NEWS.com.au |
Fox Sports |
Newspapers |
CareerOne |
carsguide |
TrueLocal |
Real Estate |
eBay
The Daily Telegraph - home

Battle stations and it’s all about the money

Malcolm Farr

Wednesday, September 17, 2008 at 11:54pm
 

LABOR is falling back on trademark values as it attempts to attack a millionaire Liberal leader without upsetting all who hope to become millionaires.

It is proposing that only the ALP can relate to the less well-off and that Liberals of any sized bank account can’t.
Extending that, the argument says Turnbull in particular is a friend of moneyed interests and not the disadvantaged _ even as he demanded a $30-a-week rise in aged pensions.
Parliament yesterday was more fiery than recent sittings as Turnbull’s natural aggression replaced the meekness of Brendan Nelson. Prime Minister Rudd was called into combat and the impact was obvious, but with no clear victor.
``I understand the Government is entirely intimidated by the new Leader of the Opposition,’’ Deputy Liberal leader Julie Bishop began in Parliament. A mass bellowing from the Labor side overwhelmed the rest of her sentence.
But she had said enough to point to one of the chief selling points of Turnbull to his Liberal colleagues.
Turnbull was the leader who would add heft to Opposition efforts and rock Kevin Rudd back on his heels politically. The new bloke could take on Rudd directly, matching him intellectually and rolling him when it came to getting things done.
Liberals say there’s been a lot of jawing in the Government with little happening. They see the contest of leaders being the man of action versus the man of talk.
Labor argues Turnbull stands for nothing and has no themes identifying his priorities. Kevin Rudd became Opposition Leader ready to argue for an education revolution, a national broadband network, more action on climate change.
Turnbull has turned up with, so far, little more than existing Opposition positions.
The contest between two men, who each are complex characters in their own ways and who each are self-made in their different fields, has more to run. But first, Labor yesterday had to nail the Malcolm Turnbull it found so objectionable.
Was he the Liberal with a rich bank account or the Liberal with poor political values? Through much of the day senior Labor figures kept trying to hone the attack on what one cheeky MP called the man from, ``Struggle St, Point Piper’’.
Finally they seemed to get it: Malcolm Turnbull could not be criticised for being wealthy, but could be criticised for a bias towards wealthy voters. He couldn’t relate to ordinary Australians, was the theme.
``There’s nothing wrong with being wealthy, there’s nothing wrong with earning a quid and doing well in life,’’ Treasurer Wayne Swan told ABC Radio.
``The Labor Party, and myself in particular, support that objective all the way. It’s the values and the policies that are then adopted [that are wrong].’’

 


Have Your Say

Show Oldest | Newest first    Page 1 of 2      1 2 >

The world’s in financial crisis, our superannuation schemes are being plundered and all the time grocery prices rise and petrol stays high, and Labor attack Turnbull over being a millionaire. Give me strength.

Isn’t Kevin Rudd a millionaire? Isn’t his wife a millionaire? Isn’t Peter Garrett a millionaire? And I’ve no doubt many other MPs on both sides of the house are too.

What I want from the Prime Minister is action that actually does something. No grocery, fuel watch gimmicks. Do something to keep this economy going.

NSW is in recession and Kevin Rudd praises Morris Iemma’s tenure as Premier. It’s so pathetic you have to laugh.

Please do something Kevin - it’s why I voted for you.

truthman replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:09am)

Sorry but you have voted for the dud of all time !and dont forget labor nsw is THE SAME MOB, KRUDD IS THE LEADER OF ALL LABOR,WHAT WAS THAT HE SAID?THEBUCK STOPS WITH ME ,DARN RIGHT IT DOES !IT SURE ISNT COMING OUR WAY.

Angry Voter replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Thu 18 Sep 08 (10:10am)

Hopefully you won’t make that mistake again.

ann replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:17pm)

Impatient voter - I feel your frustration, however I do not think this Rudd Government will ease your great concerns.

I draw attention to this comment below by Caroline Coverington in the Australian in a live blog:

12:43 [Comment:
The ALP under Rudd & Co are clueless when it comes to riding the current domestic / world economic spiral. After 9/11 & the Asian financial crisis Costello was able to navigate the Aust economy through these choppy waters successfully.

Caroline Coverington: 
12:44 I am told that some of the nation’s more experienced economists leave meetings with Swan, shaking their heads in dismay ... and in fear.

Source: 
http://blogs.theaustralian.news.com.au/coverington/index.php/theaustralian/P15/

However, the Rudd Labor Government will continue to Watch:

TurnbullWatch
Beef Stroganoff Lunch Watch
United Nations Watch
New South Wales Labor Watch
FuelWatch
GroceryWatch
BankWatch
WhaleWatch
ComputerWatch
SchoolWatch
InflationWatch
InterestWatch
WaterWatch
CarboneWatch
SolarWatch
PensionWatch
HousingWatch
RentalWatch
TaxWatch
AlcopopsWatch
Ideas20/20SummitWatch
PlasticWatch
StarWatch
WorldWatch
CarWatch
StateWatch
NukeWatch
AsiaWatch
OilWatch
ScoresWatch
PeterCostelloWatch

I have no confidence in this Rudd Labor Government, Breathtaking!

tony replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:21pm)

Ah yes.  Just after becoming PM I remember Krudds appraisal of NSW labor government.  His words were, “They are doing O.K.” So now Kevin it’s taken you 9 months to finally work out what us New South Welshmen have known for the past 6 years.  That NSW labor are the most inept, corrupt and incompetent government in Australian history.  Kevin obviously doesn’t know how bad they really are.

ann replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Thu 18 Sep 08 (01:56pm)

Malcolm - Sorry for any inconvenience, I wish to correct my post:

It should read Caroline Overington.

The link page should read:

Source: Costello’s memoirs: a sneak peekhttp://blogs.theaustralian.news.com.au/coverington/index.php/theaustralian/P15/

Thank You.

Jovial Monk replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Thu 18 Sep 08 (06:22pm)

Ann, I think Caroline just made that stuff up. Like stories about MacQuarrie Bank being in trouble.

Unlike the hammock dweller, Swan (and Tanner, Emerson & Bowen) have high economic qualifications. Very glad the hammock dweller is not still the Treasurer!

Impatient, The Labor government is working hard to ensure we don’t go under even if the US, UK, USSR etc.

One way is by growing the surplus, so eventually the budget will be structurally in surplus, i.e. not just in ‘surplus’ because of asset sales or commodities booms like Costello’s ‘surpluses.’

The reviews are reporting and action will be taken on them.

Rudd will be one of our better PMs

Bassman replied to Impatient voter feeling duped
Fri 19 Sep 08 (04:01am)

er ann...sorry to remind you of this babe but you forgot to mention HOWARDWATCH...between 2006-6 Howard had just on 500 watches,committees and reviews. Let’s be consistent about this. A bit of review and discussion about WorkNOChloices and a few of Howards other Draconian policies might not have gone astray either.

Malcolm Farr

That is an increasingly common plea.

Malcolm Farr
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:34am)

Turnbull is self-made, has started businesses and employed people. He made money. Rudd merely married into it. No comparison. Turnbull has runs on the board in many areas. Rudd is a bureaucrat.

matilda the drovers dog of freo (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:36am)
Marilyn Shepherd replied to matilda the drovers dog
Thu 18 Sep 08 (03:01pm)

Therese Rein did not have a zac when Rudd married her you stupid dog.  She worked like a slave to get it.

Turnbull jumped into bed with a bunch of crooks like Adler and Kennedy.

Merchant bankers are the sorts who have crippled the world economy while morons like you trashed Therese Rein for daring to find work for the disabled.

You morons are really scraping the bottom of the barrel now.

Tator replied to matilda the drovers dog
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:25pm)

Worked like a dog, eh Marilyn, or was it exploiting her hubbys political connections with partners such as Wayne Goss.

TonyP of Newcastle replied to matilda the drovers dog
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:25pm)

She worked like a slave to get it

Of course it was a great help that her business dealt with government contracts and that her husband and other business partners were well placed in government circles.

But in any case,we are talking about Rudd not his wife. What has Rudd done?

Bryson replied to matilda the drovers dog
Fri 19 Sep 08 (12:15am)

“You morons are really scraping the bottom of the barrel now”.
The only one who`s been scraping the bottom of the barrel is Malcolm Farr by letting such an odious,vile old hag such as Marilyn Shepherd grace his blog.
How many blogs have you been banned from now Marilyn?

Malcolm - trademark values?

I wonder, what is so different between these two parties values and beliefs:

Party 1:
We are the party of initiative and enterprise;
We believe in the inalienable rights and freedoms of all peoples; and we work towards a lean government that minimises interference in our daily lives; and maximises individual and private sector initiative.
We believe in government that nurtures and encourages its citizens through incentive, rather than putting limits on people through the punishing disincentives of burdensome taxes and the stifling structures of Labor’s corporate state and bureaucratic red tape.
We believe in those most basic freedoms of parliamentary democracy - the freedom of thought, worship, speech and association.
We believe in a just and humane society in which the importance of the family and the role of law and justice is maintained.
We believe in equal opportunity for all Australians; and the encouragement and facilitation of wealth so that all may enjoy the highest possible standards of living, health, education and social justice.
We believe that, wherever possible, government should not compete with an efficient private sector; and that businesses and individuals - not government - are the true creators of wealth and employment.
We believe in preserving Australia’s natural beauty and the environment for future generations.
We believe that our nation has a constructive role to play in maintaining world peace and democracy through alliance with other free nations.
In short, we simply believe in individual freedom and free enterprise; and if you share this belief, then ours is the Party for you.

Party 2:
We value our nation’s long-term prosperity—achieved through a modern, competitive economy and ensuring quality of life for all Australians.
We value our security—security for our family, our community and our country. We are proud of our men and women who have served our nation and those who have died in the service of their nation.
We value fairness and equality and believe in a fair go for all—we believe that a nation should be governed in the broader interests of all, not in the sectional interests of a few.
We value our communities and our families. Our families are the bedrock of our communities which we need to nurture, protect and support.
We value our democratic and public institutions, which have the power to address exclusion and disadvantage.
We value compassion and dedicate ourselves to social justice. We believe that it is the Australian way to work together to help alleviate suffering and disadvantage when we can.
We value the environment that sustains us all—and which we must now sustain with our country’s united and urgent effort.
We value liberty—the freedom to hold whatever beliefs we choose while respecting those of others; the freedom to express those beliefs without fear or favour; and the economic freedom to pursue our own employment and enterprise.
We believe in opportunity, creativity and innovation as the basis for individual aspiration and being rewarded for hard work, achievement and success.

I wonder?

ann of wa (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:39am)
truthman replied to ann
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:11am)

Shame the labor party doesnt believe in honesty !!

tony replied to ann
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:53am)

Tony from lawson.  “We value liberty - the freedom to hold whatever beliefs we choose while respecting those of others.” It’s a shame some of the labor supporters that get on these blogs didn’t live by their values.

“We believe that a nation should be governed in the broader interest of all, not in the sectional interests of a few.” Hahahahahah.  Well NSW labor have lived up to this.  They have trashed and disadvantaged everyone, not just one lot of people.

tony replied to ann
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:26pm)

I almost forgot - “We believe in opportunity, creativity and innovation as the basis for individual aspiration and being rewarded for hard work, achievement and success.” Wow.  This is straight out of the big business manual.  Well, we’re still waiting here in NSW to be rewarded for our hard work.

Labor would do well to shut their mouths on this topic.. It’ll go nowhere. One just has to mention Rudd, Keating and any other of a number of multi-millionaire laborites… As for Malcom only looking out for the wealthy. How is that different to only looking out for the wealthy unions. Wayne wayne wayne.. don’t kid yourself into thinking that the average voter doesn’t see straight through this tactic.

Rob of Perth (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (01:10am)

You give too much importance to a self-important prat who sold out his only claim to political fame the minute he had a chance to advance it.

Why don’t you brainless wallies in the media actually check the legislation sometimes and try and understand that things have to be legislated and debated in two houses of parliament before being amended, sent back and forth and then sent to the GG to be made law?

Unlike Howard and his control of the senate seeming to be the norm, it is not.

You all need to stop whining for a dog and pony show - go to the bloody circus.

Marilyn Shepherd (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (03:30am)
Slugga replied to Marilyn Shepherd
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:52am)

Hope you know what you’re rambling about because I’m buggered if I can see the point of your comment.

Outside of your hysterical and bogoted hatred of conservitive politics of course.

Amused replied to Marilyn Shepherd
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:24am)

Mazza, what are you on about here. And who is the self-important prat you refer to, Mr RUDD (my vote for prat) or Mr Turnbull. I do not expect an answer from you though, you only seem to be able to give it out without justification.

Marilyn Shepherd replied to Marilyn Shepherd
Thu 18 Sep 08 (03:05pm)

Turnbull grew up on Point piper and pretends to be a poor boy.  Rudd was a poor boy who worked bloody hard to be PM.

You people don’t have a clue about parliamentary process - do you think question time is parliament?

Malcolm and the rest of the hypocrites spent most of last year claiming that Therese was unworthy because she made money, they spent last year tearing her down with phoney stories of underpaying staff and so on.

Now grow up.

Mr Farr this is the first piece of unmitigated drivel of yours I’ve read. Is this what the great Rudd has come to-make the bullets but leave others to fire them?  Where I come from its called cowardice.

unbeliever (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (05:09am)
Politicaljunkie replied to unbeliever
Fri 19 Sep 08 (08:09am)

Gee, where were you when John Howard was getting Bill Heffernan to make his proxy attacks on Julia Gillard being childless or on Justivce Michael Kirby?

By your own definition, having others make your attacks is an act of cowardice, so I give you John Winston Howard, Liar, Racist, War Monger, Human Rights Abuse, Sychophant and Coward. 

Incidentally, where I come from, you have what we call a “selective memory” - Quite common among conservatives and Howard huggers.

Malcolm Farr

Here on Earth we call it debate.

Malcolm Farr
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:35am)

Malcolm,question for you that no journalist wants to give me straight answer so far and my email usualy goes under rock.Is it not true that Rudd family made millions out of government contracts?  question

SBE of Randwick (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (05:36am)
Robbie replied to SBE
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:26am)

...but kicked off under the Goss regime.

Desmond Harris replied to SBE
Fri 19 Sep 08 (11:23am)

Malcolm I notice you were very quick to point out-in defense of the Rudds no doubt- that Mrs. Rudd won Federal Government contracts from the Howard Government. This means that Kevin Rudd was quite happy for his wife to place people in jobs under the dreadful (according to Rudd and Labor) Work Choices legislation. What a hypocrite-its like accepting blood money. grin

Malcolm Farr

Ms Rein did indeed make money by competing with other job search providers for government contracts, both in Queensland and federally, mainly during the government of John Howard.

And to Des Harris: SBE asked me a question at 5.36am and I answered just over three hours later. That’s not a rush. Stop making things up. I should apologise for being so slow.
And I can’t work out which industrial relations system you expected Rein clients to work in. There was only one federal government. 

Malcolm Farr
Fri 19 Sep 08 (11:42am)

When will Labor learn that Australians today are not class concious to any great extent, and that it is extremely hypocritical for a very wealthy Kevin Rudd (Peter Garrett too and others) to claim that Malcolm Turnbull is rich and therefore suggest that he is a lesser person. What about the multi-millionaire former Labor PMs Hawke and Keating, are they too to be ridiculed. Rudd is scared of Turnbull, and given their achievements before politics, education and career paths/experience, he should be. And Swannie too. A message for Kevin 07, now Mistake 08, get on with governing, reduce the overseas travelling, stop watching and do something positive for a change.

D.Thompson (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (07:12am)

So the labor party decided they couldn’t criticise Mr. Turnbull for his wealth (a self made millionaire having made his money through the private sector), but he wouldn’t be able to relate to ordinary Australians.  I would love to ask Mr. Rudd “what exactly is an ordinary Australian”.  Is it the pensioner who is struggling to get by, is it the bloke earning $30,000 a year and in the process supporting a family, is it someone who is on the average weekly wage.  I watched question time yesterday and some of you labor blokes make me sick.  Several millionaires on your frontbench and you are trying to tell me (a part aged pensioner) that they relate to “ordinary Australians”.  The hypocrisy is overwhelming.  I consider myself an “ordinary Australian” and I admire people who have humble beginnings and through hard work make something of themselves, especially through the private sector.  These people have the guts and drive and willpower to better themselves and at the end of the day I personally don’t care what political views they have.  Obviously Mr. Rudd’s wife was one of these people, starting from scratch and doing well.  Does this mean that now Mrs. Rudd cannot relate to “ordinary Australans”, I don’t think so!

Anna Mulder of CP (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (07:25am)
Sullo replied to Anna Mulder
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:49am)

Anna,

Ordinary Australians” live in ”working families” all over this country…

The Labor Party would want to be very very careful about throwing stones, because with Turnbull at the helm, a few will come back and may well be aimed at a few well heeled Labor MP’s who would rather their asset status remain quiet. The response to Rudd and his wealth was a fair warning of where he intends to come from. There is a real challenger now and I am not sure Rudd and Co. know how to handle him.

