Skip to content

Saturday, Feb 27th 2010


Kraft and The State of Advanced Capitalism

It was almost inevitable. Following Kraft’s acquisition of Cadbury, the US food giant has gone back on its guarantee not to close the Cadbury plant in Somerdale with the loss of 400 jobs. According to the BBC, Cadbury employs 4,500 people in the UK. Kraft has yet to announce plans for its Bournville factory in Birmingham and its head offices in Uxbridge but has already said it expects the takeover to result in “significant cost savings”.

Kraft typifies a more long-term trend in advanced capitalism where large multinational companies boost their profitability through vampire-like acquisitions of profitable companies. Last week The Guardian revealed how two major FTSE 100 companies were stockpiling capital to fund a major wave of acquisitions in the technology market. In the FT in September, however, Gavan Nolan reported that, ‘Kraft has a relatively large debt burden, and it is unlikely that it could increase the cash component [of its takeover offer] meaningfully without threatening its investment grade rating.’ This is because the company is currently £7bn in debt. To fund the acquisition of Cadbury it had to issue bonds worth $9.5bn (£6.06bn), raking in a nice sum, no doubt, for BNP Paribas, Citigroup, Deutsche Bank, HSBC and Royal Bank of Scotland, who managed the deal. Indeed, the investment bankers, lawyers, accountants and PR advisers racked up fees at a rate of more than £2m a day for their efforts. The fear now is that this debt will be unloaded on to Cadbury’s books, providing the rationale for a wave of job cuts and attacks on working conditions and pensions. Fears have already been raised that Cadbury will be the new Manchester United after spiralling debt threatened to hobble the club.

If we look at the long-term profitability of Kraft we see a definite downward trend over the last number of years. This time last year, for instance, Kraft was posted ‘fourth quarter profit losses of six per cent, despite higher volume sales of chocolate, biscuit and beverage brands.’ In other words, production of commodities has become increasingly unprofitable because as revenue increased, profits fell due to high costs of production.

The company said overall input costs for 2007 had increased by $1.3bn, with dairy costs in particular increasing 40 per cent. Prices for wheat, soyabean oil and cocoa now at “significantly higher levels than the 2007 costs”, Kraft added.

Net revenues for the quarter hit $10.4bn, a 10.9 per cent increase compared to the year before, but the cost pressure resulted in a 10 per cent decline in operating income.

For the full year, Kraft’s operating profit fell 15 per cent to $2.6bn, down from $3.06bn in 2006. Full-year revenue climbed 8.4 percent to $37.2bn from $34.4bn in 2006.

As we can see, share prices have begun to pick up against following the acquisition, a sign that investors anticipate higher profits to come. There are signs, however, that these post-acquisition profits of this sort will be at the expense of British manufacturing. Reading between the lines in a recent statement from Richard Lambert of the Confederation of British Industry and spokesperson for the industrial bourgeoisie, who warned against ‘making value-destroying acquisitions as Britain starts to emerge from recession.’ This is not surprising because manufacturing was hit hardest in Britain by the latest recession.

This phenomenon is a symptom of the subjugation of industrial capital to financial capital. Alfred Chandler, the business historian at the Harvard Business School, concentrated his work on the growth in ’scale and scope’ of industry, as companies since the beginning of the twentieth century became larger through mergers and developed into the modern corporation, with a management structure separated from its ownership-this process was noted much earlier by Marx in Vol. III of Capital as the ‘transformation of the actually functioning capitalist into a mere manager, administrator of other people’s capital, and of the owner of capital into a mere owner, a mere money-capitalist.’

Qualitative developments in the structures of the multinational corporation did not stop there, however. In response to the declining position of American industry throughout the 1960s and growing fears about the profitability of America’s core industries, mergers and acquisitions became a central preoccupation of American corporations. Nick Beams, citing figures from Chandler, notes that the number of such transactions grew from 2,000 in 1965 to more than 6,000 in 1969. This ‘third wave of mergers and acquisitions’ was then followed by a fourth wave in which short-term trading took on an ever greater significance to the profitability of corporations. Again to quote Chandler, ‘Before the acquisitions binge of the late 1960s, almost no investment banking house had merger and acquisition departments. Very soon such specialized departments became their banks’ largest money makers.’ The figures are pretty startling: in 1980 only 6 percent of corporate profits were realized in the finance industry. By 2005, the finance industry generated 40 percent of corporate profits.

