Opinion



December 8, 2009, 9:30 pm

A Wild Celebration

Olivia JudsonOlivia Judson on the influence of science and biology on modern life.

This year, as you may have noticed, has been one long party in honor of Charles Darwin. That’s now drawing to a close. But don’t put away your glad rags. Next year is also slated to be one long party; this time, in honor of biodiversity. Yes, 2010 is to be an international knees-up for the other species on the planet.

Ping-Pong tree sponge, from the Monterey Bay’s floor.MBARI/From “The Deep,” University Of Chicago Press Ping-Pong tree sponge, from the Monterey Bay’s floor.

It’s not clear to me what, in practice, this celebration is going to mean. But the prospect of it has led me to get out some picture books — books like “The Deep,” which is full of incredible photographs of strange beings. For example: Chondrocladia lampadiglobus, the ping-pong tree sponge, which lives more than a mile and a half below the surface of the sea. This creature looks more like a piece of modern art than an animal: it has an array of spherical, translucent globes on stalks that join together at the center. It looks harmless, decorative even. But it’s a carnivore. Shrimps or other critters that settle on it quickly become stuck; the sponge then consumes them.

Or — this book is one of my favorites — “Identification Guide to the Ant Genera of the World,” which consists of hugely magnified images of the faces of ants, both head-on and in profile. I’ve never identified an ant with it; but I love looking at the astonishing variety that we, in our bigness, don’t usually get to see. Some of the faces are smooth; others have whorls and ridges. Some ants have unobtrusive mouth parts; others have great scythes. With this book in hand, there’s no need to invent monsters: you just need to imagine how terrifying it would be if ants were the size of rhinos.

Looking through these books, it’s hard not to be struck by the immensity of the planet — it’s home to all these life forms! And we haven’t even met them all yet. Just this past August, a paper published in Science announced the discovery of a new group of deep-sea swimming worms that release green fluorescent “bombs” when they are attacked. (The bombs are balls of fluid; they don’t turn green until the animal releases them.)

We’ve been making discoveries on land, too. Indeed, since 1993, more than 400 new species of mammal have been described — and this is a group that’s been studied well. And it’s not because we’ve identified lots of new mice or bats. The discoveries include an antelope, the saola, that weighs more than 100 kilograms (220 pounds); a sloth that lives on an island off Panama; several new species of monkey; and a squirrel-like animal that appears to be a living representative of a group thought to have gone extinct around 11 million years ago.

Mulling all this over, a number of thoughts run through my mind.

The first is that we still don’t know the planet all that well. On the one hand, this is exciting: there’s so much more to learn! Millions of new species may await discovery; and discovery is only the first step. Once an organism has been identified, we can learn about its lifestyle: its mating habits (if any), what it eats, how long it lives, what weird genetic quirks it has and so on.

On the other hand, our lack of knowledge is a bit worrying. Although we often behave as if we’re the only ones who live here, we depend on other organisms in all manner of ways. Some of these are obvious. We hunt fish to eat them; we grow cows for meat, milk and leather. We cultivate silkworms to make clothes. We grow a large number of plants for diverse purposes — to eat, or to use as drugs, timber or paper.

But much of our dependence is less obvious. Worms, fungi, insects and microbes consume dead bodies and fallen branches. Some organisms consume dung; others move seeds. Many organisms make soil richer and more fertile. Plants around streams and rivers filter the water and make it cleaner. Plants also take carbon dioxide from the air, and thus affect the composition of the atmosphere; their roots help prevent soils from washing away. Some bacteria may play a role in making clouds; the list goes on.

By and large, we do not pay for any of this: our economics does not, for the most part, include paying for nature.

But we pay when it is lost. Less fertile soils make it harder to grow crops. Dirtier water is more expensive to make fit for human consumption. The collapse of fisheries leads to unemployment. The loss of mangroves increases the impact of tsunamis. The loss of animal species increases the risk that humans will catch diseases such as Lyme disease. Again, the list goes on.