Ed of Kalaru (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (07:39am)

Poor Wayne, he is a very nervous man.
Labor attacks on people who have done well in the private sector, highlight what abject failures both Kevin and Wayne were when they left the safe folds of the Labor beauracracy.

Steve (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (07:51am)
ann replied to Steve
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:01pm)

Steve - I agree with you:

Poor Wayne, he is a very nervous man.

I have no confidence in Kevin Rudd, Wayne Swan, Julia Gillard and Lindsay Tanner to manage the Australian Economy in such dangerous times.

I draw attention to this amazing comment by Caroline Coverington a Journalist at the Australian Newspaper in a live blog:

12:43 [Comment:
The ALP under Rudd & Co are clueless when it comes to riding the current domestic / world economic spiral. After 9/11 & the Asian financial crisis Costello was able to navigate the Aust economy through these choppy waters successfully.

Caroline Coverington: 
12:44 I am told that some of the nation’s more experienced economists leave meetings with Swan, shaking their heads in dismay ... and in fear.

Source: 
http://blogs.theaustralian.news.com.au/coverington/index.php/theaustralian/P15/

I shall repeat - Economists shake their heads in dismay and in fear?????

I say to all my fellow Australians be afraid be very afraid!!!

Breathtaking!

I again call for our Journalists to report with Truth and Balance and without Fear or Favour, we must hold this Labor Government Accountable.

Adrian replied to Steve
Thu 18 Sep 08 (10:20pm)

It’s Caroline Overington, Ann.

You’re going to a blog on The Australian and quoting a journo making an unproven allegation by an unnamed economist.

This same journo had to apologise after verbally abusing a Labor candidate on election day last year. Some witnesses claim she did more than just verball abuse him.

So what we have here is a journo with a known Liberal leaning making an allegation by someone she doesn’t quote.

Show me the economists that have walked out of a meeting with Swan and publicly said they are either dismayed or afraid… Thought not. But that’s all part of the conspiracy by the journalists, isn’t it, Ann?

Are interest rates still going up? No.

Is unemployment going up? No, in fact it fell again last month.

Are we having to bail out our banks like the US and Europe? Nope.

How’s the Aussie dollar going? Pretty good, sitting at 80 cents US. Gone down a bit recently, but that only helps our exporters compete better in the global marketplace.

Is any of that Wayne Swans’ doing? Highly unlikely. He’s got about as much control over such matters as you or I. Fact is, despite your nightly prayers that your fellow Australians are suddenly jobless and homeless and can blame it all on Labor, it hasn’t happened. And yet here we are nearly 11 months since we changed goverments.

Here’s another baseless rumour on a blog for you, Ann: You’re a rabid Howard Hugger who believes everything a conservative journo writes, so long as it’s denigrating the evil ALP.

Start quoting facts, as opposed to blogs.

Malcolm why do labor continue with this class war thing?  If anyone shattered the class war myth it was Howard, providing millions of Australians the opportunity to own their own homes, have a job and a family.  And Mr Swan is being a tad hypocritical when saying there is nothing wrong with being a millionaire and in the next breath attacking Turnbull for being one and supporting rich people.  Just look at some of the labor figures who are more than well off and also have their snouts in the trough.  And the trough is getting bigger with Rudd’s new taxes.

And Nelson, like Beazley was too nice.  Finally we have someone to belt Rudd about the head.  And Turnbull has picked a very big, over ripe target in NSW.  I like what I see in Turnbull so far.  It appears he’s not going to pussyfoot around or hold back.  And with their low approval rating they have nothing to lose at the moment.  And with labor in power just about across the whole country it’s about time they were brought back a peg or two.  I doubt Turnbull would win the next election but it appears he is a good long term leader prospect.  A new face with an aggressive nature.  Perhaps he can get that fat head of Rudds to actually turn around for once in parliament and face his opposition instead of sitting with his back turned, such is his arrogance.

tony of lawson (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:10am)

I agree with Wayne Swan here. I used to live in the eastern suburbs and came into contact with Malcolm Turnbull all the time. He has no idea what people are struggling with. He has no idea what the battlers are doing or cant afford to do. His poll workers are pompous blue bloods and they make no bones about it either at campaigns. If Australians think this guy is on their side they really are dumb. Great article though Malcolm. big surprise

Daniel of Sydney (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (08:38am)
John replied to Daniel
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:15am)

Correction: Kevin Rudd has no idea what people are struggling with. He has no idea what the battlers are doing or cant afford to do. His poll workers are pompous blue bloods and they make no bones about it either at campaigns. If Australians think this guy is on their side they really are dumb.