As we have seen, banks such as RBS (which was less than 2 years ago bailed out by the taxpayer) are leading the charge for mergers and acquisitions and profiting handsomely from the fees involved in managing such deals. Moreover, the underlying impetus for the general trend of acquisitions is from the investor funds which own most of the stock in manufacturers such as Kraft, and who are in a desperate search for high returns for their investments. For example, the top shareholders in Kraft are all investment funds: Berkshire Hathaway, Inc. Investment Management, State Street Global Advisors, Capital Research Global Investors, Capital World Investors and BlackRock Global Investors. Behind these are likely to pension funds and sovereign wealth funds, as an interesting analysis from Phillip Inman explains.

The upshot since the Kraft bid was announced in September 2009 has been to push the FTSE 100 over the 5000 level for the first time since the Lehman Brothers collapse. We must not forget that these share price levels are not rising due to increased profitability of productive companies but of the profits of investors and the operations of banks using public money to fund acquisitions by predatory companies looking for a bargain. As a Citigroup note said: “Aggressive policy support and improving economic and corporate profit data have driven share prices higher. There will be many international investors casting their eye over UK and European companies at the moment, looking for a bargain.”

This points to a systemic crisis whereby the falling profitability of production is counter-weighed by the increased importance of fictitious capital and finance, leading to speculation, debt, and bubbles that inevitably burst. It is just like trying to keep a balloon in the air indefinitely without running out of breath. This much is evident from the long-term GDP growth levels since the 1960s. If we look at the G7 countries (minus Canada for the sake of visual clarity) taken together with the world average, the increasing periodicity of boom and bust cyclical movements is clear:


GDP Growth Rate

The following decades do not look rosy for the capitalist system, and for all of us who will be forced to sell our labour to survive within it. This latest wave of mergers and acquisitions will be a mere stopgap in the inexorable decline of the productive economy of the West, and the increasing volatility of the world economy will be symptomatic of a system increasingly unable to meet the material needs of humanity. In other words, the ‘monopoly of capital becomes a fetter upon the mode of production, which has sprung up and flourished along with, and under it.’ The Left need answers to this crisis and fast. To quote Rosa Luxemburg in her Junius pamphlet written during the savagery of World War One, ‘Friedrich Engels once said: “Bourgeois society stands at the crossroads, either transition to socialism or regression into barbarism.”‘ With imperialist wars in the Middle East not set to end any time soon, the spectre of global terrorism, environmental destruction and numerous humanitarian crises, we cannot afford the latter.

Discussion

We welcome and encourage lively discussion from the public about articles on Irish Left Review. You can leave a comment using the form at the bottom of the page. Please read through the existing comments before posting your own.

No comments so far

Leave a Comment

(required)

(required, will not be published)

Best of the Web

  • Juan Cole | Harvard Professor’s Modest Proposal: Starve the Gazans into Having Fewer Babies

    Cole dismantles Martin Kramer's astonishing claim that forcing the Palestinians to have fewer children by starving them would resolve the conflict between Israel and Palestine.
    "Martin Kramer revealed his true colors at the Herzliya Conference, wherein he blamed political violence in the Muslim world on population growth, called for that growth to be restrained, and praised the illegal and unconscionable Israeli blockade of civilian Gazans for its effect on reducing the number of Gazans.

    M. J. Rosenberg argued that Kramer's speech is equivalent to a call for genocide. It certainly is a call for eugenics."

    No comments »
  • Charity worker safe after mob’s adoption anger | Independent.ie

    Haitian's concerned about foreign nationals taking advantage of the catastrope in their country to take children - a justifiable concern - are described as an 'angry mob of Haitian men' when confronting an Irish female 'charity worker' (as opposed to an agent of a private adoption agency).
    "When we arrived at the airport we were surrounded by an angry mob of Haitian men," she told the Irish Independent. "They started getting very aggressive and were shouting at us. It was very scary, especially for the kids."

    No comments »
  • Shell Corrib Gas - Who are the real Thugs & Bullies? | Indymedia Ireland

    A number of high profile Shell to Sea campaigners including 'the Chief' Pat O'Donnell and Maura Harrington sought to appeal certain criminal convictions in cases heard last week at Castlebar Circuit Court from 9th - 11th February. A few of the appeals were successful but some of the convictions were upheld by the court.

    Also Facebook | Pat O'Donnell http://bit.ly/dyK5jh

    No comments »
  • Palestinian Avatar « Louis Proyect: The Unrepentant Marxist

    Bilin Reenacts Avatar Film A.K.A The Palestinian Avatar!