The other beings that live here with us are, like us, descended from ancient lineages. In and of themselves, they are marvels to be wondered at. But they are also precious: they make our planet what it is today. Still, as the great American environmentalist Aldo Leopold once said, when something vanishes, “We grieve only for what we know. The erasure of Silphium from western Dane County is no cause for grief if one knows it only as a name in a botany book.” Yes: if we don’t know something, we don’t care if it goes.

This, then, is what the International Year of Biodiversity should be about: it should be about conveying the excitement of discovery in biology, coupled with an intimate knowledge of the majesty of nature. For we must start cherishing our fellow life forms, and treating them well: we need them, in more ways than we probably imagine. Their loss makes the planet — and ourselves — poorer.

So please be up-standing, raise your glasses and join me in a toast to: “Other Life Forms!”

And let’s make sure that in the years ahead, we don’t need to change it to “Absent Friends.”


Notes:

For a visual feast and plenty of amazement, see Nouvian, C. 2007. “The Deep: The Extraordinary Creatures of the Abyss.” University of Chicago Press; and Bolton, B. 1994. “Identification Guide to the Ant Genera of the World.” Harvard University Press. For further information on the ping-pong tree sponge, see Vacelet, J. 2006. “New carnivorous sponges (Porifera, Poecilosclerida) collected from manned submersibles in the deep Pacific.” Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 148: 553-584.

For swimming worms and their green fluorescent bombs, see Osborn, K. J. et al. 2009. “Deep-sea, swimming worms with luminescent ‘bombs’.” Science 325: 964. For an overview of new species of mammal, see Ceballos, G. and Ehrlich, P. R. 2009. “Discoveries of new mammal species and their implications for conservation and ecosystem services.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 106: 3841-3846. For more on the mammal that was believed to be extinct for 11 million years, see Dawson, M. R. et al. 2006. “Laonastes and the ‘Lazarus effect’ in Recent mammals.” Science 311: 1456-1458.

The general term for what other organisms do for us is “ecosystem services.” There is a huge literature on this. For a good overview, see Purvis, A. and Hector, A. 2000. “Getting the measure of biodiversity.” Nature 405: 212-219.

A number of authors have attempted to price ecosystem services; this is inherently problematical because, in many respects, natural resources are priceless. But see, for example, Costanza, R. et al. 1997. “The value of the world’s ecosystem services and natural capital.” Nature 387: 253-260; James, A., Gaston, K. J. and Balmford, A. 2001. “Can we afford to conserve biodiversity?” BioScience 51: 43-52; Dasgupta, P. 2007. “Nature and the Economy.” Journal of Applied Ecology 44: 475-487; Pearce, D. 2007. “Do we really care about biodiversity.” Environmental and Resource Economics 37: 313-333; Turner, R. K. and Daily, G. C. 2008. “The ecosystem services framework and natural capital conservation.” Environmental and Resource Economics 39: 25-35. The fact that our economics does not price nature, and the problems that leads to, was spotted long ago by Aldo Leopold — he describes it eloquently in the foreword to his book “A Sand County Almanac and Sketches Here and There,” which he wrote in 1948. The quotation I give is on page 48 of my Oxford University Press paperback edition; it’s in mid-July of the “Sand County Almanac.”

For the the effect of ecosystem degradation on water quality, see Martínez, M. L. et al. 2009. “Effects of land use change on biodiversity and ecosystem services in tropical montane cloud forests of Mexico.” Forest Ecology and Management 258: 1856-1863. Turner and Daily (mentioned above) give a good description of how attention to ecosystem management recently improved water quality in New York City. For mangroves protecting from tsunamis, see Danielsen, F. et al. 2005. “The Asian tsunami: a protective role for coastal vegetation.” Science 310: 643. For Lyme disease going up as rodent diversity goes down, see Schmidt, K. A. and Ostfeld, R. S. 2001. “Biodiversity and the dilution effect in disease ecology.” Ecology 82: 609-619.

