NETWORK18

News Videos Blogs

Rajdeep Sardesai

Ads by Google

Friday , October 31, 2008 at 01 : 23

Font Size A+A-

An Open Letter to Raj Thackeray


Email PrintBlog
Ads by Google

My Dear Raj,

My apologies for having to communicate through the editorial pages of a newspaper, but frankly am left with little choice since you seem to have decided to stay away from the so-called 'national' non-Marathi media. Let me at the very outset say that I am impressed with the manner you have carved a niche on the political landscape of Maharashtra. I distinctly remember meeting you in February last year soon after the Mumbai municipal corporation elections. It wasn't the best of times: your party, the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena had been marginalized while your cousin Udhav Thackeray and the Shiv Sena had captured power in the city. With many of your supporters deserting you, you appeared down, if not quite out. Twenty months later, I see you've bounced back: every local and national daily has you on the front page, you are the subject of television debates and your politics has even united Bihar's warring netas.

And yet, my friend, there is a thin line between fame and notoriety, more so in the fickle world of politics. Bashing north Indian students may grab the headlines, getting arrested may even get you sympathy and strident rhetoric will always have a constituency, but will it be enough to secure your ultimate dream of succeeding your uncle Bal Thackeray as the flagbearer of Marathi asmita (pride)?

If Balasaheb in the 1960s rose to prominence by targeting the south Indian "lungiwala", you have made the north Indian "bhaiyaa" the new 'enemy'. In the 1960s, the Maharashtrian middle class in Mumbai was feeling the pressure of job competition for white collar clerical jobs. Today, it seems that there is a similar sense of frustration at losing out economically and culturally to other social groups in Mumbai's endless battle for scarce resources. With the Congress and the NCP having become the real estate agents of the state's rural-urban bourgeoise and the Shiv Sena a pale shadow of its original avatar, the space has been created for a charismatic leader to emerge as a rabble-rouser espousing the sons of the soil platform.

But Raj, I must remind you that electoral politics is very different from street agitations. Sure, round the clock coverage of taxis being stoned and buses being burnt will get you instant recognition. Yes, your name may inspire fear like your uncle's once did. And perhaps there will always be a core group of lumpen youth who will be ready to do your bidding. But how much of this will translate into votes? Identity politics based on hatred and violence is subject to the law of diminishing returns, especially in a city like Mumbai, the ultimate melting pot of commerce. Your cousin Udhav tried a "Mee Mumbaikar" campaign a few years ago that was far more inclusive, but yet was interpreted as being anti-migrant. The result was that the Shiv Sena lost the 2004 elections - Lok Sabha and assembly - in its original citadel of Mumbai. Some statistics suggest that nearly one in every four Mumbaikars is now a migrant from UP or Bihar. Can any political party afford to alienate such a large constituency in highly competitive elections?

Maybe, your not even looking at winning seats at the moment, but simply staking claim to the Sena legacy in a post Bal Thackeray scenario. Perhaps, thats exactly what the ruling Congress-NCP combine in Maharashtra wants: like a market leader who gets competing brands to crush each other, the Congress-NCP leadership seems to be practicing divide and rule politics once again. They did it with Balasaheb and the communists in the 1960s, with Bhindranwale and the Akalis in the 1980s, even with the Kashmir valley politicians in the 1990s. A larger-than-life Raj Thackeray suits the ruling arrangement in Maharashtra because it could erode its principal rival, the Shiv Sena's voter support. It's a dangerous game, but often when politicians run out of ideas, they prefer to play with fire. It's a fire that could leave Mumbai's cosmopolitanism scarred for life.

Now, before you see my writings as the outpourings of an anglicized non-resident Maharashtrian, let me just say that, like you, I too am proud of my roots. I too, would like to see the cultural identity of Maharashtrians preserved and the economic well-being of our community assured. Where we differ is that I am a citizen of the Republic of India first, a proud Goan Maharashtrian only later. Fourteen years ago, I left Mumbai for Delhi to seek professional growth and was distinctly fortunate to be readily embraced by the national capital. Like millions of Indians, I too am a migrant and a beneficiary of a nation whose borders don't stop at state checkpoints.

Moreover, I cannot accept that 'goondaism' is the way forward to forging a robust Maharashtrian identity. By vandalizing a shop or stoning a taxi, what kind of mindless regional chauvinism are we promoting? Taking away the livelihood of a poor taxi driver or beating up some defenceless students from Bihar reflects a fake machismo that is no answer to what ails Maharashtrian society today. The Maharashtra I once knew was inspired by the progressive ideals of the bhakti movement, by a Shahu-Phule-Ambedkar legacy of social reform. Are we going to dismantle that legacy under the weight of hate politics?

When you started your party a few years ago, it had been pitched as a party committed to a "modern" Maharashtra. If that vision still stands, why don't you take it forward in real terms? Why don't you, for example, set up vocational courses and technical institutes for young Maharashtrians to make them competitive in the job market? Why not, for that matter, start English-speaking classes for Maharashtrian students to equip them for the demands of the new economy? If cultural identity is such a concern, why not launch a statewide campaign to promote Marathi art, theatre and cinema by financially supporting such ventures? If Mumbai's collapsing infrastructure worries you, then target the politician-builder nexus first. And isn't it also time we realized that Mumbai is not Maharashtra, that the long suffering Vidarbha and Marathwada farmer needs urgent attention? Why not use your political and financial muscle to start projects in rural Maharashtra instead of focusing your energies on Mumbai's bright lights alone? An employment generation scheme in a Jalna or a Gadchiroli may not make the front pages, but it will have far greater value for securing Maharashtra's future.

Jai Hind, Jai Maharashtra!

Total Comments: 307

CollapsePosted 2008-12-13 16:27:31 : By ankitkhokhani

Rajdeep,
That was really a matured reply and the fact that you are a maharashtrian puts more weight on it. According to me there is one very simple soultion to the ' Raj Thackerey Problem '. THE ENTIRE ELECTRONIC & PRINT MEDIA COME TOGATHER AND PUT A MEDIA BAN ON THE MAN ( irrespective of what the government does to him ) .. just think if raj has to buy newspaper or New channel airtime / space for everything that he does.. dont give him any coverage whatsoever and see the result, he will be like a fish outside water...
this was just a suggestion and I am sure all you intelligent people know better how to tackle this menace. It is also good to watch your debates on T.V.
Keep it up
thanks ...

Reply

CollapsePosted 2008-12-08 11:57:36 : By neillzade

Rajdeep, As a journalist didnt you ever feel like taking up the issue of Railways Recruitment Board and the transparency in the recruitment process in question. Just like any other media/journalist I am seeing you distancing yourself from the actual more serious issues of questioning how the Railways occupies 90% hindi speaking people. Why the jobs are not published in the local newspapers? Bashing Raj thakre seems to be the most favorite past time of all the journalists these days. Blaming him for dividing India seems to be very fashionable now a days. How can you fail to see a divided India in the Indian Railways, UP/Bihar on one side and the rest of the India on the other side. The hindi/English media always look biased towards the north. This was quite evident when Rahul Raj was made a hero despite his terrorist like tactics. No media ever interviewed the conductor who Rahul Raj tried to strangulate and later thrown out of the moving bus. Neither was the man interviewed who was shot by Rahul Raj. Mumbai police were made villians in no time. Is this journalism. We expect some neutrality which seems to be lacking in todays journalism. ...

Reply

CollapsePosted 2008-12-04 14:27:53 : By calvin_

What ever you said is correct(may be), but can you please write blogs on
1) Why ruling party is so dumb, y don't they have an Indian as leader?? Why do they need a foreigner(Italian) to lead them, as well country?
2) why did they took so long to kick-out an useless minister from central?
3) why most of the home ministers in congress ruling states are so weak, dumb, don't even know how to speak, how to manage the situation??

Even though iam not from Maharastra, I like RajThackeray. Reason is so simple, he has guts to do some good(some bad also) for his people. Which we cant see in any politician. Thats y ppl outside maharastra know CM as father to some hero in bolywood, no one know who is home minister. ...

Reply

CollapsePosted 2008-12-04 13:00:16 : By Pravin Nair

Very maturly said by sir Rajdeep to Mr Raj. I guess this is something we all need to read and know about mumbai and politics,I erally liked the sugestions given to Mr Raj by Mr Rajdeep. ...

Reply

CollapsePosted 2008-12-02 21:40:33 : By anand2676

RIGHTLY SAID... AFTER THE MAHARASTRA MARATI INCIDENT....

MY BRAVE UP / BIHARI (ESPECIALLY) ....PLEDGE NOW .....

WE WONT TURN UP TO MUMBAI OR ANY OTHER STATE. WE WILL MAKE OUR STATE A BRIGHT AND UPCOMING STATE LIKE MAHARASTRA,KARNATAKA,DELHI.
WE WONT TURN UP TO ANOTHER STATES FOR OUR EMPLOYMENT.

IF EVERY ONE THOUGHT SO... INDIA WILL NOT BE CALLED "DEVELOPING". WE ARE A DEVELOPED DEMOCRACY.

NEXT THE POEPLE GOING TO AMERICA.... BETTTER WAKE UP AND OPEN YOUR EYES.

IBM,MICROSOFT,ETC ETC....IF YOU ARE IN INDIA CAN COME HERE AND OPEN UP THEIR CENTRES.

TURN UP TO IITs FOR TEACHING. WE ARE FEELING SHORTAGE OF TEACHERS THERE. ...

Reply

All the content posted in the 'IBN Blogs' section, unless specified otherwise, are made by CNN-IBN employees. The content posted in 'IBN Blogs' does not follow routine internal CNN-IBN reviews and editorial processes and should be considered only as the views and opinions of the employees and not of CNN-IBN.

About Us | Disclaimer | Careers @ IBN | RSS | Podcast | Contact Us | Feedback | Advertise With Us

© 2008 IBNLive.com India. All Rights Reserved. A Web18 Venture