Malcolm Turnbull is a self-made man who actually earned his living, and can relate to those who are battling to do the same.  He brings a wealth of experience (conspiciously absent in the Labor ranks).

Rudd is a glorified bureaucrat who has no clue of the struggles of ordinary Australians - much less any idea about how to address them.  angry

Gerard Hoyle replied to Daniel
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:42am)

And your little man Kevin07 is such a nice boy. He loves old dogs and children and watermelon wine.

Daniel replied to Daniel
Thu 18 Sep 08 (11:00am)

John,

i couldnt agree more with you. That why the only Australian leader that does know what people are going through is Bob Brown from the Australian Greens. big surprise

Thats a bit rich coming from the discracefull labor mob” who are the same mob as nsw ,take krudds wife she runs a employment agency which is funded by the taxpayers (120 million )and while “krudd the country wrecker “is bleating” on about work choices ,employment companies like hers rip 50%of unemployed persons wage off for the 1st 3 mths of his/hers employment when they find them a job on a 3 mths trial, on top of the funding they get from taxpayers,what a hypocrit”,and if thats not eneough here the union is going to court to try and get the same high wages” that the awa” workers are on 54,000 versus 72,000 on awa for the same job in public service,sounds like someone has been telling a lot of lies to us from where i stand,rotten to the core thats labor.

truthman (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:05am)

Why should we pick on richer people? Why have a “luxury” car tax? I am not rich, but I recognise that rich people pay more than their fair share of tax, and have usually risked a lot to get to where they are.

Youngster (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:23am)
Politicaljunkie replied to Youngster
Fri 19 Sep 08 (11:33am)

Hmmmm Half the HIH board were born into wealth, Adler was literally born with a silver spoon in his mouth. Not too sure how much hard work was involved there.

The assumption that all wealth comes from hard work and risk is flawed as the assumption that people on lower incomes aren’t working hard enough (Try visiting a call centre at any major corporation)

Daniel ,and swan does? give me a break these spin clowns dont know how to run anything just look at nsw.

truthman (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (09:32am)

One point I’d like to have cleared up is the reference to Rudd being a ‘self made man’ like Turnbull. My understanding is that Rudd is little more than a power hungry political bureaucrat used to crunching numbers and playing the party game. I believe it is Rudd’s wife who is the self made success. He looks more like the ‘hanger on’ in that relationship.

Turnbull has made it in business on his own. There seems little comparison between the two.

Pete of sydney (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (10:03am)

Malcolm, you said that yesterday, there was not a clear victor.To have a victor you have to have more than one in a contest and see that contest through to the end.Mr Rudd when asked a question now drivels on about anything that has absolutely no relevance to the question.When the opposition wants a point of order for relevance he gets his stooge, the Speaker,Mr Jenkins,to ask “have you finished” to which the illustrious Mr Rudd like a mongrel dog with it’s tail between it’s legs sit down and say “yes”.This happened on numerous occassions not just the once.Then he gets his cowardly attack dogs to get personal with response to their own ‘Dorothy Dixes’.When can you get a victor when one side refuses to show any courage in the debate.To pull out of the debate just shows how inept one is.I thought that when you were on with David Spears yesterday that you might have been a bit more balanced in noticing this, then of course you were with Mr Spears and we all know were he comes from, being one half of the bookends for Labor.

Ron of Toowoomba (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (10:15am)
proud aussie replied to Ron
Thu 18 Sep 08 (11:43am)

Wise contribution Ron of Toowoomba, and guess what?  You are 100% correct.  I agree with your observation of what goes on in Parliament and I have witnessed Mr Albanese handing the questions to be asked, over to the two very unhappy looking females who sit behind him. Most of team Rudd look very nervous and unhappy to me.
When a Liberal back bencher asks a question of the Rudd team, they cannot answer, for without their notes, they haven’t got a clue how to respond. Recently Mr Rudd was asked a question by a back bencher who was not of the Labor Party, and his response was something like this “ I am not across the board on that issue, but I tell you what, come and see me in my office, we’ll have a cup of tea and work through it.” OH BROTHER!
What an embarrassment is this man!

