Insight: Chris Gourlay, Jonathan Calvert, Joe Lauria in Washington
Claim your 15 free classical downloads from Passionato now
AN investigation into the illicit sale of American nuclear secrets was compromised by a senior official in the State Department, a former FBI employee has claimed.
The official is said to have tipped off a foreign contact about a bogus CIA company used to investigate the sale of nuclear secrets.
The firm, Brewster Jennings & Associates, was a front for Valerie Plame, the former CIA agent. Her public outing two years later in 2003 by White House officials became a cause célèbre.
The claims that a State Department official blew the investigation into a nuclear smuggling ring have been made by Sibel Edmonds, 38, a former Turkish language translator in the FBI’s Washington field office.
Edmonds had been employed to translate hundreds of hours of intercepted recordings made during a six-year FBI inquiry into the nuclear smuggling ring.
She has previously told The Sunday Times she heard evidence that foreign intelligence agents had enlisted US officials to acquire a network of moles in sensitive military and nuclear institutions.
Her latest claims relate to a number of intercepted recordings believed to have been made between the summer and autumn of 2001. At that time, foreign agents were actively attempting to acquire the West’s nuclear secrets and technology.
Among the buyers were Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), Paki-stan’s intelligence agency, which was working with Abdul Qadeer Khan, the “father of the Islamic bomb”, who in turn was selling nuclear technology to rogue states such as Libya.
Plame, then 38, was the glamorous wife of a former US ambassador, Joe Wilson. Despite recently giving birth to twins, she travelled widely for her work, often claiming to be an oil consultant. In fact she was a career CIA agent who was part of a small team investigating the same procurement network that the State Department official is alleged to have aided.
Brewster Jennings was one of a number of covert enterprises set up to infiltrate the nuclear ring. It is is believed to have been based in Boston and consisted of little more than a name, a telephone number and a post office box address.
Plame listed the company as her employer on her 1999 tax forms and used its name when she made a $1,000 contribution to Al Gore’s presidential primary campaign.
The FBI was also running an inquiry into the nuclear network. When Edmonds joined the agency after the 9/11 attacks she was given the job of reviewing the evidence.
The FBI was monitoring Turkish diplomatic and political figures based in Washington who were allegedly working with the Israelis and using “moles” in military and academic institutions to acquire nuclear secrets.
The creation of this nuclear ring had been assisted, Edmonds says, by the senior official in the State Department who she heard in one conversation arranging to pick up a $15,000 bribe.
One group of Turkish agents who had come to America on the pretext of researching alternative energy sources was introduced to Brewster Jennings through the Washington-based American Turkish Council (ATC), a lobby group that aids commercial ties between the countries. Edmonds says the Turks believed Brewster Jennings to be energy consultants and were planning to hire them.
But she said: “He [the State Department official] found out about the arrangement . . . and he contacted one of the foreign targets and said . . . you need to stay away from Brewster Jennings because they are a cover for the government.
“The target . . . immediately followed up by calling several people to warn them about Brewster Jennings.
“At least one of them was at the ATC. This person also called an ISI person to warn them.” If the ISI was made aware of the CIA front company, then this would almost certainly have damaged the investigation into the activities of Khan. Plame’s cover would also have been compromised, although Edmonds never heard her name mentioned on the intercepts. Shortly afterwards, Plame was moved to a different operation.
The State Department official said on Friday: “It is impossible to find a strong enough way to deny these allegations which are both false and malicious.”
It would be more than two years before Khan was forced to admit he had been selling nuclear weapons technology to Libya, Iran and North Korea.
In the meantime, the role of Plame and Brewster Jennings became public knowledge in 2003. Plame’s husband, Wilson, wrote a report that undermined claims by President George W Bush that Saddam Hussein’s regime had attempted to buy uranium in Niger – a key justification for the invasion of Iraq.
The following week Robert Novak, a journalist, revealed that Wilson’s wife was a CIA agent. In the scandal that followed, Novak’s sources were revealed to be two senior members of the Bush administration. A third, Lewis “Scooter” Libby, was convicted of obstructing the criminal investigation into the affair.
Phillip Giraldi, a former CIA officer, said: “It’s pretty clear Plame was targeting the Turks. If indeed that [State Department] official was working with the Turks to violate US law on nuclear exports, it would have been in his interest to alert them to the fact that this woman’s company was affiliated to the CIA. I don’t know if that’s treason legally but many people would consider it to be.”
The FBI denied the existence of a specific case file about any outing of Brewster Jennings by the State Department official, in a response to a freedom of information request. However, last week The Sunday Times obtained a document, signed by an FBI official, showing that the file did exist in 2002.
Plame declined to comment, saying that she was unable to discuss her covert work at the CIA.
