It's the day before Christmas and all through my house not a model was budging, not even an ounce. UGH! I will get to the late weekend storm in a bit. First, I want to tackle a topic that has come up lately.
Ok, folks, I am trying to stay in a good Christmas mood but am increasingly frustrated with the lack help I am getting from our trusty models in the last few weeks. I am also a little puzzled by some of the comments I am getting and am going to try to see if I correct some of your misconceptions.
Here is a quote from one of the reader comments I received yesterday;
I understand that we make our predictions based on computer models... etc., but once we start reporting information solely based on the 'models', where does the expertise come into play. I mean anybody can read data from a model and report that. The reason why I come to the AccuWeather is because I want to hear what the experts have to say. What is wrong with going out on a limb and making a scientific forecast based on your experience rather than waiting for a consistent model prediction to setup ? (From Paul)
And here was my response;
I have 35+ years of experience and you are right, there are times to make a forecast based on one's experience. However, there are also times, especially more than 3-4 days out, where it makes NO sense going out on a limb with what amounts to a guess. I could do that but what does that get you? Wouldn't you rather KNOW that it is a tricky situation and that by waiting a little longer you would actually get a more accurate forecast?
It is a fine line I and others walk when trying to make forecasts and in dealing with the computer models. Computer models are a guidance to the possible coming weather. It takes professional interpretation of those models and experience with their biases and errors that go into making a forecast. It also takes experience with local variations in a given area to make a complete and accurate forecast. Yes, we do rely on models to help us but that is in the end what it is, one of the tools to help us forecast the weather.
The problem we have had in recent weeks goes to my response to Paul. If I see 5 different models showing no consistency in their solutions even between the same model from run to run, how can I choose the right solution? I am not talking about small differences here. I am talking about the difference between a storm and no storm, not between a storm arriving at 4 p.m. or 7 p.m. Or it's a difference between a storm coming next Monday or waiting until Wednesday or Thursday. No small difference and no small difference that makes in your life. In this case, if I choose one model it amounts to nothing more than a guess. Now that guess may end up being right, but it would not have been based on any scientific process. What does involve a scientific process is to see which model becomes more consistent between runs and see if other models fall in line with it over time. You take this, along with your experience in pattern development, and THEN pick your model of choice.
This is a very small part of what goes on in making up a forecast. It is much more complicated, but I wanted to give a little on the models.
Next Storm:
The ridge protecting the entire West Coast from any storm through Christmas will break down over the weekend. One storm assaults that ridge on Saturday, but most of its energy is wasted on breaking down the ridge and moistening the air mass some. A shower chance does exist north-central and northern California coastal areas late Saturday or Saturday nights. It�s the second storm that has all along caused the problems. Still today we have a big difference in the models with one bringing that storm in on Sunday to central and northern California. The other extreme is that storm going so far west and then south of California it never rains from it. Then there are solutions somewhere in the middle. Right now, I am favoring a possible rain event aimed more at the southern third of California in the time period late Sunday or Sunday night into part of Monday. The most consistent models have had this solution and timing therefore the odds are greater than some semblance of this solution is the best bet.
Now to end things on a good note. I hope all that celebrate Christmas have a wonderful and great holiday tomorrow. Enjoy the people you are with and be thankful for what you have not yearning for what you don't have. I am thankful that my son Brian is here from his job on Mount Washington along with his girlfriend Laura and we can celebrate together. Then our extended family will be getting together on Saturday for a party. Next week we march toward 2010. Will El Nino weather pattern finally get established or will the El Nino pattern we are in continue not to deliver the amount of precipitation it is suppose to? We will walk that walk together for the rest of 2009 and in 2010. Have a great Christmas one and all.
Categories:
Educational
|
Forecast Models
|
Long-Range
|
Rain
|
Winter Weather