Hockey



March 24, 2010, 2:29 pm

The Morning Skate: N.H.L.’s Fast-Tracked Rule Change Skips a Stop

Nothing comes easy in the National Hockey League and the proposed rule on blindside hits to the head is the latest example.

Coming out of the general managers meeting in early March, their proposal to ban them was to be adopted next season. But they realized that players would remain vulnerable for the remainder of this season, so they moved to fast-track adoption of the rule. They proposed making players subject to suspensions and fines in lieu of in-game penalties because the league said proper training of the referees on the new rules takes time.

The fast-tracking meant the N.H.L. competition committee, composed of five team executives and five players, would have to approve the proposal and then the N.H.L. Board of Governors would have to approve it, which is how rules are adopted according to the N.H.L.-N.H.L.P.A. collective bargaining agreement.

But the players refused to be rushed and one of them, Ottawa’s Jason Spezza, said on Monday that while this was a good quick fix for the rest of 2009-10, they wanted assurances they’d have a more thorough discussion and perhaps something stronger before 2010-11.

Instead, the Board of Governors Tuesday went ahead and unanimously approved the rule anyway which prohibits “a lateral, back-pressure or blind-side hit to an opponent where the head is targeted and/or the principal point of contact.”

The owners added, “The timing and details of implementation are being worked on by the N.H.L.’s Hockey Operations Department in conjunction with representatives of the National Hockey League Players’ Association.”

So now the fun begins.

The union was not pleased with this unilateral action. “Under the C.B.A., the league’s proposal cannot take effect until it first receives the support of the joint N.H.L.P.A./N.H.L. competition committee, and then is endorsed by the N.H.L. board of governors,” players association spokesman Jonathan Weatherdon told TSN.ca. “To date, the competition committee has neither agreed on a proposal, nor forwarded a proposal to the board of governors for its vote.”

And in a statement published in a Globe and Mail story by David Shoalts, the union added, “As we have previously stated, the N.H.L.P.A.’s competition committee members are finalizing their response to the N.H.L.’s proposal regarding blindside hits to the head and will be responding to the league this week.”

N.H.L. deputy commissioner Bill Daly had a different view. “As we have stated repeatedly in the past, the creation of the competition committee has not eliminated the role of the board of governors in passing and implementing rules that it deems to be in the best interests of the game,” Daly said, according to Shoalts. “While we are intent on continuing to work with the [NHLPA] and the competition committee as we have been doing for the better part of two weeks now, to the extent we do not receive a timely answer, we will have to make our own decisions in the best interests of the game and the players.”

Daly’s claim that the players association had “the better part of two weeks” to fully examine and discuss the proposal — something that the general managers and hockey operations department had developed and discussed over a four-month span — will certainly not sit well with the players. It’s a bit more difficult to canvass 750 players than 30 teams.

Sabres goalie Ryan Miller, one of the five players on the committee, told Pierre LeBrun of ESPN.com that the five were in the process of “making sure all of our members are aware of what the league is recommending. After everyone knows the options we will proceed. Even though it is the right direction we can’t ’surprise’ players with a rule while in season.”

Miller, like Spezza, also pointed out that the players had proposed stronger measures against head checks, including blindside hits, last year and the general managers dismissed them, saying new rules weren’t needed. Shoats wrote in The Globe and Mail earlier this week that he believed the players didn’t rush to embrace the fast-track as retribution for that shabby treatment, although he admitted that might be a cynical assessment. Not that anyone observing hockey’s class struggle in the last 53 years has any reason for cynicism.

But the process may be less of an issue to the players than what they perceive as the abrogation of process by the league. And that was on the mind of Shoalts in today’s Globe and Mail when he wrote that thanks to what became very fast tracking, “The prospect of a war between the N.H.L. and the players union increased last night.”

TSN’s Bob McKenzie on Montreal’s Team 990 Morning Show said earlier today that he also thought this was not a good development, reminding listeners that union has the option to opt out of the C.B.A. at the end of next season and this action would only inflame the membership. That membership, while currently lacking an executive director, could be (as reported by TSN’s Darren Dreger and The Post’s Larry Brooks) on the verge of hiring a strong advocate of player’s rights in former baseball union head Donald Fehr. That prospect is troubling for those who would blame Fehr for the significant labor strife in baseball because that is the last thing hockey needs just five years after the lockout

Fehr, who is currently an adviser to the N.H.L.P.A., is scheduled to make a presentation to hockey agents on Thursday.

And yet, from an image standpoint, the league’s unilateral action is a winner. The rule is a good one, if limited. Predatory players have been put on notice that Colin Campbell is waiting for them. That, too, is a good thing. And the league has painted itself as taking the initiative, even though it rebuffed the players on the same initiative a year ago.

