresh unity government talks with Hamas
19:14 Israel names Salai Meridor as new ambassador to U.S.
18:51 Government spokeswoman: Illegal West Bank outposts will be removed
13:53 Palestinian killed during police round up of illegal laborers
18:51 Group calling itself al-Qaida in Palestine posts Web video
17:29 Arab, Muslim states blast UN human rights envoys' report on war
19:18 Tal Russo promoted to major general, made IDF's chief of operations
17:02 Lebanese army prevents Hezbollah supporters from protesting near border with Israel
17:02 More than 100 ex-world leaders urge Arab-Israeli peace conference
17:55 In spite of war costs, state boasts NIS 2.6 billion revenue surplus
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
Help those that need it most!
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved