Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., October 25, 2008 Tishrei 26, 5769 | | Israel Time: 06:51 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Peres Center Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 12:57 24/10/2008
Dennis Ross on why he's working for Obama and how he'd talk to Iran
By Natasha Mozgovaya
Tags: Israel News, Iran 

WASHINGTON - Ahead of the American elections, Dennis Ross, the man who used to work as President Bill Clinton's envoy to the Middle East, has been busy "working" the shuls in Florida, a key battleground state in the presidential election. Aside from sitting on the boards of many different research institutes, Ross also acts as Democratic candidate Barack Obama's Middle East advisor. In addition, he is a leading contender - among some 300 candidates - for the post of secretary of state in an Obama government. This week he sat down and talked to Haaretz.

How was it in Florida? How did people react and what are the main concerns of the local Jewish community?

Ross: "When I was down there a few weeks ago, I think there were many more questions about Senator Obama than what I see among audiences today. The questions that are asked now show that people are beginning to decide that they want to go for him, and they want to be satisfied. I think there's a desire to understand the nature of his relationship to Israel, how he would approach Iran, and [what] he thinks about the peace process. I would say those are the three big questions I was asked in one form or another everywhere I went."
Assuming that the next president's capacity to deal with these issues will be limited because of national debt, two ongoing wars and the recent financial crisis, can he really promise anything - and keep his word?

"In the first instance, [Obama] views the issue of Iran as an urgent priority, because the Bush administration's approach to Iran has failed. I talk about how Obama wants to use our willingness to talk as a means to get others to actually apply more pressure on the Iranians, as a way to ensure the talks' success, but also because the talks themselves send a signal [to] those who fear [that] applying more pressure means you're descending toward a slippery slope of confrontation. This is a way of saying, 'Look, we're trying to see if there's a way to avoid that.' Preventing Iran from going nuclear is a very high priority for him, not only because it's such a threat to Israel, but because it's such a threat to the United States.

"On the question of Israel, I talk about what I saw during his trip to Israel, how I saw his understanding of the relationship with Israel - he would describe it as a commitment of the head and heart. He looks at Israel and sees us as being two countries with common values. But he also looks at Israel and sees that whatever threatens Israel also happens to threaten the United States. So we have a [common] interest, because we end up facing the same threats.

"Regarding the peace process, I think this is an issue where engagement is also crucial, but, much like Iran, it is an engagement without illusions. When you engage, you do so without illusions. But when you don't engage, you leave the way open for your adversaries to actually gain more. The Bush administration wanted to disengage for its first six years in office. [By doing so] they actually strengthened Hamas' hand, because Hamas' argument is [that] there is no possibility for peace. The least you want to do is show that there could be an alternative answer."

What kind of engagement might it be? The Israeli government isn't fond of being under pressure, and some people are very sensitive about the idea of talking to Iran, especially since the Iranian leadership is saying nasty things about Israel.

"Sure, that's why I started by saying that it's an engagement without illusions. With regard to the Iranians, we know that by not talking to Iran the U.S. did not improve the situation. Today Iran is a nuclear power - it doesn't have nuclear weapons yet, but in 2001 it was not yet able to convert uranium or uranium gas, it didn't have a single centrifuge. Now it's stockpiling highly enriched uranium. So the current approach of not talking hasn't worked. There's no guarantee that if you talk you'll succeed, but if you don't talk you will fail."

Does one talk to Mahmoud Ahmadinejad?

"You don't talk to Ahmadinejad. First of all, he's not the decision maker. When Senator Obama suggests that he would be prepared to meet with him, he says such a meeting first has to be prepared. What he means is that you have to coordinate with your allies - all your allies. Secondly, it means you have to check whether you can put together an agenda for a lower-level meeting. If it becomes clear that you can't put together such an agenda, then you don't hold a meeting at a high level - the presidential level - because it's not going to lead anywhere. But if you can produce something that you know will lead somewhere, then it's silly not to do that.