Many thanks to Dan Haydon for insights, comments and suggestions.


Editor’s note: In an earlier version of this piece, “saola” was misspelled; it has been corrected.


Olivia Judson, an evolutionary biologist, is the author of “Dr. Tatiana’s Sex Advice to All Creation: The Definitive Guide to the Evolutionary Biology of Sex.” Ms. Judson has been a reporter for The Economist and has written for a number of other publications, including Nature, The Financial Times, The Atlantic and Natural History. She is a research fellow in biology at Imperial College London.

Inside Opinionator

January 14, 2010
Into the Closet

An intrajudicial spat highlights a debate over the right to privacy and the propriety of cameras in the courtroom.

December 31, 2009
A Judge and a Politician

Why it's unfortunate that more politicians don't become judges.

December 17, 2009
Hurry Up and Wait

The Supreme Court has cheated the public of a full airing of complex questions surrounding campaign finance.

More From Linda Greenhouse »

January 13, 2010
Arnold's Last Yodel

Can California be saved, and can a beleaguered governor in his final year in office help?

January 6, 2010
Health Care's Biggest Hypocrite — Or Hero

Mitt Romney should have the courage of his convictions, even if it puts him in Democratic territory on health care.

December 30, 2009

Timothy Egan is away this week.

More From Timothy Egan »

January 13, 2010
America vs. Europe

Which model of capitalism is better?

January 7, 2010
New Year's Resolutions

Why Gail Collins is willing to back nuclear power and David Brooks will support a cap on carbon emissions.

December 16, 2009
Deck the Halls With Joseph Lieberman

Is the senator from Connecticut responsible for everything terrible that's happened to the world since 1999 or is he performing a valuable national service?

More From The Conversation »

January 13, 2010

Olivia Judson is away this week.

January 5, 2010
A Tale of Two Flagella

Dinoflagellates are eccentric and weird organisms, creating both coral reefs and nerve poison.

December 29, 2009
Memories in Nature

A year-end reflection on the memory found in nature, from the immune system to animals to plants.

More From Olivia Judson »

January 11, 2010
The True Answer and the Right Answer

In matters both trivial and grave, "true" and "right" aren't necessarily the same thing.

January 4, 2010

Stanley Fish is away this week.

December 28, 2009
Vengeance Is Mine

"Revenge and avenge" films continue to raise the question of violence's relationship to morality.

More From Stanley Fish »

January 8, 2010
Why, I Oughta . . . and I Did

It took a local television host to bring a (professionally) even-tempered first-time author to the boiling point.

December 18, 2009
Almost Nothing About Tiger Woods

Fame can sometimes be a burden (ask Tiger Woods), and even as patient a soul as Jack Benny had his limits.

December 4, 2009
The Ghost Ship 'W.W.'

The far side of fame, as witnessed in a late-in-life Walter Winchell anecdote.

More From Dick Cavett »

January 7, 2010
The Three Magi of the Meltdown

How the Bear Stearns debacle caused the Great Recession.

More From William D. Cohan »

The Thread
From Bay State to Red State?
January 15, 2010
The Score
On Future Performance
January 13, 2010
The Thread
Haiti and the Politics of Disaster
January 13, 2010
Errol Morris
Thought Experiment #2
January 12, 2010
Home Fires
Home Fires: Bidding Farewell to Arms
January 9, 2010

All Contributors »

Opinionator Highlights

On Future Performance

Technology can take music to new levels of human expression. But can it top Yo-Yo Ma unplugged?

Thought Experiment #2

A short quiz to follow a recent pair of essays on war photography.

Home Fires: Bidding Farewell to Arms

A soldier's decision on his re-enlistment hangs in the balance — but not for long.

Home Fires: I Wanted to Be a Hero

When one soldier's discharge arrived in the mail, her super-soldier fantasies came to an end.

Home Fires: Getting the Word Out

After an unexpected tour in Iraq, a former Marine's job with Disabled American Veterans takes on new meaning.

Subscribe