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
£95k
Barnardo's
London
c £82,000
Hampshire County Council
Winchester
£
£23,500 + benefits
MI5
London
£50,000
NHS
Nationwide
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Great Investment, River Views
FOR SALE: Detached Parkside property, large garden
NEC Birmingham 26-28 Sep
Advance ticket offer Two for £10
Excellent USA & Caribbean specials!
£POA
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
In the buildup to WW II, Hitler and his cronies told the German Public many lies; and used the same tactics as now used by the G.W. Bush administration -- to keep things secret. Democracy and freedom, which Bush keeps telling us Americans is why the Moslums hate us, are destroyed by the corrupt use of the "state secrets" ploy. And yes, I do appreatiate the difference between then (the 1930's) and now --- now, we Americans are the guardians of 10,000 nuclear weapons. Thus it is in the interest of the global Community of Nations that the USA be held to the higest of standards -- of honesty and moral charactor -- and not the lowest, as embodied by the Bush-Republican way of doing business.
John Wolfe, Moab, Utah , USA
For all you people all over the world that supported Bill Clinton in 92 & 96 with the claim that "character doesn't matter", does it matter now?
WM, Liberty, TX USA
It might be assumed corrupt elites successfully silence people. Not always. Some people are resilient and will never cave into silencing tactics. Be thankful everyone, Sibel is one tough lady.
Anyone who has ever been at the receiving end of a smear campaign, threats as well as attempts to cause serious injury (blindness), will end up making an important life decision. To permanently remove the Rot from the Ark, or not.
Sam, ancona, italy
Funny how there isn't a word of this in the US press?... So much for "free press" in America - they're no more that a bunch of government lackeys!
Hilton Gray, London, UK
I hope to God these women are being careful. These corrupt elites usually find a way to silence their enemies...
Kevin Mitchell, Vancouver Island, Canada
I want to know the name of this State Department official.
Ken, Seattle, WA, USA
Thank you so much for continuing to report on this. You can be the free press we don't have in the states. Keep up this excellent work and keep the Sibel Edmonds story in the spotlight. Added pressure can only help.
Michael Monk, Raleigh, N.C., USA
Keep up the good work.
You are breaking new ground here. I hope that the series continues. There's so much more to this story - keep digging.
Luke Ryland, Melbourne, Australia
Thank you for your excellent reporting, please keep it up!
tyler, chicago, il
Great article. Couple of minor points:
1. Joe Wilson's report presented evidence for Bush's claims rather than refuting them.
2. Richard Armitage (State Department) was the original "outer" of Plame.
kb, London, UK
Shine your lights directly upon those who, regardless the consequences, seek to tell the truth, while also shining them on those who violate scared trusts...but shine them most intently on those elected/appointed US officials who have completely and undeniably sold their very empty souls....for this specific purpose, it's doubtful a sufficient number of lights exist.
As an extremely concerned American, I very much appreciate your efforts to uncover the truth and expose the frauds...perhaps some of your colleagues from "across the pond" will take note?
L. D. Carl, My Old KY Home, USA
Umm, it was Marc Grossman that outed Brewster-Jennings.
And where is Marc Grossman today???
farang, Tamuning, Guam
Keep up the fantastic display of journalism and do not let go. The American "news" media is a disgrace and nothing more than a modern-day Izvestia or Pravda of the Soviet era, spewing propaganda and brainwashing Joe Sixpack with images of Britney and nothing-else-matters-wall-to-wall election coverage.
You stay on this story! And, when this is over, you'll have my profound gratitude.
Ron Curtis, /Cleburne, Texas, USA
If the Jericho scenario ever happens it will be the US Gov,s fault.
Alan, Chelmsford, UK
Occupied America needs help from the Allies.
Chuck, Peoria, USA
GL40 : How did she know about these things? She 'heard evidence'?
She was translating telecommunications intercepts, she heard them in their own words. If she were lying about this, the people she is naming would be suing the pants off her, not stamping "state secrets privilege" on the case and refusing to let it be heard by a judge even in closed court sessions.
TomPaine, Sydney, Australia
It's pretty sad that Americans have to turn to foriegn media outlets to read something as damning as thing. Makes me wonder what ese our media outlets are ignoring.
Jeremy, Beaumont, Mississippi, USA
Please continue to follow this story. The ''drive by American media'' doesn't have the backbone to do it. I've not read or heard a single word other than a small blurb in the American media. These traitors need to be exposed and punished . It is clear the only way they will ever be brought to justice is by keeping the American informed.
Jay, Dixie, U.S. , S.C.
To GL40 in London, I agree that Israel's involvement is not logical. To your asking about the evidence, you obviously have not followed the Edmons case. When she sued for wrongful dismissal and it looked like these crimes were going to see the light of day, John Ashcroft shut down the case under a seldom used "interests of national security" statute. Of course Jack Nicholson was right."You can't handle the truth."
sc, Agoura Hills,
Thanks so much for your continuing coverage of this vital national security issue! If it wasn't for you keeping light on this subject, we'd have a total media blackout over here in the "Land of the Free, Home of the Brave."