"And in terms of the peace process, if you don't engage, then by definition, Hamas becomes stronger. We've seen that. Senator Obama won't deal with a non-state actor like Hamas unless Hamas changes its position, unless it's prepared to recognize Israel, unless it makes it clear [that] it gives up on terror, unless it's prepared to recognize previous agreements. So as for non-state actors, he's not willing to deal with them. Engagement without illusion in the peace process means that the U.S. should play a role, the U.S. should be involved, the U.S. should do what it can to promote the peace process and build bridges where it can.

"At the end of the day his position is [that] we cannot impose peace, because an imposed peace isn't peace at all. He's more than willing to invest in the process, but, then again, how he does it and in what ways will depend very much on the circumstances, and obviously there are many other issues out there."

Do you believe Israel and the Palestinians can reach an agreement in the near future? Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said she'll do her utmost to try and reach a framework agreement by the end of the Bush administration.

"I think that in the current circumstances, it's difficult to see that happening. It's important for the two sides to do what they can, but I think we need to be realistic as well."

Leaving the sidelines

Not everyone in Washington likes the Israeli talks with Syria. What do you think?

"The fact that Israel is negotiating indirectly with Syria through Turkey is a sign that Israel believes it's worth trying this approach, and I believe we should try it, too. I think it's a mistake not to. Too often when you don't talk - as I said before - you create a self-fulfilling prophecy. Just because you make the effort doesn't mean you'll succeed. But at least you ought to see if you can do it, you ought to do it with your eyes open, without illusions, without naivete, but it's worth probing and testing."

Why and when did you decide to take on an active role in this campaign?

"I decided to take an active part in the campaign because I feel the stakes are so high. I looked at us, especially in the Middle East, and I think we've been on the sidelines everywhere except [in] Iraq. And when the U.S. is on the sidelines, U.S. interests suffer and I think Israel's interests suffer, too. I felt that I just didn't have the luxury of remaining on the sidelines and sitting this one out."

Some of America's image problems didn't start with the Bush administration. Is it possible to repair the damage?

"One of the problems of the last eight years is that too often we've staked out objectives that we could not achieve. The rest of the world watches and looks for several things. The first is whether we are effective in terms of what we do. Secondly they have to see that we don't just lecture, we also listen."

Can you define what constitutes an American interest right now?

"I think our interest at this point around the world is [that] we do have to contend with the radicalists, they do constitute a serious threat to us. But I think we have to realize who our natural partners are and how we can work with both them and our allies so we, in a sense, build our collective leverage against those who constitute threats to us. It's very clear that we have to restore our economic well-being, because you can't be strong internationally if you're not strong at home, and if you're not strong financially."

Is it about the stakes, or Obama's personality and policies?

"It's a combination. First, the stakes were so high, and I think he's also a unique talent. I've sat in on probably 100 meetings with our presidents - those I've worked for and their counterparts. I know what it takes to be an effective, good leader. I saw Senator Obama at work in meetings with leaders. His manner of operation shows me unquestionably that he's someone who grasps issues in their detail, but also strategically, and he understands how to deal with leaders in an effective way, from the standpoint of promoting America's interests and needs. It's a combination of the stakes but also of seeing in Senator Obama a transformational figure at a time when I think the United States needs a transformational figure."

If Obama wins and you are offered the post of secretary of state, would you accept the offer?

"I'm not assuming that. The truth of the matter is that I'm concentrating on helping him through November 4. Whatever happens after that - we'll see."

What in his character impressed you the most, and what does he lack as a leader?

"I think that what impressed me the most is that he has perspective. He's very thoughtful, he knows how to ask the right questions, and he doesn't jump to conclusions. He's careful with his judgments and he's not afraid to ask questions, because he's not afraid to have people ask him questions. I think he has a kind of personal character and the kind of temperament presidents need.