I have given up watching Sky Channel, just could not take anymore of David Speers and Keiran Gilbert with their empty bias.
You are, of course, correct with your assessment of these two wrongly informed journalists. Even the News readers opened the other night with ‘multi-millionaire, Malcolm Turnbull....” I felt embarrassed for them, just like I feel embarrassed for most of the journalists who blindly use the Rudd Press Releases for their political information.  Where is integrity and quality with our political reporting?

Politicaljunkie replied to Ron
Fri 19 Sep 08 (11:29am)

Sorry, Proud Aussie accusing others of Bias. I laughed out loud.

I bet you still think Piers Akerman is objective and balanced too?

It’s a very slippery slope, given that Kevin and Therese Rudd are a VERY wealthy couple themselves.

Braz of Sydney (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (11:30am)

I am truly sorry, but I didn’t realise we lived in a country where it is taboo for successful people who get off their backsides and make something of their lives and reach high positions in politics get canned for it. I guess the rest (i.e. losers) just join the Labor Party or a union or the Daily Tele and criticise successful people.

Arthur of South Brisbane (Reply)
Thu 18 Sep 08 (12:55pm)
AG replied to Arthur
Thu 18 Sep 08 (05:56pm)

And Malcolm, Divisive journalism is.... well...divisive journalism.  And that my friend is a fact.

Malcolm Farr

Arthur, nominate where I or anyone in the Daily Telegraph have criticised Malcolm Turnbull for being successful. And when you have to acknowledge that you merely made up the suggestion contained in your post, remember the maxim that opinions are sacred but facts are divine.

And AG, I have no idea what you are on about and am assuming from the incompleteness of your sentence that you don’t know either.

Malcolm Farr
Fri 19 Sep 08 (10:47am)


Show Oldest | Newest first    Page 1 of 2      1 2 >

Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide a name, you may use a screen name – this will be published with your comment, and a working email address – not for publication, but for verification. The suburb/location field is optional.
( Read our publication guidelines ).


Submit your comments here:

   
 

How to add a link: Enter the text you wish to be clickable, select it and click the 'Link' button to enter the link details in the popup box. Maximum of 2 links.


* Required Fields

 

Insert an emoticon Insert an emoticon



 

Profile

Malcolm Farr

Malcolm Farr

Malcolm Farr is one of the nation's most influential (and interesting) political commentators. Want to understand what's going on in Canberra? Ask Mal.


Advertisement

Latest Articles

Article Icon - Comments
Battle stations and it’s all about the money 65
Libs go for passionate bruiser 71
Political death on the pension mountain 25
The luxury tax they can’t afford to do without 47
The Costello square-up 82
Voters mad as hell and calling for blood 30
NSW Labor’s stained legacy 117
Fielding feels the pressure 59
Pats on the back for a job far from done 79
Malcolm Turnbull the ghost that haunts the Liberal Party 62

Categories

Topic Posts Latest

View Entries by Date

September 2008
S M T W T F S
 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        

Monthly Archives

Most Recent Comments

Politicaljunkie says: A really dumb ploy by Labor. Malcolm Turnbull has a track record of putting his foot in…
(Fri 19 Sep 08 at 08:03am)
Rick says: For the liberal under John Howard it was THE BATTLERS. For the labor party under Kevin Ruhh…
(Thu 18 Sep 08 at 11:09pm)
SOLO says: Is there a difference between Le labor party and the liberal party ? NO NO NO NO NO If you…
(Thu 18 Sep 08 at 10:22pm)
Jovial Monk says: For God’s sake the ALP comments were that Malcolm was out of touch. Regarding Malcolm, I…
(Thu 18 Sep 08 at 06:32pm)
steve says: I thought Australia had got passed the ‘rich man poor man’ syndrome - if Malcolm Turnbull…
(Thu 18 Sep 08 at 04:14pm)
Moreton Voter says: Dont you just love it when you hear Swan talking Values with his comparison of Turnbull and…
(Thu 18 Sep 08 at 03:42pm)
Desmond Harris says: Both Turnbull and Rudd are very wealthy people and therefore the Labor Party would be compounding…
(Thu 18 Sep 08 at 03:07pm)

Related Links

Tools