    No comments »
  • Sex, Lies, and Economics: The Amazing Story of Economics and Economists Before Adam Smith | Michael Perelman

    Michael Perelman provides some details and short excerpts from his current project a book which he hopes to publish called Invisible Handcuffs. It includes an incredible story of 17th Century economist William Petty, who:

    Besides having the distinction of being the first economist on record to have raised someone from the dead, [...] went on to become one of the dozen founders of the Royal Society, as well as a naval engineer, professor of music, scientist, inventor, assistant to Thomas Hobbes, cartographer, pioneer in public health and demography, member of Parliament, leader in the conquest of Ireland, an adviser to the King, and a notorious land pirate who accumulated hundreds of thousands of acres of confiscated Irish land.

    Proposal


    See Hugh Green’s post on William Petty’s economic proposal for Ireland. In fact, there are two Irish connections, as he talks about William Cantillon, of Kerry, too.

    No comments »
  • The real reason for the euromess | Paul Krugman

    For the truth is that lack of fiscal discipline isn't the whole, or even the main, source of Europe's troubles not even in Greece, whose government was indeed irresponsible (and hid its irresponsibility with creative accounting).

    No, the real story behind the euromess lies not in the profligacy of politicians but in the arrogance of elites specifically, the policy elites who pushed Europe into adopting a single currency well before the continent was ready for such an experiment.

    No comments »
  • Iceland’s fight for press freedom | Alda Sigmundsdóttir | Comment is free | guardian.co.uk

    I thought the idea of creating this sort of haven in Iceland – a country struggling with the exposure of massive amounts of corruption, not to mention a severely restricted media sector – was both novel and intriguing. It also seemed perfectly viable; not to mention vitally important.

    I had no idea, for instance, that even large, established newspapers routinely have gag orders placed on them and are required to water down or even pull stories. From what I understand this is particularly true of the UK, since the legal framework is very supportive of that sort of activity.

    No comments »
  • Proinnsias Breathnach | Competitiveness myths unsupported by the evidence

    "The preoccupation of many economists with labour costs as the key to export competitiveness is difficult to fathom given the minor role played by such costs in the overall cost structure of Ireland’s main export sectors. In manufacturing as a whole, labour costs amounted for just 15.5% of total direct costs of Irish manufacturing plants in 2006 (the latest year for which the relevant data are available in the Census of Industrial Production). This figure varies intersectorally, and ironically was lowest of all (at just 3%) in the office machinery and computers sector, which has experienced substantial loss of market share, while it stands at 18% and 22%, respectively, in pharmaceuticals and medical devices, our two most successful manufacturing export sectors in recent times. According to Forfás data, labour costs in foreign-owned service export firms (which account for the great bulk of service exports) were, at 10% of total input costs, even lower than in export manufacturing."

    No comments »
  • Iceland aims to become an offshore haven for journalists and leakers » Nieman Journalism Lab

    On Tuesday, the Icelandic parliament is expected to introduce a measure aimed at making the country an international center for investigative journalism publishing, by passing the strongest combination of source protection, freedom of speech, and libel-tourism prevention laws in the world.

    See: Icelandic Modern Media Initiative
    http://www.immi.is/?l=en&p=intro

    Supporters of the proposal say the move would make Iceland an “offshore publishing center” for free speech, analogous to the offshore financial havens that allow corporations to hide capital from authorities. Could global news organizations with a home office in Reykjavík soon be as common as Delaware corporations or Cayman Islands assets?

    2 comments »
  • Paul Mason | Greece: “The PIGS Fight Back”

    Paul Mason, Newsnight economics reporter, gives a low down of events on Wednesday.

    The question of the day is: will Germany and maybe France step forward to guarantee Greece’s future loans, allowing the cost of borrowing to fall and greater certainty that it will roll-over the debts in a couple of months time.

    “I will evade the question,” Mr Papaconstantinou warns me, before we begin, adding “tomorrow will be crucial”. Right now, in Paris, the Greek PM, Mr Papandreou, is meeting President Sarkozy. At tomorrow’s informal summit of EU leaders in Brussels, ringfencing the Greek crisis will be high on the agenda. Already the spreads on Greek debt - the geiger counter of instability - have fallen back in expectation of a deal.

    And

    - as the youths wearing pig’s head masks on the demo today were keen to point out - there are young people like them all across Southern Europe. Longer term it’s a contagious youth unrest from Thessaloniki to Lisbon that Europe’s leaders may have to watch out for: “The PIGS fight back,” said the banners today.

    Instead of a straight class divide this crisis has fuelled a more complicated generational one: older workers have been poor before and, some of them will privately admit, can survive being poor again. But for those in their early 20s to see all the aspirations fostered during the noughties cancelled indefinitely is a pretty hard pill to swallow.

    No comments »

Link Archives »