In fact, the league looks so good that this morning on Toronto radio station The FAN 590, TV analyst Glenn Healy, the former N.H.L. goalie and former director of player affairs with the players association (who left when the current group of activist players running the association dismissed Paul Kelly as executive director) said of the new squabble, “This is getting like kindergarten stuff. I like what the league has done … they’ve done something, I think, that’s very proactive and positive. And it’s time for the players to respond and to get out of the sandbox, stop playing in the sandbox … and just do what’s right for the 750 members.”

In explaining the league’s motivation to LeBrun, Daly seemed to throw the player under the bus, saying, “Without trying to throw anyone under the bus here, let’s be real. This is a rule that’s intended to make the game safer for the players. It’s a no-brainer. The P.A. needs a hockey person, or at a minimum a player, who is willing to take charge, to step up and make a decision in the best interests of the game.”

That last sentence makes you wonder if the league office has some jitters that a baseball guy might end up as their adversary. It’s a strange thought coming from someone who was a football person and whose boss (Gary Bettman) was a basketball person.


News of Hockey

A Note to Readers

The News of Hockey column now appears in the main body of the blog as a regular post, allowing readers to comment on the post and other bloggers to link to it. Each daily post will be updated as appropriate throughout the day, expanding on existing items or adding new ones. Other regular posts like The Morning Skate, European Puck and The Junior Report will resume once the ice gets flooded later this month.

European League Leaders, 2009-10

League 1st place 2nd place top scorer top goalie
Russian K.H.L. (final) Salavat Yulaev Ufa, 129 of a poss. 168 pts. SKA St. Petersburg, 122 of 168 S. Mozyakin, SKA, 27+39=66 in 56 games P. Vehanen (from SM-liiga), Ak Bars, .935
Finnish SM-liiga (final) JYP Jyväskylä, 111 of 174 KalPa Kuopio, 109 of 174 J. Lehterä, Tappara, 19+50=69 in 57 J. Rynnäs, Ässät .929
Swedish Elitserien (final) HV71 Jönköping, 95 of 165 Linköpings HC, 92 of 165 M. Zuccarello Aasen, MODO, 23+41=64 in 55 J. Markström, Brynäs, .927
Czech Extraliga (final) HC Plzeň 1929, 106 of 156 PSG Zlín, 96 of 156 R. Červenka, Slavia, 30+43=73 in 50 S. Hovi, Brno, .930
Slovakian Extraliga (final) Slovan Bratislava, 117 of 141 Banská Bystrica, 96 of 141 M. Kuľha, Slovan, 23+35=58 in 43 B. Konrád, Slovan, .941
Swiss N.L.A. (final) SC Bern, 102 of 150 Genève-Servette HC 101 of 150 R. Robitaille, Lugano, 16+49=65 in 50 unavailable
German D.E.L. (final) Eisbären Berlin, 123 of 168 Frankfurt Lions, 98 of 168 J. Ulmer, Frankfurt, 37+37=74 in 56 J.-S. Aubin, DEG Metro Stars, .922

About Slap Shot

Slap Shot, the New York Times hockey blog, reports on the Rangers, the National Hockey League and anything that glides quickly across a frozen surface anywhere on the globe, from the snowy prairies of Saskatchewan to the frigid steppes of Russia and beyond, like, say, Phoenix.

Archive

Recent Posts

March 26

The Morning Skate: Rivalries and Head Checks Refuse to Fade Away

David Booth, the Florida player whose concussion sparked the movement to the brand new rule on blindside head checks, was felled again last night on a head check that remains legal.

March 25

N.H.L. Scoreboard: Rangers Win in 3-D; Caps Win in SO

Results from games of Wednesday, March 24.

March 25

There Are N.H.L. Teams in Canada? Really?

NBC might consider letting American audiences know there are N.H.L. teams in Canada.

March 24

The Morning Skate: N.H.L.’s Fast-Tracked Rule Change Skips a Stop

The N.H.L. Board of Governors approves the blindsided head shot rule without the approval of the Competition Committee.

March 23

N.H.L. Scoreboard: Big Wins for Hawks and Bruins

Results from games of Tuesday, March 23.

From the Sports Blogs

Bats
What Meeting? A-Rod Still in Tampa

Alex Rodriguez did not meet in Buffalo, as planned, with federal investigators. Instead, he batted cleanup against the Phillies.

The Quad
Live Updates From the N.C.A.A. Tournament's Round of 16

Live updates from Friday's Round of 16 games in the N.C.A.A. tournament.

Subscribe