"I've worked on the National Security Council staff of Ronald Reagan's administration, so I was in that White House. I served in a senior State Department position under George H. W. Bush and then I was President Clinton's negotiator on the Middle East - so I've been around a few American presidents. I've witnessed decision processes, I've been around American presidents at times of crisis, and I think I have a pretty good sense of what it takes for someone to be effective as president - in terms of judgment capability, perspective and even wisdom. And I think Senator Obama brings all those to bear. That's why I find him enormously impressive and believe he is just the person we need at this time."

Some progressive groups have expressed disappointment with him, saying that some of his positions are actually more hawkish than those of President Bush. Suddenly his positions regarding Al-Qaida terrorists, Afghanistan, Pakistan or Iran are becoming harsher.

"I think he is quite realistic. Contrary to what was commonplace practice in the Bush administration, he doesn't let ideology blind or color his thinking. His assessments are based on looking at the world as it is and understanding the kinds of things we'll need to do to change the world where it needs to be changed."

Taking into account the possible "Bradley effect" [referring to the discrepancies between voter opinion polls and the outcome of U.S. election campaigns], the traditional low voting rate and other "unknowns" - do you think Obama will win?

"I certainly hope he will, and I'm cautiously optimistic."
Bookmark to  
Palin as Olmert?
Free flights and life of luxury characterize both the VP hopeful and our outgoing PM
'Hit a Jew Day'
St. Louis middle school students face punishment over spirit week game gone bad
  1.   Talking with Iran? 13:18  |  Brod 24/10/08
  2.   Presidential Standards 13:34  |  Moshe 24/10/08
  3.   Rosey on Mr.Obama. 13:42  |  Stephen. 24/10/08
  4.   It`s called Dennis needs a check, the Saudis write him one. He`s 14:16  |  David 24/10/08
  5.   Dennis Ross: Moron. 14:23  |  Yo 24/10/08
  6.   At least Ross understands 14:41  |  Mark Lincoln 24/10/08
  7.   Why hasn`t this clown... 14:51  |  Veritas 24/10/08
  8.   Secretary of State? 15:10  |  Bryan 24/10/08
  9.   Are the American our allies ?... 15:45  |  Jean Van Daem 24/10/08
  10.   Dennis Ross, part of the solution, or part of the problem...??? 16:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/10/08
  11.   Why, .. because he is out of work 16:54  |  Mike 24/10/08
  12.   News of Obama link to communist party may spoil his chances! 17:17  |  redmike 24/10/08
  13.   Ross is part of the problem 17:22  |  Ira Glunts 24/10/08
  14.   Dennis Ross 17:35  |  steve 24/10/08
  15.   denis ros for obama. 17:42  |  dr. joji cherian 24/10/08
  16.   Baldwin’s approach failed and he was succeeded by Chamberlain. 17:47  |  Mladen Andrijasevic 24/10/08
  17.   Bush Administration Plans 17:52  |  Mark of Lewiston 24/10/08
  18.   Ross, Arafat`s friend a Sad Failed man 18:01  |  AB 24/10/08
  19.   Ross, Arafat`s friend a Sad Failed man 18:02  |  AB 24/10/08
  20.   Ross - The Road to Hell Is Paved With Good Intentions 18:08  |  Tod Zuckerman 24/10/08
  21.   America is not important 18:11  |  Atoo 24/10/08
  22.   Ross, Arafat`s friend a Sad Failed man 18:18  |  AB 24/10/08
  23.   3 intifadas? 18:37  |  Ben Packer 24/10/08
  24.   taylors 18:37  |  Shmuelshachor 24/10/08
  25.   Ross and the Grand Delusion 18:54  |  Binyamin 24/10/08
  26.   It`s not talk versus confronting. It`s both. 19:00  |  Fortuna Benmayor 24/10/08
