Opinion



March 3, 2010, 9:30 pm

L.A. Consequential

Timothy EganTimothy Egan on American politics and life, as seen from the West.

LOS ANGELES — Not since the Beach Boys were in peach fuzz and crew cuts has it been so safe to live and play in the City of Angels. Believe it: you are more likely to be murdered in Columbus, Ohio, or Tulsa, Okla., than in the nation’s second most populous city.

“You have to go back to 1957 — when I was four years old! — to find a similar period,” Charlie Beck, the Los Angeles police chief, was telling me. “How crazy is that?”

It’s “Dragnet”-level crazy, yes. But more than that: it’s one of the great urban surprises in a place that continues to defy its dystopian destiny.

By now, in the midst of a ragged recession, with another half-million people added to its burdened turf over the last 15 years, Los Angeles was supposed to be “Blade Runner” in 3-D.

“The Book of the Apocalypse Theme Park” was how the writer Mike Davis described it in his classic 1999 book, the nonfiction horror story “Ecology of Fear.”

I count myself among the visitors here who felt a palpable sense of relief flying out of L.A. in 1992, when riots over a racially charged police brutality verdict left 53 people dead and National Guard troops in the streets. The sense of menace, of collapse, of utter unsustainability was strong. What a pit, I thought, and a pity.

The image stuck in my mind was that brutal scene at the intersection of Florence and Normandie, where truck driver Reginald Denny was randomly pulled from his rig and beaten to a pulp by thugs. All captured live on television.

Since then, homicide is down nearly 80 percent through this year, and overall violent crime has taken a similar plunge. In 2008, the last year for full F.B.I. statistics, even Omaha, Neb., had a slightly higher murder rate than L.A.

And the trend continues: murder in L.A. is now down 50 percent from the relatively placid levels of two years ago. At this rate, blood-chasing local television news stations will have to import footage from other cities to uphold their reputation for practicing the nation’s worst and silliest local reporting.

I returned to that morbidly iconic intersection this week and it felt like, well, Omaha on a good day. Businesses, both chains and family-run storefronts, perked along. The nearby neighborhoods were mostly graffiti-free, with well-kept yards, churches and schools, and the rarest of real estate tags this year: a “sold” sign.

Of course, some dangerous ambient conditions remain. Chief Beck says there are still 40,000 gang members here — enough to fill a stadium— but that number is down by half from its peak. And, on the public relations front, the L.A.P.D. itself stumbled this week when it had to apologize for an insensitive display of evidence at a Las Vegas homicide exhibit, a show that included bloody clothing — since removed — worn by Sen. Robert F. Kennedy on the night he was assassinated.

Nationwide, the story of crime falling to half-century lows is an ongoing miracle. How New York went from the crack-addled days to tourist theme park is well known. But it’s a pattern that’s been repeated all over the United States, with the exception of a few hard patches — cities like New Orleans, Detroit and Baltimore.

The causes are many, and mostly speculative:

A high-tech mapping strategy, where police move on crime hot spots in something close to real time, was pioneered in New York and mastered here (give praise to William Bratton, who oversaw the departments in both cities, for that effort); the stuffing of prisons with career criminals also gets much of the credit; the role played by legalized abortion, according to the authors Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner in their book “Freakonomics,” in preventing a generation of unwanted children from being born; and the settling down of the drug trade, the source of so much violence during the formative years of narcotic fiefdoms, to such a degree that in many parts of the city there are now more medical marijuana dispensers in Los Angeles than Starbucks outlets (regulated retailers creating an ecosystem of nonviolence).

The experts foresaw a generation of “superpredators” prowling the streets. Moralizers with microphones predicted imminent social collapse. And with the Great Recession of 2009, and particularly 2010, the positive news would surely end, in the view of James Alan Fox, the oft-cited criminologist.

Didn’t happen. Hasn’t happened. Probably won’t happen. Everything they knew — all the scary talk, with L.A. as the centerpiece — was wrong.

You saw a glimmer of hope on the day Denny was dragged from his truck. A resident of that tough neighborhood who had watched the beating live on television risked his own life to get the trucker to the hospital.

The most crime-ridden communities were never as nihilistic as portrayed in 1992. But the bad guys did have the upper hand, in part because of the police. The L.A.P.D. had a notorious reputation — corrupt, racist, incompetent — that made a mockery of its motto to “protect and serve.”

Places like South Central Los Angeles were “a hated landscape,” says Chief Beck, a 32-year veteran of the force. Helicopters constantly buzzed overhead in the harsh sunlight, a soundtrack of dread. “It was just pure hatred, on both sides.”

Chief Beck has seen crime-fighting in Los Angeles — often, an oxymoron at that — through the eyes of three generations: his dad was a cop, and his children are cops as well.

He says these are among the best years ever. Los Angeles is on a pace for about 230 murders this year, in a city of nearly 4 million people. And the department clears — solves and prosecutes — more than 80 percent of the homicides, well above the national average for big cities.

Using civil injunctions to cripple many gang activities, and former gang members to bring peace through community outreach, the city has been able to shrink the geography of hatred.

At times, Los Angeles still feels fragile, a sprawl of hubristic nature-defiance, unable to shake its noir sketchiness. If a half-inch of rain calls for breathless TV updates and canceled social events, what would a serious earthquake do to the hard-won stability of the new civic order?

