Sydney Morning Herald - Business News, World News & Breaking News in Australia

Digital Life - High tech gadgets, technology news & tech reviews

Blog

Digital Radio finally arrives

aturner | May 31, 2009

Digital radio is on the air, but was it worth the wait?

In Australia, digital radio was meant to kick off at the same time as digital television, but it has remained "just around the corner" for a decade. Official digital radio broadcasts finally kicked off around Australia's major cities in May, and you can now listen in Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide and Perth. Many of the major AM and FM stations are now also broadcasting in digital - you'll find a full list at www.digitalradioplus.com.au. ABC and SBS are expected to commence digital services in June. Or July. Or August. It depends on who you ask.

Of course, just like digital television, you'll need to buy new equipment if you want to enjoy digital radio. At this stage, expect to pay hundreds of dollars for even a basic digital radio - which is a lot to ask to replace a radio that probably cost you less than $100.

So why would you consider going digital? The list of reasons cited by the broadcasting industry (taken from the aforementioned website) is almost identical to the list put forward by digital television's advocates;

* Clearer sound and improved reception

* Extra channels

* A wider choice of shows and program highlights, better meeting the needs of niche audiences

* Extra features such as pause and rewind radio, downloadable music, more details about the advertised product, slideshows, scrolling text, Electronic Program Guides, updated news, sports and racing information

* Tuning by station name, not frequency, making it easy to find favourite stations

Those reasons might tempt me to embrace digital television, but not digital radio. In my mind, the radio is something you listen to while you're doing something else. You switch it on and then walk away, which renders most of the new features useless. As for extra channels, internet radio already offers far more diversity than terrestrial broadcasting ever will. As for clearer sound, I'm not yet convinced the improvement justifies the extra expense.

I was at Pioneer and PURE's digital radio launch in Sydney last week and I did hear a few things that caught my attention. Of particular interest was Jamie Chaux, Austereo's Digital Radio content director for new digital-only stations such as Radar Radio. Radar Radio only plays unsigned artists, which is nothing revolutionary, but Chaux also spoke about Pink Radio, a temporary digital radio station created to coincide with Pink's Australian tour. After three months they'll take down the station and use the bandwidth for something else.

I can't say I'm a big fan of Pink, although I'm told she's sold half a million tickets for 50 Australian shows so obviously someone is. What I'm really excited about is the idea of temporary radio stations created just for major events. It opens up all kinds of possibilities.

I still think digital radio has an uphill battle to prove its relevance in the online age, but the concept of event-driven disposable radio stations is the best reason I've heard so far to consider the leap to digital.

LATEST COMMENTS

100$ for a radio? Is this true? we have pocket fm radio for $1 to $2 in India. a bigger one with am fm would cost $8-10.

"* A wider choice of shows and program highlights, better meeting the needs of niche audiences"

cant this be done now? with existing radio infrastructure?

  • Posted by: Brahmin (not verified) on June 2, 2009 6:09 PM.

I have listened to Dab+ broadcasts since they became available on the 11th May. Quality is not as good as FM. The same broadcast such as Gold 104 can be switched on my receivers from Dab+ to FM and FM is far more dynamic and does not sound compressed, no highs or lows on Dab+. Receivers are incredibly limited, no pocket size or portable units are available and car units don't exist either. My table top but battery and ac unit requires the aerial to be fully extended, even in Box Hill where I can see the transmitters, so difficult to use that while out and about! Reception is very dependent on aerial position much like rabbit ears for TV - I'm always tweaking them for better reception.
When the reception drops out you get annoying echo and tunnel sound effects and miss quite a bit of the reception. So far it's no where near as good as very old fashion AM, and without the ABC the content is woeful.

  • Posted by: Chris Davis (not verified) on June 2, 2009 5:47 PM.

Reading some of the comments reminds me of the urchin looking through the steamy restaurant window at the wealthy diners. Oh, the urchin? That's me, by the way. You see, I happen to live in a "Regional area" and you can forget digital radio or Radio National, ABC-FM, etc., unless you are located in politically correct Aurukun, or some such.

Truly wonderful things are happening in Dig TV and Radio, so they tell me, but I shan't be holding my breath waiting for this whiz bang technology to reach the bush.
Yours wistfully,
Arthur

  • Posted by: Arthur Gilbert Major (not verified) on June 2, 2009 5:39 PM.

One of the things that confuses me is why the radios are so much more expensive. I was in the UK about three years ago. They have had digital radio for some time ( I am not sure how long). My point is that a radio could be had for 40 pounds or less. ie $100 at the then exchange rate. This is an old technology that is in mass circulation. There is no reason for a price premium, its not blu-ray or some other new fangled small market system.
Is this something other than an early uptake scam? If so I'd love to hear the argument.

  • Posted by: steve (not verified) on June 2, 2009 1:52 PM.

ABC Radio's services will be available from 1 July. ABC will also be offering 3 music stations - ABC Dig Music, ABC Country and ABC Jazz. You can listen to them online or on digital radio.

  • Posted by: Karla (not verified) on June 2, 2009 11:26 AM.

To answer Paul's question:

I, too, have been listening to ABC digjazz through a digital TV set top box, but that won't last - it was always meant to be a digital test transmission and it will be ultimately switched off. The main reason though, is that it is in DAB format (which Britain uses) and Australia has decided to adopt the DAB+ format, which is of superior quality and is also used throughout Europe.

It has been mentioned in some publications that some digital set top boxes can be adapted/upgraded with a DAB+ chipset. If yours can be upgraded (whenever the chips become available) you'll be in luck. Otherwise, you'll need a new digital radio appliance.

  • Posted by: John (not verified) on June 2, 2009 1:32 AM.

I have a set-top box for my digital TV, and I have been able to get some digital radio on it for a while - such as the ABC digital jazz mentioned in another comment.

Does anyone know if the new digital radio stations are also available on my set-top box?

AM stations are hopeless quality in Sydney so it would be nice to get them clearly in digital. But I'm not keen on buying a $100 radio just to listen to ABC News Radio.

  • Posted by: Paul (not verified) on June 1, 2009 5:57 PM.

Internet radio is OK if you can afford the bandwidth or download limits, and if you don't mind compression.

But I like classical music as well as jazz, and digital is the best way to deliver it on radio. FM has been good, but I find that I need to reposition my antenna with the change of seasons and weather patterns, and some of the listener supported fine music stations here in Adelaide have stereo FM signals that are weaker and constantly noisy, hissy and static ridden. That even happens on ABC Classic FM at times.

No one will ever have enough bandwidth to hear internet radio for long periods: I have the radio on in the office and at home, for a total of about 18 hours a day. There are, in fact, many people who do that, and for long-term radio listening - especially serious listening, not just background "white noise" - digital is the way. Looked at another way, digital radio is free-to-air, internet radio is not. And that's not even taking into account the equipment one might use to listen to internet radio; computer speakers are never going to cut it, and if you plug the computer into a half decent stereo, you are still making a compromise towards lower sound quality because the signal (or digital stream) is being processed by componenets that cannot match the quality of a good stereo system even before they get to the amplifier stage.

I am waiting for the second wave of digital DAB+ radio sets to land in Australia in the hope that they will be cheaper, although I have already auditioned some, ranging from $299 to $999 that are very, very good, especially when plugged in to my Luxman amplifier and Wharfedale speakers.

In any case, analog radio will be switched off.

  • Posted by: John (not verified) on June 1, 2009 4:34 PM.

What's all the fuss about. I've had a digital clock-radio for years!

  • Posted by: Danny (not verified) on June 1, 2009 3:02 PM.

It's too late for digital radio. I get dozens of stations for free from my ISP, and thousands more on the web if I don't mind the (small) amounts of my monthly data quota they take up.

The main thing I want radio to solve is the need to constantly re-tune while driving across the country (I'm a rep, often on the road). Digital radio isn't going to help me with that, although satellite would.

Where is the advantage for digital?

  • Posted by: Stuart Midgley (not verified) on June 1, 2009 2:13 PM.

Post a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

Thumbs up or thumbs down?

Are you downloading more illegal content because of the global financial crisis?

Latest forum comments

Tue 2 Jun: WIN a Core i7 Upgrade Kit valued at $2,200
ASUS and Intel are giving you the chance to WIN a Core i7 Upgrade Kit valued at $2,200. Prizes include Intel® Core™ i7 CPU, ASUS ROG Rampage II Extreme Motherboard and TWO ASUS ENGTX 260 Matrix Graphic Card. ...

Tue 2 Jun: External Hard Drives - How to choose a good one?
Many say Maxtor is good. Many say Western Digital is good. SO how do I choose which brand?...

Tue 2 Jun: How about touch screen and super thin EeePC??
Can't wait to see something like that... i will buy it for sure!...

Register now | Your profile