Cheers!
D.M. Slaughter, Los Angeles, CA
Senator McCarthy was right,bless his soul, we need one like him now to clean up the mess.
Hans Schneider, Montreal, Que.Canada
Keep digging. Maybe you will help put some traitors to America in prison.
MJB, Indianapolis, USA
So now any disgruntled employee can say what he/she wants and claims of conspiracy are aired. Sibel Edmonds 'heard evidence' of nefarious activities. Evidence in court? Tittle tattle? We are not told.
Are we really expected to believe that Israel assisted people from countries such as Libya and Pakistan to obtain nuclear secrets? Have you no shame?
RichardM: why aren't you condemning the pro-Turkish lobby as well as the pro-israeli one? Hmm....
GL40, London,
Yes,.. Thank You for bringing this issue to the forefront. These criminals, traitors , and treasonous spy/thieves seeking self enrichments must be exposed. The elite and "Powers to Be" here in America get the white glove treatment no matter what crimes they perpetrate and the media here gives them a free pass.
Again - thank you for the investigative reports and exposing the truth of this criminal conduct. The American media has certainly short changed us - to the benefit of the filthy rich and powerful avaricious warmongers and their fascist military industrial killing machine.
Ararat, Falmouth, Maine - USA
The US government (and therefore the US mainstream media) have been trying to "dissappear" the Sibel Edmonds case. Her allegations may resolve many contradictions in US foreign poilcy under the Bush Administration. Keep digging.
Kramer, Chicago, USA
From behind the iron curtain of information blockout here in the U.S., it's gratifying to know that the corporate media hasn't taken over the entire world yet. This story banned in the U.S., as is all real investigative journalism. Because we no longer have a genuine press in the US, we have a government of war criminals in power, and an "opposition" party that aids and abets.
Jeff N, Loa Angeles, CA
..
If we ever needed proof regarding the power of the pro-Israeli Lobby in America, all we have to do is observe the silence and indifference to this story in the Major US Media, in the halls of Congress, and in the offices of the Executive Branch. Of course on 22 January, Mr. Bush signed a law allowing the US to sell nuclear secrets to Turkey. So, in response to this story, I assume his administration is either covering up the scandal or openly participating in it. Think about the beauty of this setup. Sell nuclear secrets to country X. Terrify the public with the ominous threat that country X will share nuclear weapons with terrorist. Attack country X to keep the "military industrial complex" awash in money. Finally, proclaim yourself heroes for having dealt with country X.
..
richardM, Long Beach, CA
Congratulations on you excellent work to follow the leads of a new, Watergate-like affair that could shook the Establisment of the United States in the election year. This affair has more leads, also to the criminal underworld in Turkey, Russia and the Arab states, and also to Osama bin Laden's al-Qaeda.
The very fact that high-positioned US officials allegedly participated in criminal nuclear proliferation and then in the cover-up of the activities that had involved the intelligence services of Turkey, Pakistan and Israel is an outrage and must be fully examined.
DAVID DASTYCH
Warsaw, Poland
DAVID DASTYCH, Warsaw, Poland
As an American working in Europe, I thank you very much for have the integrity and courage to investigate and expose this affair. I echo the comments of others, that it is a tragedy and shame that US journalism has neither the integrity nor the courage to even mention what you have exposed.
Floyd Rudmin, Tromsø, Norway
We need the help of the international media to save the America we once believed in. Thank you and please keep investigating & exposing the deceptions.
VFP, Washington, DC
great work, folks... you're putting the comatose u.s. news media to shame and are succeeding at putting the house of cards built by the criminals populating the u.s. government in the midst of a well-earned wind tunnel...
http://takeitpersonally.blogspot.com/
Raphael Cruz, Buenos Aires, Argentina
Thank you "Times" for covering this story. Many of us in the states have tried to get this information into the press and onto the agendas of our congresspeople--to no avail. This story has so many twists and turns, and clearly places our country and leadership in a very bad light. However, many of us welcome the facts, which can only come through pressure to investigate. Getting coverage (and hopefully pressure) from your side of the Atlantic is very helpful. Please keep up the excellent reporting.
Danno, Chicago, IL
You guys are doing a great investigative work here; please keep it up. Thank You.
SSP, Virginia, USA
As an American living in Australia, I'm amazed but gratified that an important newspaper is covering this critical story. I only wish the mainstream media in the U.S. would do the same.
Keep up the excellent works. Thanks!
US2oz, Allingham, Australia
Thank you for continuing to dig for the truth. We are helpless in America with a media blackout of this very important story. We are very grateful to have some light shining our way.
Jane Wiley, Phoenix, Arizona
Thanks for your work on this, you guys. Leading the way!
cbears34, Chicago,