Knoxville's height would help if city were hit by a Nashville-like flood

  • Email
  • Discuss
  • Share »
  • Print
  • A
  • A
  • A

Editor's Note: An earlier version of this story incorrectly identified ownership of Barkley Dam.

TVA would struggle to control flooding in the face of a massive storm like the one that hit Nashville over the weekend, which the Army Corps of Engineers now describes as a 1,000-year flood event. But downtown Knoxville at least would have a height advantage over downtown Nashville, said Chuck Bach, general manager of TVA River Scheduling.

Although Fort Loudoun Lake's shore comes right up to Neyland Drive, the ground rises very steeply from there toward downtown and the University of Tennessee, he said, although Neyland Stadium and Thompson-Boling Arena are in close proximity to the water.

"If there was flooding on Neyland Drive, downtown is still up quite a bit from the river," he said. "Nashville, on the other hand, is right on the river."

Bach, who is in charge of managing the system of dams and reservoirs operated by TVA, said he is unaware of Knoxville ever facing a deluge like that Nashville just suffered.

Massive storms struck Tennessee and northern Mississippi over the weekend, killing nearly 30 people, at least 17 in Tennessee, and causing thousands of people to be evacuated.

Bach said the largest storms he can recall hitting East Tennessee over the last five or six years have left eight or nine inches of rain. More than 13 inches of rain fell over Nashville in a two-day period, causing the Cumberland River that winds through the capital city to overflow its banks. Neighborhoods and parts of downtown Nashville were flooded.

According to the Army Corps of Engineers, the flood that hit Nashville was a 1,000-year flood - an event that could be expected to happen once in every 1,000 years on average.

TVA is playing a secondary role in controlling the flooding in Nashville and Middle Tennessee. There are several dams on the Cumberland River, but none of them belong to TVA. They are operated by the Army Corps of Engineers, which has been providing updates on the flood through the website for its Nashville District.

According to a Tuesday press release, such a one-in-1,000 event presented a severe challenge to control.

"The Corps of Engineers is doing everything in our power to minimize flood damages, but the extreme and flash nature of this event makes some damages unavoidable," Lt. Col. Anthony Mitchell, commander of the Nashville District, said in a statement.

In another press release, Mitchell said the controlled release of water from Old Hickory Dam during the flooding actually prevented further flooding and loss of the dam. Water had reached a level of 451.4 feet behind the 452-foot-high dam, he said. Old Hickory Dam is on the Cumberland River about 25 miles north of Nashville.

"If we had allowed the lake to go to 452 and overtop Old Hickory Dam, the loss of that dam would have added another four feet to the flood levels in downtown Nashville," Mitchell said.

TVA has been working with the Corps of Engineers to help with flood control efforts by coordinating operation of the Corps' Barkley Dam and TVA's Kentucky Dam, Bach said. TVA also has eight non-power dams in West Tennessee that are helping control the flooding, he said.

While Knoxville's downtown would at least have some advantage over Nashville because of topography, Bach said there would be unavoidable flooding in areas if Knoxville was faced with rainfall on the order of what hit Nashville. Much would depend on the time of the year, where the rains actually fell, how short a time the rains fell and other factors, he said.

"I can't say the TVA system would be able to hold that much water because it depends on a lot of factors, but I can say we would be doing everything in our power to control the flooding," Bach said.

Business writer Ed Marcum may be reached at 865-342-6267.

Get Copyright Permissions © 2010, Knoxville News Sentinel Co.
Want to use this article? Click here for options!

  • Email
  • Discuss
  • Share »
  • Print

Comments » 11

angelsweb writes:

I hate to be picky, but Barkley Dam is a Corps of Engineers dam. TVA owns Kentucky Dam and the Corps of Engineers owns Barkley. They're a mile apart, and the spills from the two dams are now causing flooding downstream in Kentucky.

alfred writes:

If we get enough rain Knoxville will flood no matter what its height is.

flryan#600094 writes:

in response to alfred:

If we get enough rain Knoxville will flood no matter what its height is.

ok, that's like saying "if it gets cold enough, miami will get snow no matter how far south it is."

seyjetmon writes:

And you had better build an Ark if it gets to the top of Gay Street. I also believe I heard Tim Burchett say that if Knoxville flooded like Nashville that the water would be in Baptist Hospital which seems a bit far fetched but he is a politician or I could have misunderstood him.

hallsguy writes:

If Knoxville had that kind of rain,TVA would not have been able to control it with the lake at full pool as it is now.If it had been during winter pool it would not have been a problem.There are plenty of low areas of this town that border creeks that would flood.But it is unlikely that it would be as calamitous as Nashville.
The river system TVA controls should be viewed as like a bunch of bathtubs at varying elevations with the highest being the upper East Tn.lakes down to the lowest in Kentucky.If it backs up or floods here,TVA releases progressively ahead going downstream.The net result is it all winds up in the Ohio and then Mississippi which are un dammed below where the Tennessee meet them in Northwest Kentucky.When the Mississippi floods and it does at least once a year and often two and will be by now,it is only controlled by levees until it ends up in the gulf.All of the low areas are mostly farmland and flooding is good except when planting has been done.That is the tradeoff,farming along the Missisippi is very rich but risky.Memphis sits pretty much high up over the river but low areas of Memphis will flood.It is like the ocean when the Missisippi floods.

Apex writes:

I can't see the river ever getting high enough to flood downtown Knoxville. But if we ever do get a "Nashville like" flood, the folks along the middle and lower ends of Cherokee Blvd. are done for.

hallsguy writes:

in response to Apex:

I can't see the river ever getting high enough to flood downtown Knoxville. But if we ever do get a "Nashville like" flood, the folks along the middle and lower ends of Cherokee Blvd. are done for.

Correct as well as along Houser Rd.,Duncan's Landing, Peninsula Hospital,River Club,Jackson Bend,Mariner's Pointe,Montgomery Cove,Brixworth, to name a few others.
Rich,west Knox neighborhoods,in other words.

wallandhiker writes:

Does anyone know how Vanderbilt University fared in the flooding? I never saw any pictures of their campus on the news -- I hope it was spared the worst of it, but it is near downtown.

TwistedSister writes:

I wonder if Gay Street would "cave in"? Gay Street is basically build on top of another street. How would a flood affect that? Due to all the recent construction, I wonder how stable it really is.

devilsadvocate writes:

in response to TwistedSister:

I wonder if Gay Street would "cave in"? Gay Street is basically build on top of another street. How would a flood affect that? Due to all the recent construction, I wonder how stable it really is.

If the water level reached the sub-level of Gay Street, I guarantee we would have numerous and astronomically more pressing issues than that road caving in.

harrisr#247910 writes:

in response to angelsweb:

I hate to be picky, but Barkley Dam is a Corps of Engineers dam. TVA owns Kentucky Dam and the Corps of Engineers owns Barkley. They're a mile apart, and the spills from the two dams are now causing flooding downstream in Kentucky.

Thanks for bringing this to our attention. The story has been corrected.

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Business Profiles

Clicks & Coffee with Knoxnews.com
May 12th, 8:00 am at Peerless

Learn how to master the secret of search engine rankings and measure your return on investment. Enjoy breakfast and coffee with us, register to win free advertising and receive a complimentary Clicks & Coffee mug. Cost: $25.
RSVP by May 7th!

Contact Us

Video Tours

Alternative content

Powered By Digital Media Communications

Alternative content

Powered By Digital Media Communications

Alternative content

Powered By Digital Media Communications

Features