Chief Beck has his fingers crossed. “Absent some huge social disorder, this will be a golden age of policing,” he predicted. “I have been to every neighborhood of this city and the most popular piece of government now, by far, is the police officer.”


Timothy Egan worked for The Times for 18 years – as Pacific Northwest correspondent and a national enterprise reporter. His column on American politics and life as seen from the West Coast appears here on Thursdays. In 2001, he was part of the Pulitzer Prize-winning team that wrote the series “How Race Is Lived in America.” He is the author of several books, including “The Worst Hard Time,” a history of the Dust Bowl, for which he won the National Book Award, and most recently, “The Big Burn: Teddy Roosevelt and the Fire That Saved America.”

Inside Opinionator

March 5, 2010
In What Can We Trust?

Searching for reasons to be pessimistic these days is pretty easy.

February 26, 2010
What’s Happened to Cultural Discourse?

The discrepancies between what the public wants and what it gets.

February 17, 2010
Why Househusbands Are the Future

With women getting laid off at a much lower rate than men, is it time to encourage dads to stay home with the kids?

More From The Conversation »

March 4, 2010
A Wall Street Witch Hunt

In 1987, Goldman Sachs made headlines for an insider trading arrest case marked by prosecutorial excess.

February 18, 2010
The Great Goldman Sachs Fire Sale of 2008

If everything was really under control after Lehman collapsed, why were Goldman executives dumping their stock by the bushelfull?

February 4, 2010
Mystery Men of the Financial Crisis

Who the heck is Dan Jester? And why isn’t he explaining what he did in the A.I.G. bailout?

More From William D. Cohan »

March 3, 2010
L.A. Consequential

Los Angeles is safer than it’s been in decades, having so far avoided the dire future many had predicted in the ’90s.

February 24, 2010
The Missionary Impulse

Zealous amateurs have damaged the efforts of more legitimate adoption services and relief agencies in Haiti.

February 17, 2010
Allez Canada!

With so much going for it, and now the Winter Olympics too, the Canadian nation nevertheless conducts itself with unbecoming modesty.

More From Timothy Egan »

March 2, 2010
Evolution by the Grassroots

March’s Life-form of the Month is wildly successful, hugely influential and pretty much everywhere: grass.

February 23, 2010
Stand Up While You Read This!

Too much sitting still, recent studies in rats and humans suggest, can offset the benefits of even regular exercise.

February 9, 2010
Unorthodox

Ciliates — single-celled organisms and February’s Life-form of The Month — engage in all kinds of peculiar sexual activity.

More From Olivia Judson »

March 1, 2010
Little Big Men

Many larger-than-life tough guys of the screen, it seems, just don’t measure up.

February 22, 2010
Are There Secular Reasons?

The role of secular reasoning and, yes, religion in public decision-making.

February 8, 2010
How the First Amendment Works

A followup column on the First Amendment and the recent Supreme Court decision, with a discussion of readers’ comments.

More From Stanley Fish »

February 25, 2010
Missing the Tea Party

The Supreme Court’s campaign finance ruling has both angered conservatives and given the Obama administration an opportunity.

February 11, 2010
Saved by the Swiss

With some last-minute maneuvering, the Obama administration looks as if it will avoid a test of the limits of executive power at the Supreme Court.

January 28, 2010
The Next Time

What will the Chief Justice Roberts majority’s next target be next, now that it has experienced the joy of overturning?

More From Linda Greenhouse »

February 23, 2010
The First Tea-Party Terrorist?

The man who crashed a small plane into an Austin I.R.S. office hoped to inspire an overreaction.

February 16, 2010
Zuckerman Unbound

When a wealthy columnist runs for national office, his past writings should help voters evaluate him.

February 9, 2010
Listen to the Iranian People

Why the West should let Iran enrich its own uranium.

More From Robert Wright »

February 5, 2010
Oh, What a Lovely Mess!

NBC’s recent adventures in talk-show-host management remind one former talk-show host of his own adventures in prime time with another network.

January 22, 2010
Awesome, and Then Some

An on-set encounter with John Wayne revealed an unexpected side of the actor.

January 8, 2010
Why, I Oughta . . . and I Did

It took a local television host to bring a (professionally) even-tempered first-time author to the boiling point.

More From Dick Cavett »

Home Fires
Home Fires: Cut the War Film Some Slack
March 5, 2010
The Thread
Liz Cheney’s ‘Al Qaeda Seven’
March 5, 2010
Home Fires
Home Fires: On ‘Seeing’
March 4, 2010
Home Fires
Home Fires: The Bomb Within Us
March 4, 2010
All-Nighters
All-Nighters: Failing to Fall
March 3, 2010

All Contributors »

Opinionator Highlights

Home Fires: Cut the War Film Some Slack

War movies have their faults, but their power to raise public awareness is invaluable.

Home Fires: The Bomb Within Us

After a screening of “The Hurt Locker” in Hanoi, thoughts on a nation at war with itself.

Thumbnail
All-Nighters: Failing to Fall

Exploring the elusive borderland between waking and sleep.

Thumbnail
Home Fires: The War Movie You Don’t Want to See

In the gap between war films and reality is a world of loss.

Home Fires: Writing and Rewriting Iraq

After a childhood steeped in tales of battle, a former Marine confronts his shame about his “easy war” in Iraq.