  27.   Dennis Ross: Israel`s lawyer 19:07  |  ManintheMiddle 24/10/08
  28.   Ira Glunts 19:09  |  Persian Kitty 24/10/08
  29.   to #5 19:14  |  Rose 24/10/08
  30.   Ross Is Aiming at New Failures - In the Shadow of Axelrod 20:30  |  notostupidrules 24/10/08
  31.   Don`t worry Zionists: He`ll make sure no peace deal is signed 20:35  |  peacelover 24/10/08
  32.   to Red Mike 20:38  |  Nathan 24/10/08
  33.   To #16, Binyamin. How about some homework? 20:46  |  Mladen Andrijasevic 24/10/08
  34.   To AB Ross is an honrable man 22:08  |  gus 24/10/08
  35.   Obama has Ross to divert attention from anti-Israel advisors 22:20  |  JM 24/10/08
  36.   Swiss Dino 22:33  |  Philippe 24/10/08
  37.   #18 22:35  |  Philippe 24/10/08
  38.   #.3 Redmike.... Obama linked to UFO group.! 22:46  |  Stephen. 24/10/08
  39.   redmike and Communism 23:12  |  Arnold Shore 24/10/08
  40.   A Wise Approach to the Affairs of State of the USA 23:26  |  Leeza Cohen Coleman 24/10/08
  41.   Peacelover, you`re spot on. 23:37  |  ManintheMiddle 24/10/08
  42.   GO DENNIS, GO AHEAD, BABY 23:46  |  indrajaya 24/10/08
  43.   Not So Fast There Big Guy 23:51  |  Solomon the Wise 24/10/08
  44.   TO: peacelover 23:51  |  Mark Bernadiner 24/10/08
  45.   Be very afraid 00:05  |  zaz 25/10/08
  46.   #33 Indrajaya 00:58  |  Bryan 25/10/08
  47.   Dennis Ross-- another Pollard 01:50  |  American in NY 25/10/08
  48.   Blank resume.... 02:46  |  Blogowitz 25/10/08
  49.   Dennis Ross does know his right from his left 03:00  |  D 25/10/08
  50.   Dennis Ross does know his right from his left 03:02  |  Dwido 25/10/08
  51.   # 46, BRYAN 03:50  |  indrajaya 25/10/08
  52.   #46 - Bryan: You are absolutely, totally 100% right. 04:25  |  Yo 25/10/08
  53.   #27 ManintheMiddle 05:28  |  Bryan 25/10/08
  54.   What Peace Entails 05:41  |  Bryan 25/10/08
  55.   # 53, BRYAN 06:42  |  indrajaya 25/10/08
 Read & React
'Hit a Jew Day' lands St. Louis students in hot water
Responses: 199
Peres in Sharm el-Sheikh: Saudi plan can bring peace to Mideast
Responses: 82
Bradley Burston: When Sarah Palin runs for president
Responses: 104
U.S. Muslims relieved by Powell's attack on anti-Islam rhetoric
Responses: 141
Anshel Pfeffer: Should Pius XII be made a saint? Leave that to the Vatican to decide
Responses: 61

More Headlines
17:59 Livni camp: Shas has deceived the entire country
21:48 ANALYSIS / Shas betting on its renewed alliance with Benjamin Netanyahu
20:44 Israeli businessman reportedly kidnapped in Ghana
12:57 Dennis Ross on why he's working for Obama and how he'd talk to Iran
22:53 Bradley Burston / When Sarah Palin runs for president
13:53 Is President Peres on his way to becoming a British knight?
06:48 Palestinian security forces loyal to President Abbas deploy in Hebron
18:27 Four people killed in small plane crash in the Sharon
14:02 Mourners bury family of four killed in apparent murder-suicide
11:54 New Gallup poll shows 75% of U.S. Jews plan to vote Obama
12:19 Abducted soldier Gilad Shalit receives letter from family, says France
13:22 Rumors flurry about Ahmadinejad's health following event cancellations
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
Living in Israel Studying in English
Click & Meet our students from all around the world
Dial 013 for your long-distance calls
and get all your money back
Vote for real change. Request your ballot today!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on
Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
Hebrew Summer courses
From $39.95
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
birthright Israel | Search engine marketing, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved