The Future of Science Videos

We reveal the winners of our first The Scientist Video Awards, picked by professional judges and our readers. You can watch the winning videos and runners-up below, and read comments from our professional judges about what makes each video great. Also, click the link above for an analysis by JEF AKST of the history and future of videos in science.


INDIVIDUAL CATEGORY WINNERS

"Synaptic Cleft" is a parody of rap group Wu-Tang Clan's "Gravel Pit" about neurotransmission, submitted by Tom McFadden of Stanford University. "I [had] been making similar hip-hop parodies throughout the year," McFadden says. This time inspiration struck during the unit on neuroscience for a Human Biology class for which he was a teacher's assistant. With the help of a few friends, McFadden filmed and edited the music video that educates while it entertains.

Friedmann: Very creative presentation of an academic subject.

Sanford: Had me laughing, dancing, and singing along. Kept my interest until the end.

"Fencing Flamingos" follows the work of Marita Davison, a PhD student in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at Cornell University, and her collaborator Jennifer Moslemi as they study flamingos in the rugged High-Andes of Bolivia. The harsh conditions made it challenging to make the video, Davison says, but it's been worth it. "We've had more people see the video than I'll ever have reading a journal article that I write." The video was filmed with a handheld Sony camera by Jamie Herring, another PhD student at Cornell.

Segall: A nice personal view of a scientist.

Kirby: The video provided some spectacular shots of the flamingos' habitat, and it gave a sense of the difficulty in doing this type of ecological research.


JUDGE'S CHOICE

Synaptic Cleft

SUBMITTED BY: Tom McFadden, Stanford

CONTENT: Parody of Wu-Tang Clan's "Gravel Pit" about neurotransmission

AUDIENCES'S CHOICE

Fencing Flamingos

SUBMITTED BY: Marita Davison, Jamie Herring, and Jennifer Moslemi, Cornell University

CONTENT: The logistics of studying flamingos in the rugged High-Andes of Bolivia


RUNNERS UP

TIME LAPSE VIDEOMICROGRAPHY OF THE LIFE CYCLE OF DICTOSTELIUM

SUBMITTED BY: Arjumond Khan and Benjamin Woodhouse, Western Connecticut State University

CONTENT: Time-lapse photography of the a soil-living amoeba's life cycle

Friedmann: A great scientific video short; could have used an audio track.

Sanford: Time-lapse was a neat effect, and allowed dramatic change to be more apparant, but video relied on text description.


THE NATURE OF CELL SCIENCE

SUBMITTED BY: Dirk Pacholsky, the Rudbeck Laboratory in Sweden

CONTENT: Microscopic imagery set to electronic music

Friedmann: Amazing combination of microscopy and music.

Segall: Dynamic, with interesting music.


PRESSURE BOMB

SUBMITTED BY: Burkhard Schulz, Purdue University

CONTENT: How to measure water pressure in the xylem of transpiring leaves.

Kirby: Very useful instructional video, but it was difficult to be excited by the visuals.

Sanford: Short, sweet, to the point.



INSTITUTIONAL CATEGORY WINNERS

"Tree of Life" is a documentary on the evolutionary links between living things, narrated by David Attenborough and submitted by The Wellcome Trust. We "saw an opportunity for something bigger and more beautiful" during celebrations of Darwin's 200th birthday, says Daniel Glaser, head of special projects at the Wellcome Trust and commissioner and executive producer of Tree of Life. The goal was to "illustrate the whole of evolution in quite stylized terms of 3.5 billion years into 5 or 6 minutes," explains Luke Wilmot, the creative director of the movie from Shadow Industries.

Kirby: By far this was the best video of all the submissions. The visuals were beautiful, the narrator served as a storyteller not as a lecturer, and the music complimented the piece.

Sanford: Beautiful graphics! Well-written script conveyed info in a clear, concise, engaging manner.

"Pioneering New Frontiers in Tumor Angiogenesis" is one of 15 videos and seven interactive panels on Amgen's new educational angiogenesis web site, launched in mid-April this year during the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) annual meeting. The idea for the video "originated from our research and development group," regarding a novel approach to angiogenesis research, says project manager Christine Regan. Amgen then launched a project to create something "that truly looks and feels like something different," she adds. "We're incredibly excited about the end product of this Web site and hope that health care professionals appreciate the cinematic qualities and features that go into these videos."

Segall: Dynamic with clinical relevance.

Sanford: A beautiful tour of the known physiology.


JUDGE'S CHOICE

Tree of Life

SUBMITTED BY: The Wellcome Trust, the UK's largest non-governmental source of funds for biomedical research

CONTENT: David Attenborough narrates an exploration of the evolutionary links between living things

AUDIENCES'S CHOICE

Pioneering New Frontiers in Tumor Angiogenesis

SUBMITTED BY: Amgen

CONTENT: Animation of the molecular details behind angiogenesis, including the angiopoietins, the VEGF family and other regulators


RUNNERS UP

PLANT BIOTECH FOR FOOD AND ENVIRONMENT

SUBMITTED BY: VIB, a non-profit scientific research institute that uses gene technology

CONTENT: Techniques to develop plants that are better suited for food and environment

Sanford: Good opening graphic and lede to get the viewer interested; beautiful graphics overall.

Pritsker: The authors manage to escape the typical dullness of techincal videos and conveyed their ideas appealing to scientists and the general public.


NOVEL SPINAL CORD STIMULATOR SPARKS HOPE FOR PARKINSON'S DISEASE TREATMENT

SUBMITTED BY: Duke Medicine, a research, clinical care, and educational facility associated with Duke University

CONTENT: A future treatment of Parkinson's disease that may target the spinal cord instead of the brain to help alleviate the slow, rigid movements and tremors that are the hallmarks of the disease

Kirby: Videos of the research were useful but the video would have been better served adding some supplementary visuals.

Friedmann: Solid science reporting on a new medical advance.


OBAMA INAUGURATION: A POSITIVE CHANGE IN FEDERAL STEM CELL RESEARCH POLICIES

SUBMITTED BY: California Institute for Regenerative Medicine

CONTENT: How embryonic stem cell research was affected when U.S. President Barack Obama signed an executive order to lift the ban on federal funding

Friedmann: Good as a news clip; not engaging in terms of science.

Kirby: The video was informative but the format was too standard. It would have benefitted from narration and some analysis about the changes in policy.



JUDGE BIOS

JEFFREY SEGALL earned his PhD in biophysics from the California Institute of Technology in 1984 and completed a postdoc at the Max Planck Institute for Biochemistry, West Germany before starting at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY, where he is currently a full professor of Anatomy and Structural Biology. He is a regular filmmaker of his work on chemotaxis in yeast, dictyostelium, and tumor cells, taking advantage of the Einstein Analytical Imaging Facility that provides light and electron microscope imaging technology and support staff.

MARC FRIEDMANN is the CEO of SciVee, the first scientific video-sharing Web site. Prior to working for SciVee, he was a business entrepreneur in such fields as software and telecom, with an MBA from Harvard.

MOSHE PRITSKER is the CEO , editor-in-chief, and co-founder of JoVE. After receiving a PhD in molecular biology from Princeton University and an MSc in chemistry from the Weizmann Institute of Science, Pritsker completed a postdoc at Harvard Medical School/Massachusetts General Hospital, where he studied neural stem cells.

DAVID KIRBY started his career as a bench scientist studying population genetics in Drosophila while earning his PhD from the University of Maryland College Park. But after obtaining a faculty position at American University in Washington, D.C. and organizing a "Film and Biology" night, his interests in the fictional representation of science and attitudes towards science in American culture drove him to transition into humanities and social sciences. He is now a tenured lecturer of science communication at the University of Manchester.

KIRSTEN SANFORD had nearly finished her PhD in neurophysiology from the University of California Davis when she realized she'd rather be sharing science than doing it herself. In 2006, she moved to New York City to work as a producer for medical/ health reporter Dr. Max Gomez at WNBCTV. She is now a science communicator of the Science Channel, while still maintaining her weekly podcast, This Week in Science, and her popular blog, The Bird's Brain.